Eterniseed › Curriculum › 2 Samuel
2 Samuel 19-20 — with Brown
Opening
Today we open Robert Jamieson, A.R. Fausset, and David Brown's Commentary on the Whole Bible to 2 Samuel 19-20. These chapters trace David's careful restoration after Absalom's revolt and the swift outbreak of a new rebellion under Sheba. The commentary guides us through the king's political maneuvers, the tensions among the tribes, and the ruthless actions that secure his throne. With reverent attention to the text, Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown show how mercy and justice meet amid lingering loyalties and fresh dangers. Their verse-by-verse notes illuminate the human cost of civil strife and the steady hand required to heal a fractured kingdom. Let us listen carefully as these trusted expositors unfold the narrative.
Read
With hearts ready to receive instruction, turn now to 2 Samuel chapters 19 and 20. Read slowly through David's return across the Jordan, his encounters with Shimei, Mephibosheth, and Barzillai, and the sudden revolt led by Sheba. Note the king's measured responses and the violent measures that follow. Ask the Lord to open your understanding as the text reveals both the mercy extended and the justice required to preserve the kingdom. Take time to absorb each scene before we study the commentary together.
Study
Jamieson, Fausset, and Brown begin their treatment of chapter 19 by examining Joab's sharp rebuke to the grieving king.
Verse 5. 5. Thou hast shamed . . . the faces of all thy servants —by withdrawing thyself to indulge in grief, as if their services were disagreeable and their devotion irksome to thee. Instead of hailing their return with joy and gratitude, thou hast refused them the small gratification of seeing thee. Joab's remonstrance was right and necessary, but it was made with harshness. He was one of those persons who spoil their important services by the insolence of their manners, and who always awaken a feeling of obligation in those to whom they render any services. He spoke to David in a tone of hauteur that ill became a subject to show towards his king.They next unfold the political calculations behind David's separate appeal to the tribe of Judah.
Verse 9. 9-11. all the people were at strife throughout all the tribes of Israel —The kingdom was completely disorganized. The sentiments of three different parties are represented in 2 Samuel 19:9 ; 2 Samuel 19:10 : the royalists, the adherents of Absalom who had been very numerous, and those who were indifferent to the Davidic dynasty. In these circumstances the king was right in not hastening back, as a conqueror, to reascend his throne. A re-election was, in some measure, necessary. He remained for some time on the other side of Jordan, in expectation of being invited back. That invitation was given without, however, the concurrence of Judah. David, disappointed and vexed by his own tribe's apparent lukewarmness, despatched the two high priests to rouse the Judahites to take a prominent interest in his cause. It was the act of a skilful politician. Hebron having been the seat of the rebellion, it was graceful on his part to encourage their return to allegiance and duty; it was an appeal to their honor not to be the last of the tribes. But this separate message, and the preference given to them, occasioned an outburst of jealousy among the other tribes that was nearly followed by fatal consequences [see 2 Samuel 19:10- : ].Turning to Mephibosheth's arrival, the commentators describe the depth of his mourning and the king's uncertain reception.
Verse 24. 24-30. Mephibosheth . . came down to meet the king —The reception given to Mephibosheth was less creditable to David. The sincerity of that prince's grief for the misfortunes of the king cannot be doubted. He had neither dressed his feet —not taken the bath, nor trimmed his beard —The Hebrews cut off the hair on the upper lip (see on :- ), and cheeks, but carefully cherished it on the chin from ear to ear. Besides dyeing it black or red colors, which, however, is the exception, and not the rule in the East, there are various modes of trimming it: they train it into a massy, bushy form, swelling and round; or they terminate it like a pyramid, in a sharp point. Whatever the mode, it is always trimmed with the greatest care; and they usually carry a small comb for the purpose. The neglect of this attention to his beard was an undoubted proof of the depth of Mephibosheth's grief.
Consider
Brown closes the account of Mephibosheth by weighing the justice of David's final decision.
The king seems to have received him upbraidingly, and not to have been altogether sure either of his guilt or innocence. It is impossible to commend the cavalier treatment, any more than to approve the partial award, of David in this case. If he were too hurried and distracted by the pressure of circumstances to inquire fully into the matter, he should have postponed his decision; for if by "dividing the land" ( :- ) he meant that the former arrangement should be continued by which Mephibosheth was acknowledged the proprietor, and Ziba the farmer, it was a hardship inflicted on the owner to fix him with a tenant who had so grossly slandered him. But if by "dividing the land," they were now to share alike, the injustice of the decision was greatly increased. In any view, the generous, disinterested spirit displayed by Mephibosheth was worthy a son of the noble-hearted Jonathan.They conclude the section on Amasa's death by underscoring Joab's lasting hold over the army.
Verse 11. 11-13. He that favoureth Joab, and he that is for David, let him go after Joab —It is a striking proof of Joab's unrivalled influence over the army, that with this villainous murder perpetrated before their eyes they unanimously followed him as their leader in pursuit of Sheba. A soldier conjoined his name with David's, and such a magic spell was in the word "Joab," that all the people "went on"—Amasa's men as well as the rest. The conjunction of these two names is very significant. It shows that the one could not afford to do without the other—neither Joab to rebel against David, nor David to get rid of Joab, though hating him. 2 Samuel 20:14 ; 2 Samuel 20:15 . JOAB PURSUES SHEBA UNTO ABEL.
Respond
How does David's willingness to pardon Shimei challenge or encourage your own practice of forgiveness? In what ways might partial judgments, like the one given to Mephibosheth, still appear in our relationships or churches today? What does Joab's unchecked influence warn us about tolerating strong but ungodly leaders in God's work?
Pray
Gracious Lord, in the wake of rebellion and restoration set forth in Your Word, grant us the wisdom to extend mercy without compromising truth, even as David sought to do. By Your Spirit keep our hearts from pride that hardens and from rashness that wounds, and bind Your people together in humble loyalty to Christ the King. May our leaders serve with lowliness and our lives display the reconciling power of the gospel. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →