Eterniseed › Curriculum › Matthew
Barabbas or the Lamb
Opening
A.B. Simpson’s writings on Matthew 27 open the judgment hall where the Innocent One stands accused. With reverent clarity he traces the testimonies that rise even from Christ’s enemies, pointing us to the Lamb who bears the curse in our place. His words invite us to linger at the cross where substitution and innocence meet, drawing the heart into deeper worship of Christ our Savior and Sanctifier. In the Holiness stream we hear again that the blood of the just One speaks better things than the imprecations of men, securing our hope until He comes.
Read
Turn now to Matthew 27 and read the chapter slowly. Let the scenes of the tribunal, the choice of Barabbas, and the silent Sufferer on the cross speak to your spirit. Ask the Holy Spirit to open the testimony of heaven and earth concerning the righteousness of Jesus, preparing your heart for the study that follows.
Study
Simpson leads us into Pilate’s judgment hall and the fateful choice between Jesus and Barabbas.
Brought before the tribunal of Pilate, that shrewd Roman could find no cause for His condemnation. But seeing that His accusers were bent on blood, he ventured on a compromise and suggested to them that he should release, as was the custom at the feast, some one person as a concession to the multitude and an act of clemency. In order to compel them, for decency’s sake, to consent to the release of Jesus, he puts as the alternative the release of Barabbas, who is called ‘“‘a notable prisoner.” This man seems to have been a very paragon of wickedness and his name was in the mouths of all as the most desperate of criminals. Pilate reckoned that they would not dare to ask for his life and so, with what he thought great adroitness, he placed the two horns of the dilemma before them and said, “Which will you have, Jesus or Barabbas?” To his consternation, the cry came back, ‘Not this man but Barabbas.” Rather would they set free the vilest of men than give up their hold upon Jesus Christ. Was there ever such a testimony to His innocence and to the spirit of His murderers?He then turns to the solemn warnings that reach Pilate from his wife and from heaven itself.
Both Pilate and his wife are compelled to give their testimony for the innocence of the Sufferer. From the very beginning Pilate knew that “For envy they had delivered Him,” but his perplexity was still greater when there came from his wife a pressing message, “Have thou nothing to do with that just man for I have suffered many things this day in a dream because of Him.” This was a solemn warning from the very heavens, and Pilate longed to yield to all these appeals to his sense of right and justice. But at heart he was a coward and at last he yielded to pressure, vainly thinking that he could shift the responsibility to their shoulders as he washed his hands before them and added one more testimony to the Lord, “I am innocent of the blood of this just person; see ye to it.” So from the very judgment seat of His enemies the testimony comes: Jesus Christ was righteous and died not for His own sins but for the sins of men.Simpson next contemplates the patient silence of the Sufferer before His accusers.
Is there a sublimer spectacle, is there a more heart-moving sight in all history, than that patient Sufferer standing in the judgment hall, or hanging upon the cross, and allowing His murderers to do their worst, answering not a word? — “led like a lamb to the slaughter, and as a sheep before her shearers is dumb, so He openeth not His mouth.” And the Holy Ghost, the Representative of Christ, is gentleness itself. He came upon Jesus as the Dove, and He dwells in us as a Monitor so kind, a Comforter so tender that we can only “grieve” and “vex ” Him, but we cannot make Him angry. He appeals to our obedience by His sensitiveness to the hurt that we can give Him. Oh, let us be gentle as He ; let us treat Him with the consideration that His sensitiveness should claim.
Consider
Simpson unveils the deepest secret of redeeming love as Christ stands in the place of Barabbas.
But back of all this story of substitution there lies the deepest, sweetest secret of redeeming love, namely: that Jesus Christ becomes the substitute from age to age for just such men as Barabbas; that He bore that day the shame, the wrath, the Cross, that the vilest of men deserved in order that the sinner might go free through His vicarious suffering.
Respond
1. Where in my life am I still tempted to echo the crowd’s cry, “Not this man, but Barabbas”?
2. How does the silent gentleness of Christ toward His murderers invite me to respond to the Holy Spirit’s quiet voice?
3. In what way does the substitution of the Innocent for the guilty deepen my hope in Christ’s return?
Pray
Lord Jesus, Lamb of God, we thank You for standing in the place of Barabbas and of every sinner who deserves the cross. Keep us from the cowardice that washes its hands of Your claims. Let the testimony of Your innocence ring in our hearts until we see You face to face. Sanctify us wholly by Your Spirit, and preserve us blameless until the day of Your appearing. May the love that bore our shame constrain us to live for You alone, our Savior, Sanctifier, Healer, and Coming Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →