Eterniseed › Curriculum › Sirach
Sirach 19-21 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Sirach chapters 19 through 21 form a compact treatise on the perils of unchecked speech, the hidden growth of venial faults, and the contrast between genuine wisdom and its counterfeit. The sage repeatedly warns that small indulgences or careless words erode integrity long before dramatic sins appear. He also shows how the prudent person restrains both tongue and temper, while the fool broadcasts every thought and thereby invites contempt. These chapters invite the reader to examine daily habits of conversation and self-disclosure, recognizing that authentic piety is measured less by outward reputation than by interior fidelity. Throughout, the text insists that true wisdom always seeks the good of others rather than personal display.
Read
Read Sirach 19-21 in the Douay-Rheims or Catholic Public Domain Version. Notice the recurring counsel against revealing secrets or faults, the vivid images of fire, lions, and crumbling houses that depict the consequences of sin, and the steady distinction between the wise person who listens before speaking and the fool whose words bring only confusion. Observe also how the author returns again and again to the theme of timely correction offered with gentleness, and the warning that even the just may fall yet recover through prompt repentance.
Study
Haydock’s commentary supplies several concise observations that clarify the practical moral teaching of these chapters.
The opening warning about repeated small expenses prepares the reader to grasp how venial faults accumulate into spiritual ruin.
Little. Small expenses, often repeated, will ruin an estate, (Haydock) and the neglect of venial sins is of the most dangerous consequence. (Calmet) — The best way to avoid great faults, is to guard against small ones. (Worthington)A second observation concerns the proper limits of self-disclosure and the danger of boasting even about sins one has not committed.
Not. Only to God and his minister. Friends do not require to be informed of such things. Greek, “disclose not the conduct of others.” — Be. Greek, “be not.” Do not boast of sins which thou hast not committed, (Calmet) as St. Augustine did before his conversion. (Haydock) — But the Vulgate seems preferable. (Calmet) — In ordinary conversation to reveal our faults would be dangerous, but not in confession, or in religious orders, for advancement in virtue. (Worthington)Turning to chapter 20, the commentary highlights the value of a timely and humble apology that restores both friendship and divine favor.
Prayer. A friend’s excuses must be heard. (Calmet) — Greek, “and he who apologises shall be preserved from ruin.” Grabe adds, “how good is it for one who has been rebuked,” &c., ver. 4. (Haydock) — Thus the guilty merit pardon, and the innocent obtain a greater reward, and satisfy for former offences. (Worthington)Finally, the notes on chapter 21 remind us that even the just are not immune to occasional faults, yet they differ from the wicked by their readiness to rise again.
Thee. The just may offend: but the wicked relapse continually.
Consider
These passages together sketch a portrait of the prudent believer who guards the tongue, corrects gently, and refuses to parade either real or imagined faults. Such a person recognizes that every word carries weight and that silence often serves charity better than speech. The commentary underscores that concealment of sin is never an end in itself; rather, it must be joined to sincere amendment and, when appropriate, to sacramental confession. At the same time the reader is cautioned against judging others solely by outward demeanor, since appearances can mislead. The overall effect is an invitation to cultivate both interior honesty before God and measured speech before neighbor.
Respond
In what ordinary conversations do you find yourself tempted to repeat another’s fault or to boast of your own shortcomings? How might you practice the gentle correction described in these chapters without slipping into either harshness or timidity?
Pray
O Lord, grant us the prudence to weigh our words and to keep silent when speech would wound charity. Draw us to bring even our smaller faults promptly into the light of your mercy, that the wisdom of Sirach may take root in our conduct and make us both hearers and doers of your truth. Through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints, keep us faithful to your commandments. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →