← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Luke

Luke 23 — with John Calvin

Luke 23John Calvin's Commentaries20 min
Opening
In this daily lesson we turn to John Calvin's careful exposition of the events surrounding Christ's trial and condemnation. Calvin's insights illuminate the depths of human sin and the sovereign purposes of God even in the darkest hours of the passion narrative. As we follow his verse-by-verse treatment of Luke chapter 23, we are invited to see both the gravity of the betrayal and the wonder of divine providence at work. Calvin's words guide us through the morning council, Judas's remorse, and Pilate's reluctant verdict, always pointing us back to the heart of the gospel. May this study deepen our reverence for the Savior who stood in our place.
Read
Prepare your heart to hear the sacred text of Luke chapter 23. Read slowly through the account of Jesus before Pilate, the accusations of the leaders, and the transfer to Herod. Allow the narrative to unfold without hurry, noticing the tension between earthly powers and the silent King. As you read, ask the Spirit to open your eyes to the fulfillment of prophecy and the cost of our redemption. Take time to linger over the words that describe Christ's composure amid injustice.
Study
Calvin opens by clarifying the timing of the council's final decision. Matthew 27:1. But when it was morning. The high priest, with his council, after having examined him at an unseasonable hour of the night, finally resolve, at sunrise, to place him at the bar of the governor. By so doing, they observe the form of judicial proceedings, that they may not be suspected of undue haste, when they run to Pilate at an unusually early hour, as usually happens in cases of tumult. But it is probable, that when Christ had been led away from their council, they immediately held a consultation, and, without long delay, resolved what they would do; for we have been already told at what time Christ went out from them and met Peter, which was after the cock-crowing, and just as day was breaking. The Evangelists, therefore, do not mean that they removed from the place, [239] but only relate, that as soon as it was daylight, they condemned Christ to death, and did not lose a moment in earnestly putting into execution their wicked design. What Luke formerly stated, (22:66,) that they assembled in the morning, ought not to be explained as referring to the very beginning, but to the last act, which is immediately added: as if he had said, that as soon as it was day, our Lord having acknowledged that he was the Son of God, they pronounced their sentence of his death. Now if they had been permitted to decide in taking away life, they would all have been eager, in their fury, to murder him with their own hands; but as Pilate had cognizance of capital crimes, they are constrained to refer the matter to his jurisdiction; only they entangle him by their own previous decision. [240] For the stoning of Stephen (Acts 7:59) took place in a seditious manner, as happens in cases of tumult; but it was proper that the Son of God should be solemnly condemned by an earthly judge, that he might efface our condemnation in heaven. On Judas's response Calvin writes: He says that Judas repented; not that he reformed, but that the crime which he had committed gave him uneasiness; as God frequently opens the eyes of the reprobate, so as to begin to feel their miseries, and to be alarmed at them. For those who are sincerely grieved so as to reform, are said not only (metamelein), [241] but, also (metanoein), [242] from which is derived also (metanoia), [243] which is a true conversion of the soul to God. So then, Judas conceived disgust and horror, not so as to turn to God, but rather that, being overwhelmed with despair, he might serve as an example of a man entirely shut out from the grace of God. Justly, indeed, does Paul say, that the sorrow which leads to repentance is salutary, (2 Corinthians 7:10;) but if a man stumble at the very threshold, he will derive no advantage from a confused and mistaken grief. What is more, this is a just punishment with which God at length visits the wicked, who have obstinately despised his judgment, that he gives them up to Satan to be tormented without the hope of consolation. Calvin next examines the priests' reaction to the blood money. 4. What is that to us? Here is described the stupidity and madness of the priests, since even after having been warned by the dreadful example of Judas, still they do not think about themselves. I do acknowledge that hypocrites, as they are accustomed to flatter themselves, had some plausible excuse at hand for distinguishing between their case and that of Judas; for they did not think that they were partakers of his crime, though they abused the treachery of Judas. But Judas not only confesses that he has sinned, but asserts the innocence of Christ; from which it follows, that they had meditated the death of a righteous man, and, therefore, that they were guilty of a detestable murder. Nor is there any room to doubt that God intended to sear their consciences with a hot iron, to discover the hidden corruption. Let us therefore learn, that when we see wicked persons, with whom we have any thing in common, filled with alarm, those are so many excitements to repentance, and that they who neglect such excitements aggravate their criminality. We ought also to believe, that the crime of one man can have no effect in acquitting all those who are in any way involved in it; and still more, that the leading perpetrators of a crime can gain no advantage by distinguishing between themselves and their agents, that they may not suffer the same punishment. Turning to Pilate's verdict, Calvin writes: Luke 23:4. And Pilate said to the chief priests and scribes. As Christ was come to bear the punishment of our sins, it was proper that he should first be condemned by the mouth of his judge, that it might afterwards be evident that he was condemned for the sake of others, and not for his own. But as Pilate, from a dread of exciting a tumult, did not venture absolutely to acquit him, he willingly availed himself of the opportunity which presented itself, of submitting him to the jurisdiction of Herod. This Herod was he who bears the surname of Antipas to whom was left the tetrarchy of Galilee, when Archelaus was a prisoner at Vienna, and when Judea had been annexed to the province of Syria. Now though we shall shortly afterwards find Luke relating that this mark of respect pacified Herod, who had formerly been enraged against Pilate, still his design was not so much to obtain Herod's favor, as to get quit of a disagreeable affair under an honorable excuse, and thus to avoid the necessity of condemning Christ.
Consider
Calvin reflects on Christ's appearance before the governor. For the Son of God chose to stand bound before an earthly judge, and there to receive sentence of death, [253] in order that we, delivered from condemnation, may not fear to approach freely to the heavenly throne of God. If, therefore, we consider what advantage we reap from Christ having been tried before Pilate, the disgrace of so unworthy a subjection will be immediately washed away. And certainly none are offended at the condemnation of Christ, [254] but those who are either proud hypocrites, or stupid and gross despisers of God, who are not ashamed of their own iniquity. On the purpose of Christ's silence Calvin writes: But that we may not, like Pilate, wonder at the silence of Christ, as if it had been unreasonable, we must attend to the purpose of God, who determined that his Son--whom he had appointed to be a sacrifice to atone for our sins--should be condemned as guilty in our room, though in himself he was pure. Christ therefore was at that time silent, that he may now be our advocate, and by his intercession may deliver us from condemnation. He was silent, that we may boast that by his grace we are righteous. And thus was fulfilled the prediction of Isaiah, (53:7,) that he was led as a sheep to the slaughter.
Respond
How does Calvin's treatment of Judas's remorse challenge the way you view your own repentance? In what ways does the priests' hardened response warn you about the danger of excusing sin in your life? Where do you see God's providence most clearly at work in the events Calvin highlights from Luke 23?
Pray
Sovereign Lord, in the trial and crucifixion of your Son you have displayed the mystery of your eternal counsel, whereby the Lamb was delivered up according to your predetermined will. Grant us hearts broken over sin yet anchored in the covenant mercy secured at Calvary, that we may trust your hand when justice tarries and rest in the silence of Christ who committed himself to you, the righteous Judge. By your Spirit keep us from hardness of heart and bring us daily to the foot of the cross, where grace reigns through righteousness unto eternal life. Amen.

John Calvin's Commentaries · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →