Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel
1 Samuel 27-28 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Today we enter the tense final days of Saul's reign and David's years of refuge among the Philistines, drawing wisdom from Haydock's Catholic Family Bible Commentary. This treasured compilation gathers centuries of Catholic insight to help readers see both the historical events and their moral and spiritual weight. As the narrative moves from David's careful diplomacy to Saul's forbidden consultation, Haydock's notes guide us through questions of prudence, divine judgment, and the mystery of the afterlife. May this study strengthen our trust in God's hidden providence.
Read
Take time now to read 1 Samuel chapters 27 and 28 slowly and prayerfully. Notice David's delicate position with Achis, his raids on Israel's enemies, and Saul's desperate search for guidance after Samuel's death. Let the contrast between David's resourcefulness and Saul's despair prepare your heart for the commentary that follows.
Study
Haydock opens by addressing David's prudent decision to seek protection.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Hands. God requires that we should act with prudence. (Du Hamel) --- David probably consulted the Lord, and sent ambassadors to Achis, before he went into his dominions, (Menochius) where he had been in such danger before. (Du Hamel)On the length of David's stay, the commentary notes:
Months. Hebrew, "days and four months." The former expression denotes a year; though some would have it, that David remained "four months and a few days" in the country. He probably continued so many months at Geth, (ver. 9, 11,) and about a year at Siceleg. (Calmet) --- Septuagint have "days, four months;" and Salien adopts that term. (Haydock) See chap. xxix. 3. (Du Hamel)Haydock then examines David's campaigns against neighboring peoples.
Pillaged Gessuri, &c. These probably were enemies of the people of God; and some, if not all of them, were of the number of those whom God had ordered to be destroyed; which justifies David's proceedings in their regard. Though it is to be observed here, that we are not under an obligation of justifying every thing that he did: for the Scripture, in relating what was done, doth not say that it was well done. And even such as are true servants of God, are not to be imitated in all they do. (Challoner) --- The nations of Chanaan, who inhabited as far as Egypt, and the Amalecites, who had escaped the arms of Saul, were devoted to destruction, Exodus xvii., &c. In such cases, any man might fall upon them, without any other formal declaration of war. (Calmet) --- There was another Gessuri of Syria, in the tribe of Manasses, across the Jordan. (Menochius) --- The country which these people inhabited, to the south of Palestine, was afterwards depopulated by the kings of Egypt and of Syria, in their continual wars, so that many of the cities which are mentioned in Scripture, were never known to profane geographers. (Calmet) --- St. Jerome, (Trad.) Sa, and others, think that David attacked some of the Philistines. But it is as probable at least that he would abstain from molesting them, whom had so generously afforded him an asylum. Salien concludes, that he did not attack the other nations, (except the Amalecites, who were sufficiently marked out for destruction, Deuteronomy xxv. 19,) without consulting the Lord, by the high priest, as he was accustomed to do in every difficulty. (Salien, the year of the world 2979) (Menochius) --- They all dwelt in part of the land of Chanaan, (Worthington) which was sufficient. (Haydock)
Consider
For doctrinal reflection on the events at Endor, Haydock considers the appearance of Samuel.
Understood that it was Samuel. It is the more common opinion of the holy fathers, and interpreters, that the soul of Samuel appeared indeed; and not, as some have imagined, an evil spirit in his shape. Not that the power of her magic could bring him thither, but that God was pleased for the punishment of Saul, that Samuel himself should denounce unto him the evils that were falling upon him. See Ecclesiasticus xlvi. 23. (Challoner) --- The passage is decisive; (Tirinus) he slept and he made know to the king, and shewed him the end of his life, and he lifted up his voice from the earth, in prophecy, &c. Those who have called in question the reality of Samuel's apparition, seem not to have remembered this passage. (Haydock) --- Yet his soul was not united to his body, (Salien) nor was he adduced by the power of the devil, but (Du Hamel) by a just judgment of God, to denounce destruction to the wicked king. (St. Augustine, &c.) (Tirinus) --- The woman, beholding Samuel, fled out of the place, to Saul's companions, and left him alone with the king, ver. 21. --- Adored Samuel with an inferior honour, as a friend of God, exalted in glory. (Salien) --- That Samuel really appeared, is the more common opinion of the fathers. (St. Augustine, Cura. xv.) (Worthington)
Respond
How does David's careful prudence challenge or encourage your own decisions in uncertain times?
Where do you see the difference between seeking God's will and resorting to forbidden means?
What does this passage invite you to surrender more fully to divine providence?
Pray
Lord of hosts, you guided David through exile and protected your people even when kings faltered. Grant us the prudence to act wisely and the faith to trust your word alone. Keep us far from every form of superstition and turn our hearts to you in every trial. May the example of Saul's downfall remind us to remain faithful, and may David's patience strengthen our hope. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →