Teen · Week 13 · Wednesday
What Free Will Explains
Genesis 3; Romans 5:12
Memory verse: Romans 5:12
Setting the scene
Romans 5:12 is one of the most discussed verses in Christian theology. Paul writes that through one human, sin entered the world, and death through sin, and so death spread to all because all sinned. The verse is doing two things at once. It is making a historical claim, connecting the human condition to a primal rupture, and it is making an existential claim, that every human participates in that rupture by personal choice. Different traditions have read the verse differently. Augustine in the West emphasized inherited guilt. Eastern Orthodox theology emphasized inherited mortality and corruption rather than guilt. Most Protestants land somewhere between. What every reading shares is the conviction that moral evil is not a glitch in the system, not a leftover from animal evolution, and not God's fault. It is the consequence of free creatures using freedom against the good. This is what philosophers call the free-will defense, and it is the oldest Christian response to the problem of evil. It does not answer every question, but it answers a specific one with real force.
Moral evil and responsible agency
The free-will defense argues that moral evil, the evil humans do to one another, is the price of a creation containing real agents rather than puppets. It locates responsibility where Genesis and Paul locate it: with us.
In your world
Every modern conversation about accountability, whether about war crimes, abusive institutions, or your own apology to a friend, assumes that humans are responsible agents. Trauma-informed thinkers rightly remind us that responsibility is complicated by history, biology, and power. Yet even they do not abandon agency. They refine it. The biblical insistence on responsibility is not naive; it is the foundation of every justice movement you admire.
Think about it
- Where are you tempted to outsource responsibility for your choices to your circumstances, your wiring, or your past, and where is that outsourcing partly true?
- Does the free-will defense feel more convincing when you think about evil done by humans than evil that happens to humans, and why might that be?
Let’s pray together
Righteous God, we want freedom without responsibility and responsibility without freedom. We want to be praised for our virtues and excused for our cruelties. Teach us to own our part honestly. Where we have been harmed, give us courage to name it. Where we have harmed, give us courage to repent. Hold both truths in us at once. Amen.