Eterniseed › Curriculum › Genesis
Genesis 43-44 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal devotion and Wesleyan emphasis on Scripture's plain sense and sanctifying power, we open Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Across Genesis 43-44 the venerable exegete traces the brothers' second descent into Egypt, the steward's careful provisions, and the climactic appeal that prepares the way for reconciliation. Whedon's notes illuminate both the historical customs of the Nile court and the sovereign providence that bends every fear toward mercy. May the same Spirit who guided the patriarchs guide our reading today.
Read
With hearts ready to receive both warning and consolation, let us read Genesis chapters 43 and 44 in a single attentive sitting. Notice the mounting tension as the brothers return, the careful etiquette at Joseph's table, and the sudden reversal that brings Judah to the fore. Read slowly, allowing the narrative's pathos to search the conscience and awaken hope in the God who works all things together for good.
Study
Whedon comments on Judah's address to his father.
Verse 8. 8 . Judah said The eloquent plea of Judah seems to have had more weight with Jacob than the expressed wishes of all his other sons .Whedon explains the Egyptian customs observed at the meal.
Verse 32. 32 . For him by himself He thus maintained his distinction of rank and caste, and conformed to Egyptian ideas and customs . Egyptians might not eat bread with the Hebrews Herodotus (ii, 41) says: “No Egyptian, man or woman, will kiss a Grecian on the mouth, or use the knife, spit, or caldron of a Greek, or taste the flesh of a pure ox that has been divided by a Grecian knife . ” This same fear of contamination was doubtless held with regard to other nations as well as the Greeks . The Egyptians held in abomination those who slaughtered cows and oxen, animals which they held in highest reverence . Hence it was that they despised shepherds . Genesis 46:34 .Whedon introduces Judah's moving appeal to Joseph.
Verse 18. 18 . Judah came near and said Nothing in all literature surpasses this appeal of Judah in behalf of his brother and his father . It is remarkable that he makes no attempt to deny the charge of taking the cup; he makes no plea of innocence, but assumes, in utter helplessness through other sins, that God was in all this discovering the iniquity of himself and his brethren. Luther says: “I would give very much to be able to pray to our Lord God as well as Judah here prays to Joseph.” Kalisch observes: “Judah, the lion, could never degrade his dignity by an outburst of impotent rage; the tempest of his feelings was checked by controlling reason, and the chaotic confusion of his emotions gave way to manly composure and lucid thought. Stepping forward towards the inexorable man with the courage and modesty of a hero, he delivered that address which is one of the masterpieces of Hebrew composition.
Consider
Whedon reflects on the eloquence and power of Judah's speech.
It is not distinguished by brilliant imagination, or highly poetical diction; its inimitable charm and excellence consist in the power of psychological truth, easy simplicity, and affecting pathos. It possesses the eloquence of facts, not of words; it is, in reality, scarcely more than a simple recapitulation of past incidents; but the selection, arrangement, and intrinsic emphasis of the facts produce an effect attainable only by consummate art. The deep and fervent love of the aged father for his youngest son forms the center, round which the other parts of the speech, the allusion to Joseph, to Rachel, and to the struggle of the brothers before their departure from Canaan are skilfully grouped. Jacob would never survive the loss of Benjamin; and if the brothers returned without him, they would see their father expire in agony before their eyes.… Could Joseph still remain unmoved? One trait more completed the victory over his heart.
Respond
1. Where in my own life has fear of past sins kept me from trusting God's present mercy? 2. How might the Spirit be using present trials to expose and heal old rivalries within my family or community? 3. In what concrete way can I offer myself as surety for another, reflecting the intercession of Christ?
Pray
Gracious El Shaddai, who once led the sons of Jacob through famine and fear, lead us still. Grant us the humility of Judah, ready to bear another's burden rather than repeat old wrongs. Cleanse our hearts of envy, and teach us to honor one another according to the measure of grace given. May the same providence that turned a silver cup into an instrument of testing now turn our trials into testimonies of Thy faithfulness. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, who ever lives to make intercession for us, amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →