Eterniseed › Lessons › Teen

Teen · Week 11 · Wednesday

The Question of Divine Goodness

Habakkuk 1:12-17

Memory verse: Habakkuk 1:13

Setting the scene

Habakkuk's second complaint is sharper than the first. He begins by reciting what he believes about God: eternal, holy, his Rock, of purer eyes than to look on evil. Then he turns each affirmation into an indictment. If your eyes are too pure to look on evil, why are you watching Babylon swallow people more righteous than itself? The fishing imagery in verses 14-17 is chilling. Humanity is reduced to fish caught in Babylon's net, and Babylon worships its own net, that is, its own military power. Habakkuk is using the language of Israel's creeds against itself. This is sophisticated theology. He is not abandoning his beliefs about God; he is pressing them until they crack. The literary technique is called 'argument from the divine character' and it appears in Abraham bargaining over Sodom and in Moses pleading after the golden calf. Habakkuk stands in that tradition.

Character versus action

Today's theme is the gap between God's stated character and God's observed action. This gap is the engine of the entire problem of evil. A philosopher named Epicurus formulated it around 300 BC, and David Hume sharpened it in the 1700s: if God is all-good, all-knowing, and all-powerful, why does evil exist? Habakkuk arrived at the same trilemma centuries earlier, from inside the covenant rather than outside it. His version is more personal and more painful because he is not trying to disprove God. He is trying to recognize him.

In your world

Survivors of childhood abuse often describe the moment they realized the adults reciting religious language about love were the ones causing harm. The gap between stated character and observed action is not abstract for them. It is biographical. Any theology of evil that cannot speak to a survivor sitting in a therapist's office is not yet finished thinking.

Think about it

  • Which of the responses to the problem of evil listed above feels closest to what you have been taught? Which feels most honest to you, and are those the same answer?
  • Habakkuk uses what he believes about God to argue with God. Have you ever done that? What would it look like to argue with God using God's own promises?

Let’s pray together

Holy One, I have been told you are good, and I want that to be true. But I have watched things happen that I cannot square with goodness. I am not trying to insult you. I am trying to find you in what I see. Do not let me settle for a God who is only as good as my circumstances are easy. And do not let me give up on goodness just because it is hidden right now. Hold the question with me. Amen.