← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › James

James 5 — with Whedon

James 5Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the heritage of Methodist Episcopal teaching and forthright Arminian-Wesleyan conviction, we open Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments to hear its measured exposition of James chapter 5. Whedon’s careful attention to the apostolic word guides the Church in patience, prayer, and holy living amid trial and oppression. May the Spirit who inspired the epistle also quicken these ancient insights for faithful practice today.
Read
With reverent hearts let us now read the whole of James chapter 5, attending to its warnings, its call to patient endurance, and its instructions concerning prayer and the restoration of wanderers, that the word may search and strengthen us.
Study
Whedon opens by confronting the rich oppressors of the apostolic age. Verse 1. 4 . Denunciatory appeal to the rich for their oppression, self-indulgence, and persecution , James 5:1-6 . 1 . Go to now Note on James 4:13 . Rich men The rich men of St. James were something different from the honest and charitable possessors of wealth of which our Christianity has since furnished so many specimens. They displayed great outward pomp, James 2:2-3 ; they were political dynasts, ( καταδυναστευουσιν ,) or potentates, James 2:6 ; they were blasphemers and persecutors, James 2:7 ; they used their power to defraud the labourers upon their broad acres, James 5:4 ; they held judicial positions, and used them to put the just man to death, James 5:6 . They are, therefore, the Jewish ruling tyrant-class of the day, called rich men , because their gorgeous display of pomp and opulence is their prominent aspect to the Christian eye. Of the rich men of St. James’s day in the Roman empire generally, see note on James 5:6 . But the strangest thing in interpreting the words of St. James is, the fact that leading commentators imagine these rich men to be Christians! Howl and shall come are both participles in the present tense. A literal rendering of the whole verse would be, Ho, now, ye rich men, weep! howling upon the miseries coming on. The howling aggravates the weep , likening them to a pack of eastern dogs. He then turns from persecutors to the persecuted brethren. Verse 7. 5 . The Christian sufferer under these wrongs pointed to the judgment day , James 5:7-11 . 7 . Brethren Our apostle turns in contrast, from the rich men to the just men; from the persecutors to the persecuted. But what shall we think of commentators who are not quite sure that the rich men and the brethren are not the same! Be patient To the Church in all ages the judgment seat of Christ, even though long millenniums distant, is, conceptually, near at hand. See supplementary note to Matthew 25:0 , and note on 2 Peter 3:8 . Coming The PAROUSIA; the second advent, the day when the human race, in resurrection state, stands in the presence of its final Judge. Observe, again, that, unlike last days , in James 5:3 , and day of slaughter , in James 5:5 , this Parousia has the Greek article. This indicates that the two former were indefinite events, and the last a definite. Whedon next unfolds the consolations provided for the afflicted and the sick. Verse 13. CONCLUSIONS 1. Consolations for the sad, the merry, the sick; the prayer of faith , James 5:13-18 . 13 . Our apostle now shows better methods than swearing to give vent to our moods. Afflicted Suffers one any evil? Let him not swear, but pray! Merry Cheery, in good spirits? Let him not blaspheme, but sing psalms . These are the richest methods of letting forth our abounding nature within the sphere of the blessed and divine. No need of oaths, or bacchanalian riot, in order to the most joyous and happy activities of our souls and voices. Finally he treats the reclaiming of the one who wanders from the truth. Verse 19. 2 . The reclaim of the wanderer, and its reward , 19, 20. 19 . Brethren In the closing two verses our apostle completes his series of fraternal suggestions of Christian duty among themselves, in line with James 5:16 ; James 5:12 ; James 5:10 , and many preceding points in the entire epistle. This closing suggestion is of immense importance, touching the restoration of the wandering backslider. Any one of you Bringing the point closely down to each one, as an individual duty and reward. Err A passive verb, and rightly rendered by Alford be seduced. From the truth Not merely from Christian doctrine, but from that word of truth ( James 1:18 ) which is the life-principle of the soul, without which the man is sure to become, practically, as next verse, a sinner , and will relapse into death . Convert him From error and sin back to the truth . A clear implication that sin and death would be the result of his apostasy.
Consider
Whedon presses the nature of the prayer of faith that saves. Verse 16. 16 . In order that the sins may be known and prayed for, confess your faults This not in the public congregation, where the effect would be bad; but individually, one to another , in a most sincere and penitent way. We now have a fuller description of the nature of that prayer of faith that will save . The effectual The Greek word (taken in the middle voice) is defined effective, which makes it almost a tautology. We prefer, with the old English commentators Hammond, Bull, Benson, and Macknight, to take it in the passive voice, so that it would signify energized, or inwrought, that is, by the divine Spirit. The Greek commentator OEcumenius considers it passive, and makes it mean energized, that is, by the co-operative prayer of the patient himself. And Michaelis (quoted by Huther) defines the phrase, preces agitante Spiritu sancto effusae, prayers poured forth prompted by the Holy Spirit. He concludes by declaring the eternal reward of converting the sinner. Verse 20. 20 . Let him know Or, by a reading preferred by Alford, know ye. What now follows is stated as a universal truth, implying that this individual case would be included under it. The sinner Rather, a sinner , whoever and wherever he may be. Error of his way Error , or wandering, is the characteristic quality of the way he is pursuing. Shall save The future far reaching beyond the present. Death The eternal consequent, commenced here and perpetuated hereafter, of unpardoned sin. Hide Cover from sight. So Psalms 32:1-2 , “Blessed is he whose transgression is forgiven, whose sin is covered.” And Psalms 85:2 , “Thou hast forgiven the iniquity of thy people; thou hast covered all their sin.” The sins which he shall cover are, of course, the sins of the sinner . The idea of some commentators, that the converter will thereby cover his own sins, is unevangelical.
Respond
1. Where in my life do I most need the patience Whedon commends before the coming of the Lord? 2. How shall I cultivate the Spirit-wrought prayer that the commentary describes? 3. Whom has the Lord placed before me that I may seek to restore in the spirit of James 5:19-20?
Pray
O Lord of Sabaoth, who judges the oppressor and sustains the just, grant us patience until the Parousia of thy Son. Pour upon thy Church the prayer of faith that saves the sick and restores the wanderer. Keep us from murmuring and from every oath, that our yea may be yea and our nay, nay. Raise up among us elders who pray with holy fervor, and give each believer courage to convert the sinner from the error of his way. So may many sins be covered and souls delivered from death, to the praise of thy mercy and the glory of thy name. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →