← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Matthew

Matthew 19 — with Whedon

Matthew 19Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal study we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. This revered Arminian-Wesleyan resource opens Matthew chapter nineteen with careful attention to the Lord's teaching on marriage, children, and discipleship. Whedon's exposition invites us to receive Scripture as the living word that forms holy living and entire devotion. As we follow his paragraphs we seek both doctrinal clarity and the warming of the heart that leads to faithful obedience. May the same Spirit who guided the commentator guide our meditation now.
Read
Let us now read the nineteenth chapter of Matthew in a spirit of prayerful attention. Hear the Lord's words on the permanence of marriage, the blessing of little children, and the cost of following him. Allow the text to search the heart and awaken desire for the kingdom. Read slowly, pausing where conviction or comfort arises, and receive the passage as the church has long received it for faith and practice.
Study
Whedon opens by detailing the Pharisees' approach to Jesus. Verse 3. 3 . The Pharisees also came The Pharisees as well as the multitudes. The former to cavil, and the latter to be healed. Tempting him Trying him to see if they cannot get him into a difficulty. The point was one about which there was a hot partisan dispute, and the object was to involve our Lord in its quarrel. For every cause The point is this: In Deuteronomy 24:1 , Moses gives to a man permission to dismiss his wife by granting her a bill of divorce or discharge, certifying that she is no longer his wife, if she “find no favour in his eyes, because he hath found uncleanness in her.” The followers of Rabbi Hillel interpreted this to mean that a man might dismiss his wife whenever he pleased, for the very slightest offence, or for no offence at all, if he found some woman that pleased him more. But the followers of Rabbi Schammai held that the uncleanness meant unchasteness, and so forbid divorce for any other cause. If these Pharisees now can make our Lord commit himself upon this point, they hope to involve him in the feud with one party or the other. He then turns to our Lord's answer drawn from Genesis. Verse 4. 4 . He answered Our Lord’s answer really coincides with neither party. Schammai is indeed in the right in maintaining the stricter view of marriage obligation. His views are founded in absolute right. But then he is wrong in maintaining that the letter of the Mosaic law does maintain the highest strictness of the divine right on this subject. From the hardness of their hearts Moses did permit to the Jews, though not enjoin, a practice which was not absolutely right. A truly pure man could not avail himself of the permission. Have ye not read Our Lord here quotes the book of Genesis as a divine authority. We thus prove the Old Testament by the New. If Christ was the Son of God, Moses was the servant of God. If Christ’s words had a divine authority, then Moses was also inspired. Made them male and female He made the race male and female, with the divine intention that marriage should exist. And by still maintaining the race as divided into two sexes, he shows that marriage is a permanent and natural institution. And as he made one for one, and no more, so the marriage of a single man with a single woman is a law of the race. And since, by some mysterious law, the two sexes are perpetually preserved in an approximate equality in point of number, it is plain that the permanent marriage of one man with one woman is the permanent and universal law of nature. Polygamy, as well as capricious divorce, is a violation of natural law. Whedon proceeds to unfold the meaning of one flesh. Verse 6. 6 . One flesh As in Adam before the creation of Eve the twain were one, so now, by marriage, the oneness is restored. They are two halves of one whole, forming one person. Yet, however much we may talk of their oneness, they are not one soul. They have an eternal separateness of individuality, by which they may be eternally separated in future destiny. Hence they are indeed one flesh, but not one soul. Let not man put asunder It cannot be done in any case without crime, except by death. Our Lord in this answer sides with neither party, but rises above them both. He does not say, with Schammai, that the letter of Moses’s law allowed no divorce but for adultery. Nor does he, with Hillel, affirm that divorce is allowable for every or any cause. He maintains that, upon the foundation of original creation, divorce for any other cause than adultery is wrong, and only permitted by Moses to prevent greater wrong. He next places children within the life of the kingdom. Verses 13-15. § 104. CHILDREN BLESSED BY CHRIST, Matthew 19:13-15 . It is with great propriety that immediately after our Saviour has settled the law of marriage under the Christian dispensation, he should also assign the place of children in the Christian Church. This passage surely is not given for the purpose of showing that Christ was personally fond of children, but of showing that the child is no more to be excluded from the Church of the New Testament than from that of the Old.
Consider
Whedon presses the demand of perfect surrender. Verse 21. 21 . Be perfect If thou wilt lack nothing, but have all things necessary to complete thy salvation, give up all for Christ. Our Lord has now brought him to just the right test. The young man wished a high standard of righteousness; our Saviour has presented it. He wished to be saved by works; our Saviour has shown him the way of faith. He truly thought he was ready for any task; our Saviour has undeceived him. He expected that he should be able to earn heaven by the nobleness of his performance; our Lord shows him that there is a price infinitely below the value of heaven which he is not willing to pay. Henceforth let no one dream that he can offer any price of righteousness that shall merit eternal life. Let him not go about asking what good thing he shall do to become an heir of heaven. Let him simply throw himself by faith upon God for salvation, and trust in the Saviour he hath sent. He concludes with the miracle of grace for the rich. Verse 26. 26 . With God all things are possible The salvation of a rich man is as miraculous as the putting a camel through a needle’s eye. It is a human impossibility. But God can do it. But does not this reduce the rich man to just the same level as any other man, and so destroy all the force of our Lord’s first reflections on the impossibility of bringing a rich man into the kingdom of heaven? We reply, that our Lord means to represent that the salvation of a rich man bears to the ordinary salvation of common men the same relation that a miracle does to an ordinary transaction. If the saving of an ordinary man be a miracle of grace, the saving of a rich man is a miracle upon a miracle. It is an event above the ordinary train of grace, just as a miracle is above the ordinary course of nature.
Respond
1. Where in my life do I still seek to negotiate the terms of discipleship rather than surrender all? 2. How does the permanence of marriage shape my view of covenant faithfulness today? 3. In what ways am I trusting God to do the impossible with those I deem far from the kingdom?
Pray
Gracious Lord, we thank thee for the clear light of thy word as opened by thy servant Whedon. Grant us grace to receive thy law of marriage with reverence and to guard the sacred bond thou hast ordained. Bring the little children near and keep us childlike in faith. Deliver us from every idol of wealth or self that would turn us from following thee. Work in us the miracle of conversion that only thy power can accomplish. May our homes, our churches, and our hearts reflect the order and love of thy kingdom. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →