← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › James

James 2 — with Whedon

James 2Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of the Methodist Episcopal tradition we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for a careful reading of James chapter 2. Whedon's Arminian-Wesleyan exposition illumines the apostle's call to consistent faith expressed in love toward rich and poor alike. His treatment guards against every antinomian evasion while upholding the royal law of liberty. As we listen, may the same Spirit who inspired the epistle grant us receptive hearts and obedient lives.
Read
Let us now hear the sacred text itself. With open Bibles we read James chapter 2 in full, attending to its unified exhortation against partiality and its insistence that living faith always bears the fruit of mercy. May the words of the inspired apostle settle deeply within us as we prepare to study them with Whedon's guidance.
Study
Whedon opens by treating the prohibition of respect of persons within the Christian synagogue. Verses 1-4. 3 . No obsequiousness to rich incomers to the Christian synagogue, 1-4. 1 . My brethren The apostle is still administering lessons to the Synagogue of believers. In the first chapter he reproves their disputatiousness; in the present, their courting the rich . Of glory Omitting the Italic words, the Greek order is, our Lord Jesus Christ of glory , in which the author does not suppose that inserting the identifying name Jesus Christ prevents of glory from belonging to Lord, so as to make Lord of glory , namely, Jesus Christ . Faith in so glorious a Lord is not in consistency with respect of persons . Respect of persons (see note on Acts 10:34 ,) means to regard a man for his rank, personal appearance, or any other reason than his true deserts or value. All men are equal before the Lord of glory ; and therefore, in his Church, rich and poor are equally valuable in the sight of Him who died for all. He next unfolds the apostle's argument that God has chosen the poor to be rich in faith. Verse 5. 4 . For the rich are generally persecutors and blasphemers , James 2:5-7 . 5 . Hearken… brethren In this earnest expostulation ( James 2:5-7 ) St. James makes two points: 1. The poor are the chosen , and so wrong is done to them. 2. The rich are the oppressors and blasphemers, and so a wicked preference is given to them. Chosen The (aorist) tense, Did not God choose? that is, (Gr. middle,) prefer for himself. The objects of his choice present three objective characteristics; they are poor in worldly goods, but (antithetically) rich in faith , and even heirs (heightening the antithesis) of a future royalty. The very nature of the antithesis shows the inadmissibility of Huther’s interpolating (followed by Alford) the words to be, and reading, chosen to be rich in faith . This to be, might just as authoritatively be interposed before poor , and so render, has not God chosen them to be poor? The worldly poverty, the spiritual richness, and the celestial heirship, all precede this choice, which is simply the divine preference in contrast with this, their human, rejection in the synagogue. God chose, but men (next verse) despised them. The kingdom The future kingdom of heaven, as being yet subject of promise. Whedon then addresses the antinomian refuge of workless faith and its inconsistency with apostolic doctrine. Verses 14-26. 6 . The Christian synagogue rejects workless faith as unjustifying, James 2:14-26 . St. James now inflexibly chases his brethren out of their last refuge and excuse for their sin toward the poor . Our works, say they, do, indeed, violate the law a little, but then we are justified by faith, and the law will not punish us for subordinate negligences. In other words, we are Christians, and will be saved in spite of our sins. This is antinomianism; and it often appears in various forms, practical and doctrinal, in the Church. Its effect is, as St. Paul says, to “make Christ the minister of sin,” and to demoralize Christianity. In his Epistle to the Romans Paul emphasizes the doctrine of justification by faith alone; yet guards against all antinomianism by insisting that it is a faith from which a holy life must result. Romans 6:1-2 . St. James, on the contrary, emphasizes the necessity of works that is, a holy life but secures the fact that the works, in order to be a true holy life, must spring from a living faith. Paul says, You are justified by a work-begetting faith; James says, You are justified by faith-begotten works. They disagree, not in doctrine, but in the emphasis they lay on the different parts of the doctrine. Finally he shows how genuine faith is evidenced and completed by corresponding works. Verse 18. 18 . May (wisely) say That is, the advocate of works evidencing his faith , may say to the mere holder of faith without works , thus. Show… without… works And prove thyself an antinomian. And I… faith by… works And prove myself a duty-doing believer. I hold faith and duty in correspondence and symmetry with each other. My faith inspires my works , and my works evidence my faith . Works are rightly said to justify a man by evidencing his faith. Yet this is not all. Works are a direct justification of faith before God. According to Paul it is by the act of submitting and self-consecrating faith alone that a man comes into reconciliation and justification with God. But the condition of the continuance of that state of justification is not faith alone, but faith with works correspondent to that faith. And those works justify, not only indirectly, as evidence of the trueness of the faith, but directly, being graciously accepted by God as works of righteousness and true holiness.
Consider
Whedon presses the harmony between James and Paul on justification. And thus we are justified by works. And yet this is not precisely the view that St. James in this paragraph presents. Huther places in contrast the words of the two apostles thus: James says, “By works a man is justified, and not by faith only.” ( James 2:24 .) Paul says, ( Galatians 2:16 ,) “A man is not justified by the works of the law, but by… faith.” Again, James, ( James 2:21 ,) “Was not Abraham… justified by works?” and Paul, ( Romans 4:2 ,) “If Abraham were justified by works, he hath whereof to glory.” In regard to which we remark: (1.) James does not here, or any where else, deny, but does assume, that we are justified by faith. (2.) Nor does he deny that it is faith which alone, and in itself, justifies; he only denies that the faith which alone justifies is ever alone and unattended by works. (3.) He concludes by affirming the epistle's corrective authority against every antinomian misreading of Paul. That there was a standing antithesis, without real contradiction, between Paul and James, is evinced by the “from James” of Galatians 2:12 , (where see note, with our note on Acts 15:6 ;) and we believe that antithesis is here stated, and was, on James’s part, intentional and wise. (5.) How truly James’s statements do stand as a perpetual corrective of the antinomianism often inferred from Paul’s language in successive periods of the Church, is well illustrated by Wesley’s experience with the Moravians, given in our vol. iv, p. 209. So antinomian had they become by implicitly following Luther and overstraining Paul, that he took to expounding James to bring them to the right position.
Respond
Where in our assemblies or daily dealings do we still show subtle preference for the outwardly impressive? How does the royal law of liberty expose any claim to faith that leaves mercy undone? In what concrete act of love is the Spirit now prompting us to let our faith become perfect through works?
Pray
Gracious Lord of glory, we thank thee for the faithful witness of thy servant James and for the clear light shed upon his words by Daniel D. Whedon. Grant us grace to receive the poor as thou hast received us, and to let no partiality stain the fellowship of thy Son. May the faith we profess be ever accompanied by the works of love that alone prove it living. Keep us from every antinomian evasion and bind our hearts to the royal law of liberty. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →