Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Maccabees
1 Maccabees 7-8 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
The seventh and eighth chapters of First Maccabees trace a decisive shift in the struggle for Jewish independence. After the death of Antiochus Epiphanes, Demetrius escapes Roman custody and seizes the Seleucid throne, installing compliant officials who resume the campaign against Judas and his followers. The narrative records both the treachery of Alcimus and the temporary success of Nicanor before turning to Judas’s diplomatic overture to Rome. These events illustrate the interplay between political ambition, religious fidelity, and the search for reliable allies. Readers encounter the cost of misplaced trust when the Assideans accept Alcimus’s assurances, as well as the prudent recognition that even powerful empires can serve divine providence. The chapters therefore prepare the community to weigh military resistance against negotiated security while remaining anchored in the covenant.
Read
Read First Maccabees 7–8 in the Douay-Rheims or Catholic Public Domain Version. Notice how Demetrius consolidates power and dispatches Bacchides with Alcimus, whose false promises lead to the slaughter of the Assideans. Observe the repeated pattern of deceitful negotiations by Nicanor and the swift reversal at Adasa. Pay attention to the priests’ prayer for the king even while under threat, and to the detailed portrait of Roman institutions that prompts Judas to seek a treaty. Note the contrast between the Romans’ disciplined governance and the instability of the Seleucid court.
Study
Haydock’s commentary supplies historical detail that clarifies the motives of the principal actors and the character of the Roman republic at the time of the embassy.
The opening account of Demetrius’s escape from Rome supplies the political backdrop for the renewed persecution described in chapter 7.
Rome. He had been a hostage instead of Epiphanes, who usurped his throne, chap. i. 11. After the death of the latter, the senate sent three legates to administer the kingdom, during the minority of Eupator. One of them was slain. The king and Lysias sent to exculpate themselves, but received no satisfactory answer. Demetrius thought this a proper opportunity for regaining the throne. He consulted the historian, Polybius, who advised him to depart privately. He, however, addressed the senate for leave, and being refused, fled with eight attendants to Tripoli, and thence to Apamea. His rivals durst not attack him, as he pretended to be sent by the Romans. The army of Eupator seized their king and Lysias, and put them to death. (Polybius cxiv., and cxxii.; Josephus; Calmet) — Seleucus and Epiphanes were brothers; and of course Demetrius was cousin to Eupator, (Worthington) and the lawful heir of Seleucus. (Haydock)Alcimus’s irregular claim to the high priesthood explains why the Assideans initially trusted him yet ultimately suffered betrayal.
Alcimus. He occupied the place of Menalaus, and would be high priest, but that office was held by the Machabees. (Worthington) — Eupator had slain Menalaus, as being too turbulent. Onias IV ought to have been recognized; (Calmet) but he fled into Egypt, and there built a temple. Lysias advised the king to select one from a family of less power. Alcimus was such, though of the posterity of Aaron, ver. 14. (Josephus, Antiquities xii. 5., and xiii. 6., and xx. 8.) — He had fallen under Epiphanes, and the Jews would not receive him.The career of Nicanor illustrates the Seleucid strategy of alternating diplomacy and force, culminating in his defeat near Jerusalem.
Enemy. He was one of the most terrible: yet Judas at last slew him, ver. 43., and 2 Machabees xv. 28. (Worthington) — Nicanor was high in the king's favour, and had fled with him from Rome. (Josephus, Antiquities xii. 17.) — He first sent three ambassadors to Judas, in answer to what Simon had proposed; and peace was concluded. Alcimus hereupon accused Nicanor, and the king sent him an order to seize Judas. While he was endeavouring to comply, Judas escaped. He was again much exposed; (ver. 29.) and therefore collected his army, and fought near Jerusalem, 2 Machabees xiv. 15. (Usher, year of the world 3842.) (Calmet)The description of Roman power and policy accounts for Judas’s decision to pursue an alliance that would protect religious liberty.
Romans. Many historians, Livy, Plutarch, &c., record the same. (Worthington) — Things. Greek, "people who join them." (Haydock) — They comply with their just requests. (Menochius) — The Scripture speaks of the fine times of the republic and gives this temporal reward to the virtues of the Romans, which they so greatly sought, and to which alone they were entitled. (Calmet) — "Hitherto, says Florus, the Roman people were beautiful, noble, pious, holy, and magnificent." The Jews, first among the eastern nations, employed their friendship to secure their liberty. Facile tunc Romanis de alieno lagrientibus, Just. xxxvi.
Consider
The text presents a community caught between a hostile monarchy and an emerging republic whose virtues the sacred writer records without endorsing every later development. Judas recognizes that fidelity to the law sometimes requires prudent engagement with foreign powers, yet the same chapter warns against the illusions that arise when leaders accept assurances from men like Alcimus. The priests continue to offer sacrifice for the king even while Nicanor threatens the temple, demonstrating that intercession for civil authorities need not imply approval of their policies. Rome’s ordered liberty, free of the envy that later fractured its senate, offered a temporary shield; the alliance therefore served the immediate goal of survival without supplanting reliance on divine deliverance. These episodes invite reflection on the proper limits of political calculation within a life ordered to covenant fidelity.
Respond
How does the example of the Assideans caution against placing confidence in leaders whose profession of shared faith masks contrary intentions? In what ways might contemporary Catholics distinguish between necessary cooperation with civil authorities and the risk of compromising the integrity of worship?
Pray
Lord of hosts, you guided your people through seasons of exile and restoration; grant us the discernment to recognize trustworthy counsel and the courage to reject deceitful promises. We give thanks for the historical insight preserved by the commentator whose work gathers earlier witnesses to the sacred text. May their careful attention to the record of Rome’s early discipline and the Seleucid court’s intrigues continue to illuminate the choices that confront believers today. Strengthen the leaders of your Church to seek alliances that safeguard the freedom to worship while trusting ultimately in your mighty hand. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →