Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians
1 Corinthians 5 — with Barnes
Opening
Albert Barnes's Notes on the Bible supply a steady, verse-by-verse exposition of 1 Corinthians 5 that places the church's duty of holiness in clear relief. The chapter records the apostle's grief over tolerated immorality and his firm direction for its removal. Barnes traces the argument from report to remedy, showing how the gospel itself requires both purity and mercy. His treatment keeps the focus on Christ's sacrifice as the true Passover and on the congregation's responsibility to act. We turn to these notes expecting the Spirit to renew our zeal for the honor of the Lord Jesus among his people.
Read
Let us now read 1 Corinthians 5 in full, listening for the apostle's grief, his apostolic authority, and his call to remove the leaven of sin so that the church may be a new lump. Ask the Lord to prepare your heart to receive both the warning and the hope contained in these verses.
Study
Barnes opens by summarizing the apostle's response to the reported scandal.
The apostle 1 Corinthians 5:1 reproves them for tolerating a species of licentiousness which was not tolerated even by the pagans; he reproves them 1 Corinthians 5:2 for being puffed up with pride even while this scandal existed in their church; he ordered them immediately to purify the church by removing the incestuous person 1 Corinthians 5:4-5 ; and exhorted them to preserve themselves from the influence which a single corrupt person might have, operating like leaven in a mass; 1 Corinthians 5:6-7 .He proceeds to examine the specific report of fornication in the assembly.
Verse 1. It is reported - Greek It is heard. There is a rumor. That rumor had been brought to Paul, probably by the members of the family of Chloe, 1 Corinthians 1:11 . Commonly - Ὅλως Holōs. Everywhere. It is a matter of common fame. It is so public that it cannot be concealed; and so certain that it cannot be denied. This was all offence, he informs us, which even the pagan would not justify or tolerate; and, therefore, the report had spread not only in the churches, but even among the pagan, to the great scandal of religion - When a report obtains such a circulation, it is certainly time to investigate it, and to correct the evil. That there is fornication - See the note at Acts 15:20 . The word is here used to denote incest, because the apostle immediately explains the nature of the offence. And such fornication ... - An offence that is not tolerated or known among the pagan.Barnes then turns to the congregation's inappropriate pride despite the sin.
Verse 2. And ye are puffed up - See the note at 1 Corinthians 4:18 . You are filled with pride, and with a vain conceit of your own wisdom and purity, notwithstanding the existence of this enormous wickedness in your church. This does not mean that they were puffed up, or proud on account of the existence of this wickedness, but they were filled with pride notwithstanding, or in spite of it. They ought to have been a humbled people. They should have mourned; and should have given their first attention to the removal of the evil. But instead of this, they had given indulgence to proud feeling, and had become elated with a vain confidence in their spiritual purity. People are always elated and proud when they have the least occasion for it. And have not rather mourned ... - Have not rather been so afflicted and troubled as to take the proper means for removing the offence. The word “mourn” here is taken in that large sense. Ye have not been “so much” afflicted - so troubled with the existence of this wickedness, as to take the proper measures to remove the offender - Acts of discipline in the church should always commence with mourning that there is occasion for it. It should not be anger, or pride, or revenge, or party feeling, which prompt to it. It should be deep grief that there is occasion for it; and tender compassion for the offender. Might be taken away - By excommunication. He should not, while he continues in this state, be allowed to remain in your communion.
Consider
Barnes underscores that church discipline rests with the gathered body under apostolic direction.
As if I were with you; that is, with my declared opinion; knowing what I would advise, were I one of you; or, I being virtually present with you by having delivered my opinion. It cannot mean that Paul’s soul would be really present with them, but that, knowing his views and feelings, and what he would do, and knowing his love for them, they could act as if he were there. This passage proves that discipline belongs to the church itself; and so deep was Paul’s conviction of this, that even he would not administer it, without their concurrence and action. And if Paul would not do it, and in a case too where bodily pains were to be inflicted by miraculous agency, assuredly no other ministers have a right to assume the authority to administer discipline without the action and the concurrence of the church itself.Finally he notes the temporary nature of the miraculous element in such judgments.
But it is very evident from the Scriptures that the apostles were imbued with the power of inflicting diseases or bodily calamities for crimes. See Acts 13:11 ; 1 Corinthians 11:30 . What this bodily malady was we have no means of knowing. It is evident that it was not of very long duration, since when the apostle exhorts them 2 Corinthians 2:7 again to receive him, there is no mention made of his suffering then under it - This was an extraordinary and miraculous power. It was designed for the government of the church in its infancy, when everything was suited to show the direct agency of God; and it ceased, doubtless, with the apostles. The church now has no such power. It cannot now work miracles; and all its discipline now is to be moral discipline, designed not to inflict bodily pain and penalties, but to work a moral reformation in the offender.
Respond
Where in our own fellowship might we be tolerating what even the world condemns? How does the finished sacrifice of Christ move us to pursue both personal and corporate purity? In what ways can we practice discipline that aims at restoration rather than revenge?
Pray
Gracious Father, cleanse your church from every form of tolerated sin and grant us humble hearts to mourn over offenses against your holiness. By the power of your Spirit, fix our eyes on Christ our Passover, sacrificed for us, that we may keep the feast with sincerity and truth. Guard us from pride that blinds us to our need and make our assemblies pleasing to you until the day of his appearing. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →