Eterniseed › Curriculum › Ecclesiastes
Ecclesiastes 1-2 — with Coke
Opening
In the spirit of early Methodist devotion we turn today to Thomas Coke's Commentary on the Holy Bible. As Wesley's trusted associate and the first Methodist bishop, Coke brought both scholarly depth and warm evangelical heart to the sacred text. His treatment of Ecclesiastes chapters 1 and 2 invites us to sit with Solomon's searching questions while keeping our eyes fixed on the greater wisdom that is in Christ. Let us listen reverently, expecting the Spirit to apply every word to our hearts.
Read
With quiet attention we now read Ecclesiastes chapters 1 and 2. Let the Preacher's measured cadences settle upon the soul. Notice how every pursuit under the sun is weighed and found wanting, yet the passage leaves room for the hope that only God can give. Read slowly, allowing the Spirit to search and to comfort.
Study
Coke opens by presenting Solomon in the character of the Preacher.
Verse 1. Ecclesiastes 1:1 . The words of the Preacher — Or, orator. Mr. Desvoeux has shewn with great learning, that Solomon in this book appears nearly in the character of an eminent sophist among the Greeks, according to the primitive signification of that word, which implied philosophy and rhetoric joined together. The method of these ancient sages, as far as we can judge of it from what remained among their degenerate successors, was, to treat any subject which was reckoned worthy their learned dissertations in such a manner as to please the ear and improve the mind; which Tully calls the most perfect philosophy. The book of Ecclesiastes certainly deserves that character, if any in antiquity does.He then unfolds the first proposition with its analytical proofs.
Verses 2-3. Ecclesiastes 1:2-3 . Vanity of vanities — Vanity of vanities, according to the Hebrew idiom, signifies, the greatest vanity. The original word הבל hebel, signifies, properly, steam or vapour, and is used to denote any thing which is transient and empty, in apparition to what is solid, substantial, and permanent. These verses contain the first proposition, "That no labour or trouble of men," &c. The proofs of which we here subjoin analytically: Ecclesiastes 1:2-3 . I. Proposition. Ecc 1:4 to Ecc 11:1 st Proof. The course of nature. Ecclesiastes 1:12 , &c. 2nd Proof. Men's occupations. Ecclesiastes 1:16-18 . 1st Head. Wisdom or philosophy. Ecc 2:1-2 nd Head. Pleasure. 3.-10. Both jointly. Ecclesiastes 2:11 . General conclusion of the 2nd proof. A review of the 2nd proof, with special conclusions relating to every particular therein mentioned; viz. Ecclesiastes 2:12-17 . Ecclesiastes 2:1 . Wisdom. Ecclesiastes 2:18-23 .Coke moves into reflections upon the vanity of all earthly courses.
Verse 18. Ecclesiastes 1:18 . For in much wisdom, &c.— The sum of the matter, from the 16th verse, is this; First, the research of wisdom, nay, the very possession of that science, whereby one is fully enabled to distinguish good from evil, avails nothing to solid happiness: on the contrary, it even serves frequently to imbitter our lives; as nothing can be more afflicting to a rational mind, than to see, and not be able to reform, the vices of his fellow-creatures. REFLECTIONS.— 1st, Solomon upon the throne never appeared so august and venerable, as here he does in the pulpit. We have, 1.He concludes the section by contrasting human wisdom with the knowledge of Christ.
In short, he that increaseth knowledge, only increaseth sorrow; and every new attainment affords fresh cause of disquietude and dissatisfaction. But there is a wisdom which will not thus disappoint the attentive inquirer; the knowledge of Jesus, the wisdom of God, and the mystery of godliness; the more we are acquainted with it, the more satisfaction will it afford to our souls; and, however defective our measure of it may be here, the least attainment contains a divine hope, that hereafter it will be complete and perfect, when we shall know even as we are known.
Consider
Coke presses the final conclusion that only the wisdom which is from above satisfies the heart.
In short, he that increaseth knowledge, only increaseth sorrow; and every new attainment affords fresh cause of disquietude and dissatisfaction. But there is a wisdom which will not thus disappoint the attentive inquirer; the knowledge of Jesus, the wisdom of God, and the mystery of godliness; the more we are acquainted with it, the more satisfaction will it afford to our souls; and, however defective our measure of it may be here, the least attainment contains a divine hope, that hereafter it will be complete and perfect, when we shall know even as we are known.He seals the argument by reminding us that true profit is found only above the sun.
The text of the discourse is, Vanity of vanities, all is vanity; and this is redoubled, to shew his own deep conviction of the truth, and to affect his hearers with a sense of it. The world and all the things of it are utterly unsatisfactory; they perish in the using, afford no solid comfort to the soul, and disappoint all those who place their confidence in them, or expect happiness from them; and they, who have with greatest eagerness strove to quench their thirst at those broken cisterns, by sad experience have found them vanity of vanities: none had ever greater abilities to gratify his desires, none ever with more boundless indulgence sought satisfaction in earthly things, than Solomon; and, after long proof, this is his deliberate conclusion. 3. He appeals to universal experience for confirmation of the truth. What profit hath a man of all his labour which he taketh under the sun?
Respond
1. Where in my daily labour do I still seek lasting profit under the sun?
2. How does the knowledge of Christ already answer the grief that increased wisdom once brought?
3. What one practice this week will help me labour for the portion that endures above the sun?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the honest searching of thy servant Solomon and for the faithful exposition given by Bishop Coke. Teach us to number our days aright and to cease from every broken cistern. Grant that the wisdom which begins and ends in Jesus may fill the empty places of our hearts. May we labour not for the wind but for that eternal inheritance kept for us in heaven. Through the same Lord Jesus Christ, who with thee and the Holy Spirit liveth and reigneth, one God, world without end. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →