Eterniseed › Lessons › Teen

Teen · Week 28 · Tuesday

Theft Hypothesis

1 Corinthians 15:3-4, Matthew 27:62-66

Memory verse: Matthew 27:64

Setting the scene

Matthew uniquely preserves the story of the guard at the tomb. The religious leaders, worried about a staged resurrection, ask Pilate for security. Pilate either grants them Roman soldiers or tells them to use their own temple guard; the Greek is ambiguous. Either way, the tomb is sealed and watched. The creed Paul quotes simply says Jesus 'was buried' and 'was raised,' but the gospels add the detail that the tomb was found empty. The earliest counter-explanation, recorded by Matthew himself, was already a theft theory: the disciples stole the body. This is historically significant. Even Jesus's opponents were not arguing that the tomb was full. They were arguing about why it was empty.

Testing the theft objection

An empty tomb on its own does not prove a resurrection. A body can go missing for many reasons. So historians weigh competing hypotheses. The theft hypothesis is the oldest and, on the surface, the simplest. Today we will examine it the way a careful thinker examines any claim: by asking what would have to be true for it to work, and whether those conditions actually hold.

In your world

In criminal investigations, detectives talk about 'inference to the best explanation.' You do not need certainty; you need the hypothesis that handles the most facts with the fewest extra assumptions. The same logic shows up in science, journalism, and medical diagnosis. Practice it on smaller things: when a friend tells you a story that does not quite add up, what would have to be true for their version to work? Train this muscle. It serves you in faith and outside it.

Think about it

  • Why do you think the earliest opponents of Christianity went with 'they stole the body' rather than 'the tomb was never empty'? What does that choice imply?
  • Is there a belief you currently hold — religious, political, or personal — that you have not stress-tested with counter-explanations? What would it cost you to try?

Let’s pray together

Jesus, I am learning that real faith is not afraid of hard questions. Keep me from lazy certainty and lazy doubt. When I want to dismiss something quickly, slow me down. When I want to believe something because everyone around me does, slow me down too. Let me be a person who tests things, not because I distrust you, but because I want to know you truly. Amen.