Eterniseed › Curriculum › Apology of the Augsburg Confession
Apology — Of Both Kinds in the Lord’s Supper — Book of Concord
Opening
Today we turn to the Apology of the Augsburg Confession and its article titled Of Both Kinds in the Lord’s Supper. This section of the Lutheran Confessions defends the full use of the Sacrament as Christ gave it. It speaks directly to the faith and practice of the Church, showing why both bread and wine belong to the entire people of God. The article matters because it guards the integrity of Christ’s testament and comforts those whose consciences have been burdened by human restrictions. As we listen, we hear the Reformers plead for fidelity to the Lord’s own institution rather than later customs or rulings.
Read
Now read the article Of Both Kinds in the Lord’s Supper from the Apology of the Augsburg Confession. The text rests chiefly on 1 Corinthians 11, along with references to Luke 24, Acts 2 and 20, 1 Samuel 2, and Ezekiel 7. Let the words of the Confession guide your meditation on why both kinds were given to the whole Church and what that means for faithful reception today.
Study
The Confession opens by addressing the institution of both parts.
It cannot be doubted that it is godly and in accordance with the institution of Christ and the words of Paul to use both parts in the Lord’s Supper. For Christ instituted both parts, and instituted them not for a part of the Church, but for the entire Church. For not only the presbyters, but the entire Church uses the Sacrament by the authority of Christ, and not by human authority; and this, we suppose, the adversaries acknowledge. Now, if Christ has instituted it for the entire Church, why is one kind denied to a part of the Church? Why is the use of the other kind prohibited? Why is the ordinance of Christ changed, especially when He Himself calls it His testament? But if it is not allowable to annul man’s testament, much less will it be allowable to annul the testament of Christ. And Paul says, 1 Cor. 11:23ff, that he had received of the Lord that which he delivered. But he had delivered the use of both kinds, as the text, 1 Cor. 11, clearly shows.It next presents further testimony from Scripture and early custom.
This do [in remembrance of Me], he says first concerning His body; afterwards he repeats the same words concerning the cup [the blood of Christ]. And then: Let a man examine himself, and so let him eat of that bread and drink of that cup. [Here he names both.] These are the words of Him who has instituted the Sacrament. And, indeed, he says before that those who will use the Lord’s Supper should use both. It is evident, therefore, that the Sacrament was instituted for the entire Church. And the custom still remains in the Greek churches, and also once obtained in the Latin churches, as Cyprian and Jerome testify. For thus Jerome says on Zephaniah: The priests who administer the Eucharist, and distribute the Lord’s blood to the people, etc. The Council of Toledo gives the same testimony. Nor would it be difficult to accumulate a great multitude of testimonies. Here we exaggerate nothing; we but leave the prudent reader to determine what should be held concerning the divine ordinance [whether it is proper to prohibit and change an ordinance and institution of Christ].The Confession then turns to the claims made by the adversaries.
The adversaries in the Confutation do not endeavor to [comfort the consciences or] excuse the Church, to which one part of the Sacrament has been denied. This would have been becoming to good and religious men. For a strong reason for excusing the Church, and instructing consciences to whom only a part of the Sacrament could be granted, should have been sought. Now these very men maintain that it is right to prohibit the other part, and forbid that the use of both parts be allowed. First, they imagine that, in the beginning of the Church, it was the custom at some places that only one part was administered. Nevertheless they are not able to produce any ancient example of this matter. But they cite the passages in which mention is made of bread, as in Luke 24:35, where it is written that the disciples recognized Christ in the breaking of bread. They quote also other passages, Acts 2:42,46; 20:7, concerning the breaking of bread.It continues by examining additional arguments offered in the Confutation.
And consider their impudence. Gabriel recounts among other reasons why both parts are not given that a distinction should be made between laymen and presbyters. And it is credible that the chief reason why the prohibition of the one part is defended is this, namely, that the dignity of the order may be the more highly exalted by a religious rite. To say nothing more severe, this is a human design; and whither this tends can easily be judged. In the Confutation they also quote concerning the sons of Eli that, after the loss of the high-priesthood, they were to seek the one part pertaining to the priests, 1 Sam. 2:36 (the text reads: Every one that is left in thine house shall come and crouch to him for a piece of silver and a morsel of bread, and shall say, Put me, I pray thee, into one of the priest’s offices (German: Lieber, lass mich zu einem Priesterteil) that I may eat a piece of bread ]. Here they say that the use of one kind was signified. And they add: “Thus, therefore, our laymen ought also to be content, with one part pertaining to the priests, with one kind.”
Consider
The Confession closes its treatment by weighing the excuses given for the prohibition.
They also allege the danger of spilling and certain similar things, which do not have force sufficient to change the ordinance of Christ. [They allege more dreams like these, for the sake of which it would be improper to change the ordinance of Christ.] And, indeed, if we assume that we are free to use either one part or both, how can the prohibition [to use both kinds] be defended? Although the Church does not assume to itself the liberty to convert the ordinances of Christ into matters of indifference. We indeed excuse the Church which has borne the injury [the poor consciences which have been deprived of one part by force], since it could not obtain both parts; but the authors who maintain that the use of the entire Sacrament is justly prohibited, and who now not only prohibit, but even excommunicate and violently persecute those using an entire Sacrament, we do not excuse. Let them see to it how they will give an account to God for their decisions.
Respond
How does receiving both kinds strengthen your confidence that the whole Sacrament is meant for you? In what ways might human traditions still threaten to limit the gifts Christ freely offers? What steps can you take to treasure the Lord’s testament exactly as He gave it?
Pray
Lord Jesus Christ, You instituted the Sacrament of Your body and blood for the entire Church and commanded its use in both kinds. Keep us steadfast in this Your testament and guard us from every human ordinance that would diminish what You have given. Comfort all who have been denied the fullness of this gift and restore to Your people the complete Supper You ordained. By Your Spirit grant us worthy reception of both bread and wine, that we may be joined to You and strengthened in faith. We ask this for the sake of Your mercy. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →