← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Acts

Acts 5 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary

Acts 5Haydock Bible Commentary20 min
Opening
Today we enter the sacred narrative of Acts chapter five through the lens of Haydock's Catholic Commentary, a treasured compilation of patristic and Catholic exegetical wisdom. This venerable resource gathers the voices of the Fathers and later doctors to unfold the mysteries of the early Church's trials and triumphs. As we prepare to study the sobering account of Ananias and Sapphira alongside the apostles' bold witness, Haydock's Commentary invites us to ponder divine holiness, the cost of fidelity, and the unstoppable advance of the Gospel. May these reflections root our hearts more deeply in truth and courage.
Read
With reverent attention, open your Bible to Acts chapter five and read the entire chapter slowly. Allow the dramatic events of the early Jerusalem community to unfold before you: the sudden judgment upon deceit, the growing signs and wonders, the imprisonment and release of the apostles, and Gamaliel's measured intervention. Notice how the text moves from internal purification to public testimony. Pause after each section to let the sacred words settle in silence before continuing.
Study
Haydock opens by examining the vow implied in the early Christian community's practice. Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Act 5:1 is believed by many of the Fathers, that the resolution which the faithful made of selling their property, and laying the price at the feet of the apostles, implied a vow of reserving nothing for themselves, but giving all to the community; and that the crime of Ananias and Saphira consisted in the violation of this vow; on which account they regarded them as sacrilegious, and plunderers of sacred things. See St. Basil, Serm. i. de instit. Monac.; St. Cyprian, lib. i. ad Quir. &c. ---For, without this supposition, we cannot, as Menochius justly remarks, account for the sudden and severe punishment inflicted on the offending parties. The commentary then addresses the nature of the lie offered to the Holy Ghost. Did it not remain to thee? That is, no one forced thee to make such a promise. --- And being sold, was it not in thy power, and at thy free disposal, before such a promise? but promises and vows must be kept. Thou hast not lied to men, but to God, by lying to the Holy Ghost. (Witham) --- Thou hast not lied to men, only and principally, but to God also; for he had also lied to Peter, and the other apostles. (Menochius) --- "If it displeased God," says St. Augustine, "to withdraw part of the money they had vowed to God, how is he angry, when chastity is vowed and not performed! ... let not such persons think to be condemned to corporal death, but to everlasting fire." (Serm. x. de diversis.) --- St. Gregory, on t his same subject, says: "Ananias had vowed money to God, which afterwards, overcome by diabolical persuasion, he withdrew; but with what death he was punished, thou knowest. See, then, what judgment thou art to expect, for withdrawing, not money, but thyself, from Almighty God." (lib. i. ep. 33.) Haydock further reflects on differing patristic opinions concerning the offenders' eternal lot. Ananias ... fell down and gave up the ghost. St. Augustine says,[3] this severe judgment was to strike a terror of such dissembling fraudulent dealings into the new Church. It was also to shew that St. Peter, and the apostles, had the gift of prophecy. (Witham) --- Origen thinks his death was occasioned by the sudden fright and shame, with which he was seized. Pliny relates a similar accident in the sudden death of Diodorus Dialecticus, lib. vii. cap. 53. --- Menochius and Cornelius a Lapide think, that God struck him interiorly, as Peter spoke. ... There are likewise different opinions among the Fathers, respecting the salvation of Ananias and Saphira. Some are of opinion, that as their fault was great, they died, and perished in their sin. but the ideas we are fond to cherish of the infinite mercy of God, would rather incline us to say, with St. Augustine, "I can believe that God spared them after this life, for his mercy is great. ... They were stricken with the scourge of death, that they might not be subject to eternal punishment." (St. Augustine, Serm. cxlviii. olim. 10. et in Parmen.) --- St. Benedict also, in the 57th chapter of his rule, insinuates, that their death was only corporal. (Haydock) --- It is not unreasonable, that the first violators of laws, should be punished with severity. It was thus that the Almighty treated Adam, the adorers of the golden calf, the first who broke the sabbath-day, &c. to prevent the effects of bad example. (Calmet)
Consider
Haydock turns to Gamaliel's prudent counsel before the Sanhedrin. Gamaliel. He that had been St. Paul's master, according to St. John Chrysostom, advised them to forbear, and do nothing rashly. [Ver. 38.] Meddle not with these men; literally, go from them.[6] For, saith he, if this be the work of men only, it will soon fall to nothing; but if it be from God, you cannot hinder it, and you will only make yourselves guilty, by resisting the designs of God. They consented to him, so far as not to put them to death; but they made them be scourged, which they rejoiced at; and they dismissed them with reiterated threats. (Witham) --- Gamaliel was the master of St. Paul, Barnabas, Stephen, and others, and favoured the Christians. St. Clement and Ven. Bede think he was then a Christian, but concealed his conversion at the instigation of the apostles, that he might have an opportunity of defending Christ in the council. He afterwards professed his faith publicly, and was canonized with is son Abibas. See Baronius, 3d of Aug. (Tirinus) The commentary concludes by affirming the Church's divine origin and endurance. Act 5:39 , and the evident success of Christ's Church, prove it to be of God. No violence of the Jews, no persecution of heathen princes, no attempts of domestic adversaries, heretics, schismatics, or evil livers, have been able to prevail against it. Men of superior abilities have made violent attacks against it; their memory, and that of their disciples, has either been buried and forgotten, or liveth only in malediction and infamy. Let, then no Catholic be dispirited, because modern heresies continue; Arian and other heresies have continued much longer, have been more powerfully supported by temporal power, and yet have come to nothing. The Catholic religion was the first, and it will be the last religion.
Respond
How might the seriousness with which vows are treated in this chapter shape the way I make and keep promises to God? In what areas of my life am I tempted to withhold something from the Lord that I have already offered? Where do I see the same divine protection of the Church at work amid present challenges?
Pray
O Lord Jesus Christ, who by the power of the Holy Spirit preserved the infant Church from deceit and strengthened the apostles to obey God rather than men, cleanse our hearts from every duplicity so that our offerings may be pure and pleasing in Your sight. Fill us with the same joy the first disciples knew amid suffering, and cause the Gospel to advance through Your faithful people. Through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints, guard Your Church against every assault and draw us ever deeper into Your truth. Amen.

Haydock Bible Commentary · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →