← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Apology of the Augsburg Confession

Apology — Of Ecclesiastical Power — Book of Concord

Apology of the Augsburg Confession 25The Book of Concord18 min
Opening
Today we turn to the Apology of the Augsburg Confession in its article Of Ecclesiastical Power. This portion of the Lutheran Confessions addresses the proper limits of church authority and defends Christian freedom under the Gospel. It speaks directly to how believers understand the role of bishops and human traditions in light of justification by faith alone. For the Lutheran reader this teaching guards the conscience and keeps the Church centered on Christ rather than on man-made requirements. Its careful distinctions remain vital for faith and practice in every generation.
Read
Set aside time to read the full article Of Ecclesiastical Power from the Apology of the Augsburg Confession. The text rests especially on passages such as Matthew 15:11, Romans 14:17, Acts 15:9, Galatians 5:1, Colossians 2:20, Hebrews 13:17, and Acts 5:29. As you read, notice how the Apology answers the Confutation while confessing the freedom believers have in Christ.
Study
The Confession opens by identifying the central controversy raised in the Confutation. But although in the Confession we have in this article embraced various topics, the adversaries make no reply [act in true popish fashion], except that the bishops have the power of rule and coercive correction, in order to direct their subjects to the goal of eternal blessedness; and that the power of ruling requires the power to judge, to define, to distinguish and fix those things which are serviceable or conduce to the aforementioned end. These are the words of the Confutation, in which the adversaries teach us [but do not prove] that the bishops have the authority to frame laws (without the authority of the Gospel] useful for obtaining eternal life. The controversy is concerning this article. It then states the doctrine that must be retained in the Church. [Regarding this matter we submit the following:] But we must retain in the Church this doctrine, namely, that we receive the remission of sins freely for Christ’s sake, by faith. We must also retain this doctrine, namely, that human traditions are useless services, and therefore neither sin nor righteousness should be placed in meat, drink, clothing, and like things, the use of which Christ wished to be left free, since He says, Matt. 15:11: Not that which goeth into the mouth defileth the man; and Paul, Rom. 14:17: The kingdom of God is not meat and drink. Therefore the bishops have no right to frame traditions in addition to the Gospel, that they may merit the remission of sins, that they may be services which God is to approve as righteousness, and which burden consciences, as though it were a sin to omit them. All this is taught by that one passage in Acts 15:9, where the apostles say [Peter says] that hearts are purified by faith. And then they prohibit the imposing of a yoke, and show how great a danger this is, and enlarge upon the sin of those who burden the Church. The Confession next sets forth the power that the Gospel actually grants to bishops. Besides, we have declared in the Confession what power the Gospel ascribes to bishops. Those who are now bishops do not perform the duties of bishops according to the Gospel; although, indeed, they may be bishops according to canonical polity, which we do not censure. But we are speaking of a bishop according to the Gospel. And we are pleased with the ancient division of power into power of the order and power of jurisdiction [that is, the administration of the Sacraments and the exercise of spiritual jurisdiction]. Therefore the bishop has the power of the order, i.e., the ministry of the Word and Sacraments; he has also the power of jurisdiction, i.e., the authority to excommunicate those guilty of open crimes, and again to absolve them if they are converted and seek absolution. But their power is not to be tyrannical, i.e., without a fixed law; nor regal, i.e., above law; but they have a fixed command and a fixed Word of God, according to which they ought to teach, and according to which they ought to exercise their jurisdiction. It further clarifies how far traditions may be framed without burdening consciences. Although in the Confession we also have added how far it is lawful for them to frame traditions, namely, not as necessary services, but so that there may be order in the Church, for the sake of tranquillity. And these traditions ought not to cast snares upon consciences, as though to enjoin necessary services; as Paul teaches when he says, Gal. 5:1: Stand fast, therefore, in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, and be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage. The use of such ordinances ought therefore to be left free, provided that offenses be avoided, and that they be not judged to be necessary services; just as the apostles themselves ordained [for the sake of good discipline] very many things which have been changed with time. Neither did they hand them down in such a way that it would not be permitted to change them. For they did not dissent from their own writings, in which they greatly labor lest the Church be burdened with the opinion that human rites are necessary services.
Consider
The Confession closes by placing its entire response before the judgment of the godly. This is what we have replied to the Confutation for the time being. Now we leave it to the judgment of all the godly whether the adversaries are right in boasting that they have actually refuted our Confession from the Scriptures.
Respond
How does the distinction between the power of the order and the power of jurisdiction shape the way you view pastoral authority today? In what areas of Christian life do you sense the temptation to treat human traditions as necessary for righteousness? Where do you most need the comfort that traditions cannot merit the forgiveness of sins?
Pray
Gracious Lord, we thank You for the clear witness of the Apology concerning ecclesiastical power. Keep us steadfast in the doctrine that forgiveness is received freely for Christ’s sake through faith. Guard Your Church from every burden that would obscure this Gospel. Grant faithful bishops and pastors who teach and exercise authority according to Your Word alone. Preserve Christian liberty so that consciences are not entangled by human traditions. Let the peace and unity that flow from justification by grace reign among us. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

The Book of Concord · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →