Eterniseed › Curriculum › James
James 3 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of the Methodist Episcopal tradition we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for a careful reading of James chapter 3. Whedon's Arminian-Wesleyan exposition guides us through the apostle's warnings against the untamed tongue and the call to heavenly wisdom. His treatment reminds us that true faith bears fruit in controlled speech and peaceable conduct. As we listen, may the same grace that tames the tongue also order our hearts. This lesson invites both learners and teachers to examine themselves before the Lord of wisdom.
Read
Let us now hear the word of God in James chapter 3. As the passage is read aloud, attend to the apostle's images of the bridle, the rudder, and the little fire. Notice how the tongue is set forth both as a source of blessing and a fountain of cursing. Ask the Spirit to search your own speech and to plant within you the wisdom that is from above. Read slowly and reverently, allowing the text to expose and to heal.
Study
Whedon opens by situating the apostle's caution within the Christian synagogue.
Verse 1. 7 . Christian synagogue, also, rejects many teachers with untamable and self-contradictory tongues , James 3:1-12 . 1 . My brethren Our apostle’s standpoint is still in the Christian synagogue, where he is checking the errors and faults of his brethren . In the last chapter he reproved their obsequiousness to rich incomers, and refutes their excuses; he here checks their ambitious loquacity, aiming to be teachers before they had become competent learners. In James 1:19-26 he had criticised rather the garrulity of hearers and answerers; he here reprehends the assumptions of the speakers. Masters Rather, teachers. This did not forbid the expression of Christian experience and interchange of exhortation and counsel by the many . Nor did it forbid catechists and imparters of the elements of established Christian knowledge to be many .He next unfolds the requirement of controlling the tongue for the one who would be a teacher.
Verse 2. 2 . For In explanation of the greater condemnation . We offend Literally, we stumble. The Greek word is cognate with the Greek word to fall, and they are finely distinguished by St. Paul, Romans 11:11 , where he says that Israel has not stumbled that they should fall . (A Greek proverb, “not to stumble twice at the same stone.”) All The mere English reader is very apt to understand our translation to mean, we offend every body; making all the object. The true meaning is, that in many things we all stumble; that is, make intellectual and moral mistakes and blunders; which is true enough of the wisest and holiest of us. And, therefore, our apostle cautions us to avoid setting up for too much. Offend not Stumble not. In word In performance of his assumption to be a teacher in the synagogue. Perfect man He has become in mind and spirit what he doubtless has in body a completely grown, filled out, and proportioned man . Able also For, so far as he is able to speak perfectly right, it is probable that he can do perfectly right. The wisdom and moral power with which he can govern his tongue is very likely to govern his whole body . The body , as the whole organ of the soul, with its susceptibilities to temptation, and its limbs as the instruments of right or wrong, as the I, the will, directs.Whedon then presents the true test of wisdom through meekness and good conduct.
Verse 13. 8 . True test of teachers and hearers a heaven-descended wisdom, evinced by rectitude and peacefulness of temper and life , James 3:13-18 . 13 . Who Of these contrasts be sure to exhibit the right one. Wise man Truly on the side of divine wisdom ; the wisdom of James 1:5 . Let him show Like a good fountain let him pour forth the sweet and not the bitter stream; like a good tree, the right fruit. What the good fruits are he now tells. Conversation Conduct, mode of life. Works Special good doings. Meekness The opposite of the tongueiness of the many teachers. Wisdom The wisdom of the just. If there be among you a professed Christian let him come out of an equivocal state, half holy and half wicked, and let him, both by general life and special act, show the Christian tempers.
Consider
On the untamable tongue he presses the necessity of divine grace.
Verse 8. 8 . Tongue can no man tame Augustine says, that never, but by the grace of God, has any tongue been tamed. It may be replied that worldly self-interest often tames the tongue as effectually as divine wisdom. As to that, however, it may be asked, To what does worldly prudence tame the tongue? And it may be answered, It tames the tongue to a subdued but still wild and depraved state. Nothing but the grace of God tames the tongue to that docility to which our apostle alludes, submission to the divine law, and the hearty utterance of a holy confession.Finally he concludes with the harvest of righteousness sown in peace.
Verse 18. 18 . Fruit… is sown By fruit is meant the harvest, crop, or product; and this is virtually sown in the seed that produces it. Fruit , consisting in righteousness , not fruit produced by righteousness . And this fruit , namely, righteousness , springs from a seed-sowing in the soil of peace by them that make or enact peace . The man of holy peace sows that seed in peace which brings forth righteousness . Thus in holy eloquence does St. James appeal to his fellows of the twelve tribes , both Christians and those who should be Christians, among whom strifes of tongue arising from bitterness of heart were producing sin and ruin, to seek for righteousness in the paths of holy quietude and peace. In an angry age his warnings were slighted, and the ruin resulted in the destruction of their capital and the overthrow of their State.
Respond
1. In what areas of speech do you most need the grace that alone can tame the tongue? 2. How does the wisdom from above differ from the wisdom that produces strife in your daily conversations? 3. Where is the Lord calling you to sow seeds of peace so that righteousness may be the harvest?
Pray
Gracious Lord, we thank thee for the light of thy word and for the faithful labors of thy servant Daniel D. Whedon. Grant us now the grace that alone can subdue our tongues and order our thoughts. Deliver us from the earthly, sensual, and devilish wisdom that breeds envy and confusion. Fill us instead with the wisdom that is first pure, then peaceable, gentle, and full of mercy. May our mouths bless thee without ceasing and speak no curse upon those made in thy image. Sow in us the peace that brings forth the fruit of righteousness. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →