Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Maccabees
1 Maccabees 7-8 — Eterniseed (Catholic with deuterocanon)
Opening
The seventh and eighth chapters of 1 Maccabees carry the reader from the close of the religious persecution into the long shadow of the dynastic struggle for the Seleucid throne and the first formal contact between the Maccabean state and the rising power of Rome. The book here changes register from war of conscience to war of politics, and the Church receives these chapters as a school of the prudent governance that follows upon the won freedom of religion. Demetrius the First Soter, the legitimate Seleucid claimant, escapes from Rome and seizes the throne; the Hellenized high-priestly party in Jerusalem appeals to him through their representative Alcimus; the Syrian general Bacchides and then Nicanor are sent against Judas; and Nicanor falls at the battle of Adasa, his body desecrated as he had desecrated the priests at the temple, and his head and right hand hung up in Jerusalem as a public sign of the day called Nicanor's Day, the thirteenth of Adar, instituted by the Maccabean community as an annual commemoration. The eighth chapter then sets forth in detail the embassy of Judas to Rome and the treaty of friendship and military alliance that the Roman senate granted to the Jewish nation. The Church reads this development with attention to the irony only later visible: the Rome that received Judas' embassy in friendship would within a hundred years become the imperial power that, having destroyed the second temple and dispersed the Jews, would itself bear the Christian gospel to the ends of the earth.
Read
Read 1 Maccabees chapters 7 and 8 with attention to the political textures and the longer historical arcs. In chapter seven, attend to the escape of Demetrius Soter from Rome and his seizure of the Seleucid throne; the embassy of Alcimus and the renegades to the king; the appointment of Alcimus as high priest; the false treaty by which Alcimus first reassured the Hasidim and then betrayed them, killing sixty pious Jews in a single day; the dispatch of Bacchides; the subsequent dispatch of Nicanor and his arrogant boast against the temple; the assembly of Judas' army at Adasa; Nicanor's death in battle; the desecration of his corpse as he had desecrated the priests; and the institution of Nicanor's Day on the thirteenth of Adar as an annual feast. In chapter eight, attend to the reputation of Rome among the nations as Judas had heard it; the catalog of Roman virtues and achievements as the inspired author presents them; the embassy that Judas sent under Eupolemus son of John, son of Accos, and Jason son of Eleazar to Rome; and the formal Roman treaty of friendship and military alliance, the text of which the inspired author preserves in his book.
Study
The seventh chapter of 1 Maccabees deserves attention not only for the military narrative of Nicanor's defeat but for its sober portrait of the persistent danger of intra-Jewish division that the religious persecution had largely masked. With Antiochus Epiphanes the enemy was clearly external; with Demetrius and Alcimus, the enemy is the apostate Jew himself, the Hellenizing high-priestly party that sought political legitimacy from the Seleucid throne. Alcimus is presented with notable theological seriousness: he is described as having defiled himself in the time of the persecution, having sought the office of the high priesthood through the influence of a foreign king, and having sworn falsely to the Hasidim that he would not harm them only to violate his oath and put sixty pious men to death in a single day. The Fathers from Saint Cyprian onward have read the figure of Alcimus as a perennial type of the bishop or priest who, having compromised himself in time of trial, seeks rehabilitation through political alignment with the persecuting power, and whose subsequent oath-breaking discloses the moral disorder that compromise had introduced into his soul. The Catholic moral tradition has been severe about the breaking of solemn oaths sworn under religious form; Saint Thomas Aquinas in the Summa devotes the lengthy treatise on the virtue of religion in II-II questions 80 through 100 to the nature and binding force of vow, oath, and adjuration, and Alcimus' violation of his sworn pledge to the Hasidim falls under precisely the species of perjury that Aquinas regards as the most grievous form. The figure of Nicanor by contrast is presented as the proud Gentile officer whose arrogance against the temple precedes his fall. The text records his stretching out his hand in pride toward the sanctuary and his profane oath that he would burn it to the ground; it then records his death at Adasa, the cutting off of his head and right hand — the hand he had stretched out — and the hanging of them in public Jerusalem. The Maccabean community instituted the thirteenth of Adar as Nicanor's Day, an annual commemoration, and the rabbinic tradition preserved its observance into the Talmudic period. The Church has not adopted Nicanor's Day into her own liturgical calendar, but the principle of liturgical remembrance of deliverances given to the people of God in particular historical crises is one she has preserved and extended — every parish patronal feast, every commemoration of a city's preservation from plague or invasion, every Te Deum sung in thanksgiving for a particular grace, is the spiritual descendant of the Maccabean instinct to bind historical deliverance into the liturgical year. The eighth chapter on Rome is one of the most poignant passages of the Old Testament for the Christian reader. The inspired author, writing in the late second century before Christ, presents Rome to his Jewish audience with admiration: he records the Roman victories over the Gauls, the conquest of Spain, the campaigns of Scipio Africanus against Carthage, the defeat of Antiochus the Third Megas at Magnesia, the management of the kingdom of Macedon, and the careful Roman practice of bestowing kingdoms upon allied kings without themselves wearing crowns. He praises the Roman political form — the senate of three hundred and twenty members, the single annual chief magistrate, the absence of envy and rivalry among the leaders. He records the diplomatic embassy of Judas under Eupolemus and Jason and the formal treaty of friendship and military alliance that the senate concluded with the Jewish nation. The Church reads this chapter with an irony that the inspired author could not have foreseen: within a hundred years the Roman armies under Pompey would walk into the temple of Jerusalem and within two hundred and thirty years the armies of Titus would burn it to the ground. Within three hundred years the same Roman power would put to death the very Messiah promised to the Jewish people, and within four hundred years the persecutions of Roman emperors would have produced the Christian martyrs whose blood would seed the conversion of the empire. The very Rome that Judas embraced in friendship would become the great enemy and then the great convert and then the great mother of the Church that bears Saint Peter's name. The Fathers from Saint Augustine onward have meditated on this transformation as a particular instance of the long providential pattern by which the powers of this world are first received by the people of God in friendship, then suffered as enemies, then folded into the wider communion of the universal Church.
Consider
Consider Alcimus the apostate high priest as the perennial type of compromised religious authority. The Catholic tradition has been steady about the danger that confronts the bishop or priest who, having compromised in a previous trial, seeks rehabilitation through political alignment with the persecuting power. This temptation is not the temptation of the laity but the particular temptation of the clerical state, and the Church has preserved canonical procedures of penance and demotion precisely to prevent the kind of unaddressed compromise that produces Alcimus. Where in your reading of the Church's recent history do you see traces of the same temptation? Consider too Nicanor's arrogance and the Maccabean response of liturgical commemoration. The instinct to bind a particular deliverance into the liturgical year is deeply Catholic. Does your parish or family preserve any such annual remembrance — a Te Deum on a particular date for a particular grace given, a Mass of thanksgiving for a healing or a return, a commemoration of an answered prayer? The Maccabean instinct is not dead in the Church; it has only sometimes been forgotten by individual households. Consider finally the embassy to Rome and the long providential irony. The very power that the Maccabean state embraced in friendship would one day destroy the second temple and bear the gospel to the ends of the earth. Where in your own life are you treating as friend or as enemy a power whose deeper providential role you cannot yet see?
Respond
Identify one significant deliverance from your own life — a healing, a reconciliation, a vocational opening, a danger averted — and institute for yourself or your household a small annual commemoration of it. It may be a Mass offered on the anniversary, a special prayer at family dinner that day, a renewal of a particular charity. Bind the memory of grace into the year, after the Maccabean instinct.
Pray
Almighty and eternal God, who in the days of Judas Maccabeus delivered your people from Nicanor's arrogance and gave them the instinct to bind that deliverance into the annual remembrance of their year, give to your Church the same liturgical memory of every grace you have given her. Where compromised authority within her has sought rehabilitation through political alignment with the persecuting power, restore the order of penance and conversion that the office of bishop and priest requires. By the intercession of the Maccabean martyrs and of every saint who has resisted the temptation of Alcimus, and through the prayers of the Blessed Virgin Mary, mother of the Church in every age of her trial, sustain in us the long providential vision that sees in the powers of this world both their present hostility and their future possible conversion. Through Christ our Lord, who lives and reigns with you in the unity of the Holy Spirit, one God, forever and ever. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.