Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Maccabees
1 Maccabees 5-6 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
The fifth and sixth chapters of First Maccabees portray Judas Maccabeus leading decisive campaigns to rescue Jewish communities under threat while also recording the dramatic end of Antiochus Epiphanes and the continuation of conflict under his young son. These events illustrate how fidelity to the covenant brings unexpected deliverance even when human resources appear insufficient. At the same time the narrative warns against unauthorized initiatives that spring from vainglory rather than obedience. Readers encounter both the courage of those who fight under legitimate authority and the sobering consequences when leaders act on their own initiative. The chapters therefore invite reflection on the proper relationship between zeal, obedience, and trust in divine protection during times of persecution.
Read
Read First Maccabees chapters 5 and 6 in the Douay-Rheims or Catholic Public Domain Version. Notice the rapid succession of eight victories won by Judas and his brothers across Idumea, Ammon, and Galaad, always undertaken at the request of besieged brethren. Observe the disastrous defeat suffered by Joseph and Azarias after they ignored explicit orders to remain in Judea. Pay attention to the account of Eleazar’s self-sacrifice beneath the elephant and to the description of Antiochus’ final illness and hollow regret. Note how the narrative repeatedly credits success to those who act within the line of lawful command and how it records the breach of oath by the young king’s regent.
Study
Haydock’s notes clarify both the geography of these campaigns and the moral principles at stake when leaders exceed their mandate or when persecutors claim late repentance.
The opening observation places the eight victories within God’s providential testing of his people and introduces the theme of authorized warfare.
Nations. They were always ready to oppress the Jews. Thus God punished or tried his people. (Calmet) — Judas, or his brethren, here gains eight victories over them. (Worthington)The commentary on the failed expedition of Joseph and Azarias explains why their independent action met defeat and underscores the necessity of remaining under the authority given by Judas.
And Azarias. These two are known only for their disobedience and misconduct. In holy wars, God does not favour those who are actuated by base motives, ver. 18, 60. (Calmet) — Men who depend on themselves, and who are not properly authorized, receive not assistance from above; so these failed, as they were not chosen like those who were to save Israel, (Worthington) of the family of the Machabees. (Menochius)On the exploit of Eleazar the note defends the soldier’s twofold motive of zeal for his people and desire for lasting honor while distinguishing it from mere pride.
Name. This motive has made some condemn the exploit. But surely a person may seek to acquire fame, even by exposing himself to danger. Eleazar might well hope that the beast would not fall so suddenly. The other motive specified is truly noble and virtuous, and we cannot condemn this hero without stronger proofs. St. Gregory (Mor. xix. 13.) represents him as a figure of the proud: but he might not therefore be one of the number, (Calmet) no more than Esau, who was a type of the reprobate, Malachias i. 3. (Haydock) — St. Ambrose (Off. i. 40.) highly commends the fortitude of this soldier exposing himself to the danger of death for religion. (Worthington) — This is the general sentiment. See Serarius; Menochius; Tirinus; and Grotius, jure. iii. 4. a. 18.The remark on Antiochus’ deathbed words reminds readers that external expressions of sorrow do not necessarily indicate genuine conversion when the surrounding actions remain unchanged.
Evils. All this repentance was fictitious, 2 Machabees ix. (Worthington)
Consider
The contrast between Judas’ obedient campaigns and the presumption of Joseph and Azarias shows that zeal alone does not guarantee success; legitimacy and submission to rightful command matter. Eleazar’s willingness to risk everything beneath the armored beast reveals a sacrificial love that seeks the common good rather than personal safety. By contrast, Antiochus’ lament over past evils arrives too late to alter the course of his reign or to restore the temple he had desecrated. These episodes together teach that God protects those who fight under proper authority while he permits setbacks for those who act from selfish ambition. The broken oath at the end of chapter six further illustrates how political expediency can override sworn promises, leaving the faithful to rely ultimately on divine fidelity rather than human treaties.
Respond
Where in my own life do I risk acting on personal initiative rather than under legitimate spiritual or ecclesial authority? How can I cultivate a willingness to sacrifice recognition or safety for the sake of my community’s welfare?
Pray
Lord of hosts, who strengthened your servants to answer the cry of the oppressed and to fight with courage under lawful authority, grant us grace to reject every impulse of vainglory and to place our trust in your protection alone amid the trials of your Church. Raise up faithful leaders who, like Eleazar of old, prefer death to the betrayal of your law, and through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints, keep us steadfast in your service. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →