Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel
1 Samuel 27-28 — with Coke
Opening
In the quiet hours of daily devotion we turn again to Thomas Coke's Commentary on the Holy Bible. As Wesley's trusted associate and the first Methodist bishop, Coke brings both scholarly care and warm evangelical spirit to the sacred text. His reflections on 1 Samuel invite us to trace the movements of grace and the perils of unbelief in the lives of David and Saul. May the same Spirit who guided the commentator open our hearts to receive the word with humility and faith.
Read
Let us now read 1 Samuel chapters 27 and 28, listening for the steady voice of Scripture. As the narrative unfolds, notice the contrasting paths of a man after God's own heart and a king who has grieved the Spirit. Read slowly, allowing the Holy Spirit to search the motives of our own hearts while the story moves from Ziklag to En-dor.
Study
Coke opens his treatment of chapter 27 by examining David's inward resolution.
Verse 1. 1 Samuel 27:1 . And David said in his heart, I shall now perish — David, tired of wandering, weary of struggling with Saul's implacable spirit, sensible of the unequal conflict between too dangerous generosity, and too relentless malice, and unwilling longer to subsist by the spoils of his enemies or the bounty of his friends, resolves at last to quit his country, and throw himself once more under the protection of its enemies. This resolution has been generally censured, on account of his neglecting to consult God, either by his priest, or by his prophet, before he fixed upon it. God had before commanded him to go into the land of Judah, 1Sa 22:5 and surely he should not have left that place to go into a heathen country, without a like divine command, or at least permission. Wherefore most writers ascribe this resolution to a deficiency in grace, and a want of proper confidence in the protection of that God who had so often and so signally delivered him in the greatest exigencies.He next considers the ambiguous reply David offered Achish.
Verse 10. 1 Samuel 27:10 . Against the south, &c.— The answer was true, but ambiguous; for all those people actually dwelt on the south of Judah. But Achish understood the answer as meaning that the incursion was made on Judah, on the Jerahmeelites and the Kenites themselves, though David asserted no such thing. David, therefore, did not utter a falsity, as some writers suppose, and labour to palliate or to condemn. If he was to blame, it was for giving an ambiguous answer to a question which he was not obliged to give a direct reply to. Achish well knew that David had made an incursion upon some of the neighbouring tribes, and in this David did not deceive him; but he thought he was no ways obliged to tell him who they were; and therefore said only, in general, that they were such as dwelt on the south of Judah. Dr. Delaney observes upon this deception which David appears to have passed upon Achish, "I will not stand up in a strict defence of this conduct. It was indeed a deception; but if it injured nobody, as I apprehend it did not, I must own that I am utterly at a loss what degree of guilt to charge upon it. This must be allowed, that all habits of deception have a natural tendency to bias the mind, and warp it from truth, and therefore ought carefully to be avoided, even where the deception is innocent," or (I should rather have said,) harmless. Note; Let the sins of great and good men be looked upon, not as an exculpation for our imitation of them, but as an admonition to avoid them.Coke then turns to Saul's growing terror and the silence of heaven.
To accumulate his miseries, he receives no answer from God; he is vouchsafed no divine vision in a dream; has no Urim to consult, since the priest is fled with it to David; nor prophet to advise or direct him. At last, he is resolved to have recourse to the devil for advice; but his own former edicts against sorcerers make it difficult to find one, as he had, in pretended zeal for God, or at Samuel's instigation, put to death all such abominable workers of iniquity throughout the land of Israel. Note; (1.) They who refuse to seek God while he may be found, will cry in vain when he refuses to answer. (2.) The troubles of the wicked are doubly aggravated by the terrors of an evil conscience. (3.) To the very sins against which men professed once to be most zealous, they will readily abandon themselves, when they have thrown off the cloke of religion.He carefully weighs the character of the appearance granted at En-dor.
Our translators have inserted the particle when in the 12th verse, which embarrasses the sense, and implies, that some space of time had passed between Saul's request, and the appearance of Samuel: whereas the original text stands thus, When Saul said, bring me up Saumel, then immediately follows, and the woman saw Samuel, and cried, &c. She saw an apparition that she did not expect; she knew the prophet; she knew the veneration that Saul had for him; and she knew that her art had never exhibited a person of that figure to her. Various have been the opinions concerning this apparition of Samuel. From the manner in which we have interpreted these verses, and which seems to be just, there appears no doubt that this was a real apparition of Samuel, sent by the immediate intervention of God: for one cannot suppose, either that it was a trick put upon Saul by this sorceress, or that it was a demon which thus assumed the form of Samuel.
Consider
Coke presses the solemn certainty of the prophetic word spoken to Saul.
Verse 19. 1 Samuel 28:19 . To-morrow shalt thou and thy sons be with me — Samuel predicts two things. I. That Saul, and his three sons who were with him in the camp, should be with him; i.e . should, like him, be in another world, or should die. II. That they should die on the morrow, or rather, very shortly; for that is the signification of the word מחר machar, in many places of Scripture. See Exo 13:14 and Joshua 4:6 . It is probable, however, that the word in this place may be taken in its literal sense of to-morrow. These predictions of Samuel evidently proved that he spoke by God's order; for he foretells, first, the victory of the Philistines; secondly, the death of Saul and his sons; and thirdly, the advantages which the Philistines should derive from their victory. See chap. 1 Samuel 31:7 . And it is surprising, that after such plain predictions as these, which could come only from God, any person should imagine that this apparition of Samuel was either a human or a diabolical imposture.He closes with a grave warning against grieving the Holy Spirit.
And, as this practice was so general among the heathens, it is plain that the immortality of the soul was generally received as a determined principle. See Le Clerc and Calmet. Note; (1.) They who depart from God, leave their own mercies. A miserable life, and a more miserable death, is their wretched portion. (2.) When a man is given up to despair, he rushes on his own destruction, as the horse rusheth into the battle. (3.) Let every man who reads Saul's end, tremble at the thought of grieving the holy Spirit of God, lest he be thus forsaken, and left to the wickedness and despair of his own heart.
Respond
1. Where in my present circumstances am I tempted to act from fear rather than from fresh seeking of the Lord?
2. How do I guard my speech when an ambiguous answer seems safer than the plain truth?
3. What practices of repentance keep me from the path that led Saul into despair?
Pray
Gracious Lord, we thank thee for the faithful labors of thy servant Thomas Coke. Keep us, we beseech thee, from the unbelief that made David seek refuge among the Philistines and from the hardness that drove Saul to forbidden arts. Grant us instead a steady confidence in thy promises and a tender conscience that cannot rest when thou art grieved. May the same grace that preserved David in every trial uphold us until we see thy face. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →