← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Romans

Romans 11 — with Whedon

Romans 11Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal teaching we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for Romans chapter 11. Whedon's forthright Arminian exposition illumines the apostle's treatment of Israel's present condition and future hope, underscoring divine mercy conditioned upon faith. His words guide us through the mystery of election by grace and the impartial dealings of God with both Jew and Gentile. As we study, we listen for the Wesleyan emphasis upon free, responsible response to the Gospel. May the Holy Spirit open our hearts to receive these truths with humility and joy.
Read
Let us now read Romans chapter 11 in a spirit of prayerful attention. Hear how the apostle moves from the sobering reality of Israel's unbelief to the glorious prospect of future restoration. Allow the text to speak of God's unchanging purpose and the conditional nature of covenant blessing. As you listen, consider your own place within the unfolding mercy extended to all who believe.
Study
Whedon opens by presenting the chapter's introduction. Introduction. Into the dark picture thus far of Israel’s depression, not only under the rectitude of the divine supremacy, but beneath the ascendency of the Gentiles themselves, the apostle now will throw a few hues of light, and so part with the Jew in the most cheerful possible spirit. 1 . The Palliation of Israel’s Condition , Romans 11:1-10 . Israel is not wholly cast away, since Paul’s own case proves that, as in the darkest period of idolatrous history, there is a chosen remnant by grace reserved to God. Yet the great body, on account of impenitence, are under a judicial ban from God. 2 . Resultant Benefits of Israel’s Defection to the Gentiles Glorious, yet of a Conditional Character , Romans 11:11-22 . Rejected by Israel, the Gospel has gone to the Gentiles. Yet from the Gentiles it may overflow back again upon the Jews, ( Romans 11:11-16 ,) and the Gentile holds his preeminence by tremulous conditions, ( Romans 11:17-22 .) 3 . The full Conversion of the Gentiles will result in the full Recovery of the Jews to Christ , Romans 11:25-32 . The divine mystery should not be unknown, that the partial blindness of Israel is not final; the ancient covenant will stand good, and in the general conversion of races Israel will be finally included, ( Romans 11:23-32 .) 4 . The Doxology closing the Argument , Romans 11:33-36 . Wonderfully deep is God in this entire history of his plans, ( Romans 11:33 ,) with no counsellor, ( Romans 11:34 ,) no compensator, ( Romans 11:35 ,) but solely self-sufficient and forever glorious. He then addresses the palliation of Israel's condition. Verse 1. 1 . The Palliation amid Aggravation of Israel’s Present Condition , Romans 11:1-10 . 1 . Cast away Wholly and irrecoverably? Not wholly, for there is an accepted minority. Not irrecoverably, for an entire future generation will be restored to Divine favour. Israel is, therefore, prospectively, as well as in the past, “his people.” I A very signal I. The stern proclaimer of Israel’s downfall is a living proof that the downfall is not absolute. The apostle’s own person is pledge of God’s continued mercy to Israel; and proof that it is not his mercy, but their faith, that has failed. An Israelite Not by proselytism, but by pure blood of Abraham; not of dubious relationship, but duly authenticated as to tribe; that tribe not born of Leah, or a bonds-woman, but of beloved Rachel the tribe which with Judah formed the substantial stock of the Israel of Paul’s age. Whedon next unfolds the resultant benefits of Israel's defection to the Gentiles. Verse 11. 2 . Resultant Benefits of Israel’s Fall to Gentiles Glorious yet Conditional , Romans 11:11-22 . 11 . Stumbled… fall Palliating the apostasy of the Jews, the apostle distinguishes between a mere stumble and a fall. The former indicates recoverability, the latter finality of failure. Provoke… jealousy Arouse them by the rich display of mercy through the Gospel to an emulation for seeking like blessings. Our Saviour confined his ministry to the Jews; for reason see note on Matthew 10:0 . The apostles first preached to Jews. Paul first preached to Jews, and it was not until by them rejected that he said, “Since ye count yourselves unworthy of eternal life we go to the Gentiles.” ( Acts 13:46 .) And so at the Rome to which this epistle is written he said to the rejecting Jews, “The salvation of God is sent unto the Gentiles, and they will hear it.” (See Acts 28:28 .) Thus did the fall of the Jews become the riches of the Gentiles . Finally he expounds the full conversion of the Gentiles resulting in the recovery of the Jews. Verse 25. 3 . The full conversion of the Gentiles will result in the full Recovery of the Jews , Romans 11:25-32 . 25 . Mystery A mystery of the divine counsel; a fact concealed until this time of revelation. Conceits Puffed up with your superiority to the fallen Jew. In part To a part of Israel. Happened Taken place, but not in the sense of accident. Fulness of the Gentiles We have little doubt that Paul’s mind half unconsciously here recurs to our Lord’s words in Luke 21:24 : “Jerusalem shall be trodden down of the Gentiles until the fulness of the Gentiles be gathered in.” (See our note on that passage.) By the word fulness we understand not necessarily absolutely all the Gentiles, but such a plenitude, foreseen by God, as will, as it were, drown out the infidelity of the Jews; and then the conversion of the Jews will reflow to drown out the unbelief of the Gentiles. Thereby a Christianity more or less pure and perfect may fill the earth.
Consider
Whedon presses the conditional character of divine goodness and severity. Verse 22. 22 . Goodness… severity These are the two alternatives from God, conditioned on the continue and the fall in man. To add to this that God has infallibly secured either one or the other, is to mar the apostle’s doctrine, destroy the freedom of man, and the moral government of God. He closes the argument with the doxology to God's unsearchable ways. Verse 33. 4 . The Doxology closing the Argument. 33 . Riches Tholuck and others, including Alford, hold riches , wisdom , and knowledge to be three coordinates, dependent upon depth. It would then read, “O the depth of the riches, and wisdom, and knowledge of God!” Riches would then imply affluence of goodness and blessing; as rich in Romans 10:12 , and riches, Philippians 4:19 . That this is the true sense is probable from the parallelisms (well shown by Dr. Forbes) which follow. (See our Introduction to Romans.) This passage is at once a sublime, rapturous apostrophe, and a rich commentary by the apostle on his whole previous argument. But it is plain that Paul is not a Calvinistic commentator. When Calvin surveyed his own scheme his shuddering comment was, “A horrible decree, I confess!” When Paul surveys this his own grand argument he exultantly exclaims, “O the depth of God’s bounty and wisdom!”
Respond
How does the conditional nature of covenant blessing shape your daily walk of faith? In what ways might you guard against the pride that forgets its dependence upon grace? Where do you see opportunity to pray and labor for the recovery of those still outside the visible people of God?
Pray
Gracious God, we thank Thee for the light shed upon Thy word by Thy servant Daniel D. Whedon. Grant us humble hearts to receive the mystery of Thy dealings with Israel and the nations. Keep us from boasting over those whose branches have been broken off, and teach us to stand only by faith. May the riches of Thy mercy overflow again upon Thy ancient people, and may all who believe be grafted into the one olive tree of Thy Church. Through Christ our Lord, Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →