← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel

1 Samuel 27-28 — with Whedon

1 Samuel 27-28Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal devotion and Arminian confidence in prevenient grace, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s careful exposition of 1 Samuel 27–28 invites us to trace the perilous paths of David and Saul with both historical honesty and spiritual watchfulness. His treatment underscores human frailty while pointing toward the steadfast mercy that sustains the believer amid trial. As we open these chapters, may the same Spirit who guided the ancient witnesses illuminate our reading and guard our hearts from despair or presumption.
Read
With reverent attention let us now read 1 Samuel chapters 27 and 28. Hear how David seeks safety among the Philistines and how Saul, forsaken by the Lord, turns in desperation to forbidden arts. Allow the narrative to speak plainly of fear, deception, and the solemn limits of divine patience. Pause after each section to let the weight of these events settle upon the conscience.
Study
Whedon opens by weighing David’s flight to Gath and the questionable measures that followed. Verses 1-4. DAVID AT GATH THE SECOND TIME, 1 Samuel 27:1-4 . David had now good reason to believe that his life would be in continual jeopardy as long as he remained in the land of Saul; and seeing in that monarch’s conduct so striking a display of human treachery and deceitfulness, he may have even felt that some of his own men might find occasion at some time to betray him into the hands of his enemy. But the method by which he sought to escape from danger was a very questionable one. Far better for him to have gone away into the wilds of Horeb, as did Elijah in the time of his persecution, and to have there awaited the death of his royal foe. Dr. A. Clarke’s comments on this wrong step in David’s life are not too strong. “There is not one circumstance in this transaction that is not blamable. David joins the enemies of his God and of his country; acts a most inhuman part against the Geshurites and Amalekites, without even the pretence of Divine authority; tells a most deliberate falsehood to Achish, his protector, relative to the people against whom he had perpetrated this cruel act, giving him to understand that he had been destroying the Israelites, his enemies. I undertake no defence of this conduct of David; it is all bad, all defenceless; God vindicates him not.” “This measure was calculated to alienate the affections of the Israelites, and to give credit to the slanders of his accusers; he thus ran himself and his men into the temptations to idolatry; and he laid himself under obligations to those whom he could never favour without betraying the cause of God.” Scott. He next surveys the long-standing difficulties surrounding Saul’s interview with the witch of Endor. Verses 3-25. SAUL’S DISTRESS, AND INTERVIEW WITH THE WITCH OF ENDOR, 1 Samuel 28:3-25 . Saul’s interview with the witch of Endor has ever been regarded as a subject beset with peculiar difficulties, and variously has it been explained. Justin Martyr and Origen held that by the incantations of the witch the spirit of Samuel actually appeared and conversed with Saul. Modern spiritism also affirms that the witch was a medium through whom the king of Israel received communications from the spirit of Samuel. But the majority of the older expositors, and some few moderns, believing it absurd for a holy prophet to be raised from the dead by the arts of witchcraft, regard the supposed apparition of Samuel as Satan personating that prophet. Whedon then presents the clairvoyant hypothesis as a coherent alternative to earlier interpretations. This is a kind of acquirement not sought for, except by those who mean to use it for deception, and therefore by most persons is but little understood. Let an individual of proper capacity make it a business to study the significance of every slight movement, intonation of voice, and expression of countenance, as criteria of concealed thoughts, and let this pursuit be prosecuted for years, under the incentives afforded by the love of gain or applause, or the fear of detection, and the tact thus acquired will be likely to develop results that appear almost incredible.” Dr. Austin Flint, (in Quart. Jour. of Psychological Medicine, July, 1869.) There is another, and, to our mind, more complete exposition of this subject, which we present in these notes. It assumes that the woman of Endor was a superior clairvoyant. All the parts of the narrative are so happily explained on this hypothesis as to evidence its probable correctness and worth.
Consider
Whedon presses the decisive objections that rule out an actual appearance of Samuel. Here, then, appears an insuperable difficulty we might well say, an utter absurdity to suppose that after Jehovah had refused to answer Saul by urim, by prophets, and by dreams, and had also, in his law, denounced the heaviest punishments against all forms of witchcraft, and had forbidden all resort to such as had familiar spirits, he would yet send Samuel from heaven to communicate with Saul through the agency of a miserable witch! Another difficulty is the character of the communication which is pretended to come from Samuel. It contains nothing worth sending a sainted prophet from heaven to tell; nothing which the witch might not, under the circumstances, have naturally and easily devised to awe and terrify the king. Its language, too, savours more of the spirit of witchcraft than of the spirit of divine revelation. See notes on vers. 15 to 19. The manner of Samuel’s appearance is also of a strange and suspicious character. He concludes by affirming the explanatory power of the clairvoyant reading for the entire account. We hope to show, by fair and worthy criticism, that upon this hypothesis the narrative before us is capable of a happy and consistent interpretation, and is relieved of the difficulties which attend the assumption of the actual appearance of Samuel.
Respond
Where in my present circumstances am I tempted to take refuge in schemes that compromise my witness? How does Saul’s refusal to wait upon the Lord warn me against seeking guidance outside the appointed means of grace? In what ways might I cultivate a steadier trust in God’s providence rather than yielding to fear-driven expedients?
Pray
Gracious and patient God, we confess how quickly fear can drive us from the path of simple trust. Keep us from the desperate measures that Saul embraced and from the compromises that shadowed David’s sojourn among the Philistines. Grant us instead a quiet confidence in thy providential care and a holy reverence for the boundaries thou hast set. May the study of these chapters deepen our reliance upon the Spirit’s guidance and upon the means of grace thou hast ordained. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →