Eterniseed › Curriculum › Judges
Judges 9-10 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal study we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. This revered Wesleyan voice guides us through the turbulent record of Israel’s early judges with forthright Arminian clarity. Whedon’s careful exposition of Judges chapters nine and ten reveals both the perils of human ambition and the steadfast providence of God. His treatment calls us to sober reflection on leadership, covenant faithfulness, and divine judgment. As we listen, may the same Spirit who inspired the text illuminate our hearts for holy living.
Read
Let us now read aloud the full narrative of Judges chapters nine and ten. Hear the rise and ruin of Abimelech, the piercing fable of Jotham, and the quiet succession of Tola and Jair. Read slowly, allowing each verse to echo in the silence of your soul. Note the recurring themes of covenant breach and merciful deliverance. Permit the word to search and to comfort as the Spirit bears witness.
Study
Whedon opens by distinguishing the nature of Jotham’s discourse.
Verses 7-21. JOTHAM’S PARABLE, Judges 9:7-21 . The following beautiful apologue, commonly called the parable of Jotham, is rather a fable than a parable. The parable moves in the higher realm of spiritual thought. Its imagery is always taken from real life, and its narrative that which may have been objectively true, and often has its parallel in the history of man. See note, Matthew 13:3 . The fable is based on imaginary actions of irrational creatures or inanimate things, and can therefore never be true to actual life. It deals with talking trees and beasts, imagery which all know has no foundation in fact, but which may still serve a useful purpose in setting forth most suggestive and valuable lessons for the people. Such a fable is this discourse of Jotham, the oldest and one of the best apologues in the world.Whedon next identifies the bramble within the fable’s imagery.
Verse 14. 14 . All the trees Not one of all the trees was willing to be king, but all were willing that the bramble should rule over them a stinging reflection on the Shechemites. We understand Gideon and his sons, under the refusal of royalty, ( Judges 8:23 ,) to be represented by the olive and the vine, and Abimelech by the bramble. The bramble does not refuse to be king. Jotham sarcastically makes the bramble invite them to come under his shade, as an image of the felicity? of the Shechemites if they have done well in their choice. But if, as he believes, they have done wickedly, their bramble will prove a torch to burn their very cedars of Lebanon, the tallest of the Shechemite nobility. The bramble The word אשׂד , atad, occurs elsewhere only in Psalms 58:9 , where it is rendered thorns, and Genesis 50:10 , where it is rendered as a proper name. “It is generally thought to denote the southern buckthorn, a brier bush indigenous in Egypt and Syria, shooting up from the root in many branches, (ten to fifteen feet high,) armed with spines, and bearing leaves resembling those of the olive, but light coloured and more slender, with little whitish blossoms that eventually produce small, black, bitter berries. The Arabs still call it atad. Rauwolf found it growing at Jerusalem.” M’Clintock and Strong’s Cyclopaedia. From this same bush it is supposed the Saviour’s crown of thorns was made. Compare note on Matthew 27:29 .Whedon then expounds the divine sending of an evil spirit.
Verse 23. 23 . God sent an evil spirit Not merely “permitted jealousies to take place, which produced factions, but actually sent, or permitted to go, a personal evil demon, to generate discords among the Shechemites, and thus bring judgment on them for their wickedness. The Scriptures everywhere recognise a kingdom of darkness, as well as a kingdom of light; and it is contrary to reason and experience, as well as Scripture, to assume the impossibility of personal evil spirits having influence over the human soul. But these powers of darkness are held in check, and their agency is circumscribed, by the mightier power of God, who sometimes sends them, as a huntsman sends his dog after the game, by unbinding their powers and letting them loose to their own route. See note on Mark 5:13 . The evil spirit that troubled Saul came by permission and command of God, ( 1 Samuel 16:14 ,) and even Satan goes forth to afflict pious Job by permission of Jehovah. Job 1:12 ; Job 2:6 . Dealt treacherously The very men who had been so ready to make Abimelech king are the first to seek his overthrow.Whedon finally introduces the judges who followed Abimelech.
Verse 1. TOLA AND JAIR, Judges 10:1-5 . 1 . There arose In the providence of God. To defend Rather, to save Israel. No particular acts of Tola are recorded, but only the general statement ( Judges 10:2 ) that he judged Israel twenty three years. Hence it has been a question among the commentators, How did Tola save Israel? There is no record of any new oppressions, or of any special dangers. But the chief difficulty comes from assuming that there was no sense in which he might have saved Israel unless they had been in bondage to some foreign foe. He might have saved them from civil discords and fearful feuds by his wise and prudent judgments. He may have saved them from foreign invasions by a timely and prudent caution. We should also remember that the silence of Scripture respecting an individual is not sufficent ground for assuming that he did no mighty works.
Consider
Whedon presses the prophetic fulfillment of Jotham’s words.
Verse 20. 20 . Devour Abimelech The application transcends the fable itself. Not only shall Abimelech, the accursed bramble, kindle a fire to the destruction of many lords of Shechem, but also fires of revengeful judgment shall come out in fury from the latter, and devour Abimelech himself. All this, as the subsequent history shows, was a true prophecy. See Judges 9:49-57 .Whedon closes by marking the disgrace attending Abimelech’s death.
Verse 54. 54 . A woman slew him This was reckoned a terrible disgrace to a warrior. Like his next successor in Israelitish royalty, ( 1 Samuel 31:4 ,) he implored his armour-bearer to despatch him; but he did not thereby escape the dreaded ignominy, for the manner of his death was written in history, and long after familiarly associated with his memory. 2 Samuel 11:21 . And thus was ultimately fulfilled the prophetic curse of Jotham. “Much more beautiful is the otherwise tragical death of Saul. His attendant, influenced by reverence, refuses to kill him, and finally follows him in voluntary death. The songs of David celebrate Saul’s memory; but Abimelech’s epitaph is his brother Jotham’s curse.” Cassel.
Respond
1. Where in my own life do I see the temptation to grasp power that belongs to God alone?
2. How does the pattern of covenant mercy after judgment stir my hope for renewal?
3. In what ways am I called to defend the people of God through faithful, hidden service?
Pray
Gracious and sovereign Lord, we thank thee for the faithful witness of Daniel D. Whedon and for the searching light of thy word. Grant us grace to reject every bramble-king that would rule our hearts. Keep us steadfast in truth and integrity, lest we reap the bitter harvest of treachery. Raise up among us judges after thine own heart who will save thy people from discord and idolatry. May the fire of holy love consume every false refuge and the oil of thy Spirit anoint us for humble service. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →