Eterniseed › Curriculum › Formula of Concord: Solid Declaration
Solid Declaration V — Of the Law and the Gospel — Book of Concord
Opening
This lesson draws from Solid Declaration V of the Formula of Concord, a key Lutheran confession that safeguards the proper distinction between the Law and the Gospel. In a time when these doctrines were being confused, the confessors insisted on clarity so that Christ’s merit would remain the sole comfort for troubled consciences. Their careful wording continues to guide readers today in rightly dividing God’s Word and receiving the Gospel in its purity.
Read
Turn now to Solid Declaration V itself and read the article in full. The text rests especially on passages such as Mark 1:1,15, Luke 24:46-47, John 16:8, Romans 1:16-18, 3:20, 2 Corinthians 3:7-16, and Galatians 3:24, showing how Scripture itself maintains the distinction between Law and Gospel.
Study
The Confession opens by...
As the distinction between the Law and the Gospel is a special brilliant light, which serves to the end that God’s Word may be rightly divided, and the Scriptures of the holy prophets and apostles may be properly explained and understood, we must guard it with especial care, in order that these two doctrines may not be mingled with one another, or a law be made out of the Gospel, whereby the merit of Christ is obscured and troubled consciences are robbed of their comfort, which they otherwise have in the holy Gospel when it is preached genuinely and in its purity, and by which they can support themselves in their most grievous trials against the terrors of the Law.It addresses the dissent among theologians...
Now, here likewise there has occurred a dissent among some theologians of the Augsburg Confession; for the one side asserted that the Gospel is properly not only a preaching of grace, but at the same time also a preaching of repentance, which rebukes the greatest sin, namely, unbelief. But the other side held and contended that the Gospel is not properly a preaching of repentance or of reproof [preaching of repentance, convicting sin], as that properly belongs to God’s Law, which reproves all sins, and therefore unbelief also; but that the Gospel is properly a preaching of the grace and favor of God for Christ’s sake, through which the unbelief of the converted, which previously inhered in them, and which the Law of God reproved, is pardoned and forgiven.It distinguishes the two senses in which the term Gospel is used...
Furthermore the term Gospel is employed in another, namely, in its proper sense, by which it comprises not the preaching of repentance, but only the preaching of the grace of God, as follows directly afterwards, Mark 1:15, where Christ says: Repent, and believe the Gospel.It then sets forth the unanimous confession regarding the Law...
Therefore [we shall set forth our meaning:] we unanimously believe, teach, and confess that the Law is properly a divine doctrine, in which the righteous, immutable will of God is revealed, what is to be the quality of man in his nature, thoughts, words, and works, in order that he may be pleasing and acceptable to God; and it threatens its transgressors with God’s wrath and temporal and eternal punishments. For as Luther writes against the law-stormers [Antinomians]: Everything that reproves sin is and belongs to the Law, whose peculiar office it is to reprove sin and to lead to the knowledge of sins, Rom. 3:20,7:7; and as unbelief is the root and well-spring of all reprehensible sins [all sins that must be censured and reproved], the Law reproves unbelief also.
Consider
It warns against mingling the two doctrines...
Now, in order that both doctrines, that of the Law and that of the Gospel, be not mingled and confounded with one another, and what belongs to the one may not be ascribed to the other, whereby the merit and benefits of Christ are easily obscured and the Gospel is again turned into a doctrine of the Law, as has occurred in the Papacy, and thus Christians are deprived of the true comfort which they have in the Gospel against the terrors of the Law, and the door is again opened in the Church of God to the Papacy, therefore the true and proper distinction between the Law and the Gospel must with all diligence be inculcated and preserved, and whatever gives occasion for confusion inter legem et evangelium (between the Law and the Gospel), that is, whereby the two doctrines, Law and Gospel, may be confounded and mingled into one doctrine, should be diligently prevented. It is, therefore, dangerous and wrong to convert the Gospel, properly so called, as distinguished from the Law, into a preaching of repentance or reproof [a preaching of repentance, reproving sin].
Respond
Where in your own reading of Scripture have you noticed the need for this careful distinction? How does the comfort of the Gospel change when the Law is allowed to overshadow it? What steps can you take this week to let the Gospel remain a pure message of grace in Christ?
Pray
Gracious Lord, we thank You for the clear light of Your Word that distinguishes Law and Gospel. Keep us from confusing these doctrines or turning the Gospel into another law. Let the preaching of repentance drive us to Christ alone, and let the sweet message of forgiveness in His name strengthen our hearts in every trial. Preserve this distinction in Your Church until the end of time, that many may find true comfort and salvation in Jesus. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →