Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Timothy
1 Timothy 4 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of the Methodist Episcopal tradition we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. With forthright Arminian clarity Whedon expounds the apostolic charge given to Timothy, warning against apostasy while exalting the gospel of the incarnate Christ. His words guide us to receive every created gift with thanksgiving and to pursue godliness with disciplined zeal. As we open the fourth chapter of First Timothy, may the same Spirit who spoke through Paul still speak to the Church today.
Read
Let us now hear the sacred text itself. With open Bibles and attentive hearts we read First Timothy chapter four, listening for the Spirit’s explicit warning and the apostle’s charge to guard both doctrine and life. May the words of Scripture prepare us to receive Whedon’s faithful exposition.
Study
Whedon opens by setting the paragraph within its larger context.
Introduction. The 1 Timothy 4:1-10 are a continuation of paragraph beginning 1 Timothy 3:14 , and should be read with it as one piece. But 1-3 is a counter picture to 1 Timothy 3:15-16 , especially. They are a contrast of the Church of apostasy versus the Church of faith; the truth of the incarnation opposed by the errors of Gnosticism.He next addresses the particular ascetic errors named by the apostle.
Verse 3. 3 . Some of their particular tenets are now specified. They present the ascetic side of Gnosticism as distinguished in our note on 2 Thessalonians 2:7 . Jude and John deal with the licentious side. Hence Paul imputes to the leaders not so much sins of the flesh, as sins of the spirit. Their sin consisted in an apostasy from the Christian faith, and the formation of a spiritual influence, power, and ultimate despotism, based upon the diffusion of an austere and oppressive superstition among the people. Forbidding to marry From an ascetic view of the sinfulness of matter an exaggerated estimate of a virgin life was propagated. This same view among the Christian Gnostic heretics rejected the real manifestation of Christ in the flesh , maintaining that his was a body in appearance only, and condemned by 1 John 4:3 , as antichrist. A matter-condemning celibacy was antichrist, because it condemned the incarnation.Whedon then distinguishes the conditions under which abstinence is to be condemned or commended.
Is good Is not the mere effect of physical laws, but the product of a good Creator, who pronounced them good at the creation, and is good for its purpose, if we can find what its true purpose is. Nothing to be refused From a wise and temperate use. Yet our apostle, in perfect consistency, was ready for a total abstinence from meats through his whole life if it were necessary to save his brother. Asceticism or abstinence is to be condemned: 1. When it is based on such idea of the sinfulness of matter as condemns the incarnation. 2. When it is used by us as a penance, or atonement, for our own sin, as if we might thereby be justified or pardoned. 3. When it is assumed to be a meritorious act, winning for us the divine approbation, as if God were gratified by our suffering. 4. When it tends to diffuse a gloomy and superstitious view of God and religion among men, instead of a benevolent, cheerful, practical, good-doing piety.
Consider
On the universal offer of salvation he presses the decisive point.
Verse 10. 10 . And our acceptance of this value is clear for, therefore ; that is, for the reason now to be given. Labour and suffer reproach Things far more serious than exercise . Namely, because . The Saviour Alford says: “So far as salvation stands in him, he is the Saviour of all men. And it is by virtue of this universality of salvation offered by God that we have rested our hopes on him.” Specially of those that believe Alford adds: “In these (that believe) alone does that salvation which God has provided become actual. He is the same Saviour, towards and of all: but these alone appropriate his salvation.”Finally he lays the warning directly upon Timothy and every minister.
Verse 16. 16 . Warning: Take heed unto thyself Paralleled by save thyself ; as to the doctrine is paralleled by them that hear . There is danger for thyself ; for it is not the mere office of the ministry that will save thyself . Great heed even for thee is necessary to insure the final reward. Doctrine is teaching, preaching, publicly putting forth of thought. Only by heed , care, earnest purpose, can hearers be saved by it.
Respond
1. Where in my life am I tempted to treat God’s good creation as defiled rather than received with thanksgiving?
2. How am I training myself in godliness as earnestly as an athlete trains for the games?
3. In what ways am I heeding both the doctrine and my own walk so that I and those who hear me may be saved?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank Thee for the clear witness of Thy Spirit through the apostle and for the faithful labors of Thy servant Whedon. Keep Thy Church from every doctrine of demons and from every superstition that dishonors the incarnation. Grant us to receive Thy gifts with joyful gratitude, to labor and suffer reproach for the gospel, and to give ourselves wholly to the sacred work. Save us and those who hear us, through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →