Eterniseed › Curriculum › Judges
A Way Out of the Impasse: Wives for Benjamin and the Longing for the True King
Opening
The book of Judges closes upon a tangle. Benjamin has been all but destroyed, only six hundred men surviving at the rock Rimmon; and Israel, in the heat of its anger, had sworn a great oath that none of them would give a daughter in marriage to a Benjamite. Now their wrath has cooled, and they grieve that a whole tribe should be blotted out of Israel; yet the oath binds them, and they will not be forsworn. Blessed Theodoret of Cyrus answers the plain question of how the survivors of Benjamin came to have wives at all. Because all the women of their tribe had been slain, he explains, and the others had sworn not to give them their own daughters, they devised, lest the Benjamites be forced to bring in foreign wives from the nations round about, a way out of their difficulty: at the yearly feast in Shiloh, when the daughters of the city came out to dance, the surviving men of Benjamin were told to seize them for wives. So the tribe was preserved, neither by breaking the oath outright nor by mingling with the heathen, but by this strange contrivance born of necessity. Theodoret keeps to the sober history; but the very disorder of this ending — a people patching together a hard solution to a self-made impasse, in days when, as the book has told us again and again, there was no king in Israel — sets before us, by its sheer brokenness, the longing for the true King who alone can gather and heal His people.
Read
Read Judges 21 — the men of Israel had sworn in Mizpeh, "There shall not any of us give his daughter unto Benjamin to wife." Now they come to the house of God and weep sore, saying, "O Lord God of Israel, why is this come to pass… that there should be to day one tribe lacking in Israel?" They find that none of Jabeshgilead had come up to the assembly, and send to smite it and bring four hundred young virgins for the survivors of Benjamin; but these are not enough. So they take counsel: "there is a feast of the Lord in Shiloh yearly." They charge the Benjamites, "Go and lie in wait in the vineyards; and see, and, behold, if the daughters of Shiloh come out to dance in dances, then come ye out of the vineyards, and catch you every man his wife of the daughters of Shiloh." It is done; the Benjamites take wives for themselves of the dancers, and return to their inheritance, and rebuild their cities, and dwell in them. And the book ends with the word it has sounded throughout: "In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes."
Study
Theodoret answers the question the chapter raises: how did the remnant of Benjamin come by wives, when Israel had sworn not to give them their daughters? The cause was twofold — the women of their own tribe were gone, and the oath stood fast:
Because all the women of their tribe had been slain, and they themselves had sworn not to give them their daughters in marriage. The danger this raised was that Benjamin, finding no wives within Israel, would be driven to take them from the surrounding nations, which the Law forbade. To prevent that, the contrivance of the seizure was devised:
Therefore, lest they be compelled by necessity to bring in foreign wives, they found a way out of their difficulty and devised the seizure. Theodoret states the same a second way, that we may see the people's bind clearly:
The women of their tribe had all been slain, but they themselves had sworn not to betroth their own daughters to them. So the tribe of Benjamin was kept from being blotted out — but only by an expedient born of necessity, the last awkward act of a nation with no king.
Consider
Theodoret keeps to the plain sense, and the plain sense is itself the sermon. Here is a people who would not be forsworn and would not marry into the heathen — and these are real goods, a reverence for the oath and a horror of mingling with idolaters — yet who can hold those goods together only by so strange a device as commanding the seizure of dancing girls at a feast. Theodoret names it plainly for what it was —
they found a way out of their impasse and devised the seizure. It is a solution that solves, and yet leaves us uneasy; a knot cut rather than untied. And that is exactly the note on which the book of Judges chooses to end, with its refrain ringing once more: "there was no king in Israel; every man did that which was right in his own eyes." The whole book has been a descent — deliverers raised up and falling away, idols set up beside the tabernacle, a tribe nearly destroyed, and now a nation improvising its way out of a self-made impasse. The very shape of it is a question the book cannot answer from within: who will gather this scattered, self-willed, half-faithful people and make them whole? Israel's later answer was a king in Jerusalem; but the deeper answer the Church has always heard is the true King, Christ. For only He can keep together the goods that fall apart in our hands — mercy and truth, justice and faithfulness — for in Him "mercy and truth are met together; righteousness and peace have kissed each other" (Ps 85:10). Where we cut knots by hard expedients, He unties them by His Cross; where we improvise to save a remnant, He gathers His scattered people from the ends of the earth and loses none that the Father has given Him. The broken ending of Judges is not the last word; it is a door left open, a longing left unfilled, until the King should come who does in His people what is right in the eyes of God.
Respond
Do not despise the days of "no king." The end of Judges is a sober mirror of any life, and any age, that tries to be good without a true King within — keeping some real goods, honouring some real boundaries, yet forever improvising, cutting knots, patching together hard solutions to impasses of its own making. You may, like Israel, hold fast to an oath and shun what is forbidden, and still find your life a tangle, because something is missing at the centre: a King to reign over the will and gather what is scattered. The lesson of the whole book, sounded one last time at its close, is the need that only Christ can fill. So let Him be King over you. Bring Him the knots you cannot untie — the binds of your own making, the goods you cannot seem to hold together — and let His wisdom do what your contrivances cannot. Where you have been doing simply what is "right in your own eyes," ask instead what is right in His. And trust His gathering. He does not save a remnant by stealth and necessity, as Israel saved Benjamin, but draws His scattered people to Himself in love, willing that not one should be lost. The book of Judges ends with a longing; let your own heart answer it, opening the door to the King who has come, and saying with the whole Church, "Even so, come, Lord Jesus."
Pray
O Lord our God, who in the days when there was no king in Israel didst preserve even the remnant of Benjamin, that no tribe might be blotted out from among Thy people: I bless Thee that Thy mercy reaches to the last and the least, and that Thou wilt not let perish what Thou hast purposed to save. We are a people forever improvising, cutting knots we cannot untie, holding hard to some goods while our lives remain a tangle, because we have sought to do what is right in our own eyes and have lacked the true King. Reign Thou over me, O Christ; gather what is scattered in me; untie by Thy Cross the knots that my own contrivances only tighten; and hold together in me the mercy and the truth, the justice and the faithfulness, that fall apart in my hands. Thou who dost gather Thy scattered people from the ends of the earth and losest none that the Father hath given Thee, gather me also, and make me whole. The book of Thy old judges ended in longing; let my heart's longing find its rest in Thee. To Thee, O Christ our God, the true King who healest Thy people, with the Father and the all-holy Spirit, be glory now and ever, and unto ages of ages. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →