Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Samuel
1 Samuel 19-20 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Today we enter the turbulent world of 1 Samuel chapters 19 and 20 through the lens of Haydock's Catholic Family Bible Commentary. This rich compilation gathers the insights of centuries of Catholic scholars to unpack the jealousy of Saul, the loyalty of Jonathan, and the perils facing David. Haydock's notes help us see both the human drama and the divine protection at work. As we study, pray, and reflect together, may these ancient verses speak to our own lives of faith and friendship.
Read
Take up your Bible and read 1 Samuel chapters 19 and 20 slowly and prayerfully. Notice the shifting alliances, the narrow escapes, and the deep bond between David and Jonathan. Let the narrative unfold in your mind as you listen for God's hand guiding his anointed one through danger and uncertainty.
Study
Haydock opens by examining Jonathan's complex position between his father and David.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Jonathan. He was most interested, as David might be feared as a competitor; (Menochius) and, under the cloak of friendship, he might more easily destroy him. Saul was a stranger to the generous sentiments of his son, or he would never have made the proposal. (Haydock) --- Grotius compares him with Germanicus. (Calmet)Haydock next addresses Michol's actions to protect her husband.
Sick. This is an officious lie. She tells another to excuse herself, ver. 17. The children of Saul strive to prevent their father's cruelty, by taking part with the innocent David. (Haydock) --- It is thought that David composed the 68th Psalm, Eripe, &c., on this occasion. (Calmet)On the messengers and Saul, the commentary notes the surprising effect of the prophetic spirit.
Prophesying. That is, singing praises to God by a divine impulse. God was pleased on this occasion that both Saul's messengers and himself should experience the like impulse, that he might understand, by this instance of the divine power, how vain are the designs of man against him whom God protects. (Challoner) --- The messengers did not return. (Menochius) --- They were seized by the spirit only when they arrived at Najoth. But Saul felt the impression even at Socho, threw aside his garments, and began to act and to speak as one inspired. (Calmet)Haydock then turns to the new moon feast and its significance for the story.
To-morrow is the new moon. The neomenia, or first day of the moon, kept according to the law, as a festival; and therefore Saul feasted on that day; and expected the attendance of his family. (Challoner) (Numbers x. 10.) --- Moon. Literally, "calends," a Greek word, intimating that the people were informed, or "called" together, on that occasion; as many nations follow the lunar system in the regulation of the year. (Haydock) --- The Rabbins say that people were stationed on the highest hills to observe the first appearance of the moon, and to give notice of it. But for fear of a mistake, two days were observed, as here we see that Saul gave a feast for such a length of time. This, however, is very uncertain. David speaks without any reference to the watchmen, as of a thing well known to all. The reason of Saul's feasting two days, was because one of them was the sabbath. The following work-day David came to Nobe, (ver. 19,) and partook of the loaves which had been changed on the sabbath day, chap. xxi. 6., and Leviticus xxiv. 8. --- Sit. The custom of sitting at table seems to have been more ancient than that of lying. The Persians chiefly introduced the latter. They had very low tables, so that one of them placed under the feet of Alexander, when he sat upon the throne of Darius, which was too high for him. (Curtius v.) Both customs frequently prevailed at the same time, Ecclesiasticus ix. 12., and xxxi. 12. Women probably always sat, as the Chaldean says Esther did, Esther vii. 8. See Atheneus i. 14. V. Max. ii. 1. --- Day. The second of the month, after the sabbath was ended. (Calmet) --- Pezron thinks that both the last and first days of the month were festivals. (Du Hamel)
Consider
Haydock reflects on the sacred covenant sworn between the two friends.
Die. Hebrew literally, "If I live, thou shalt not shew me, &c....and if I die, (15) thou shalt not," &c. It seems there is a negation too much. Jonathan requests that David would shew mercy to him and to his family; or he is willing that neither should partake of his kindness, if he prove a traitor to his friend. (Calmet) --- Protestants, "And thou shalt not only, while yet I live, shew me the kindness of the Lord, that I die not: (15) But also thou shalt not cut off they kindness from my house for ever, no not when the Lord hath cut off," &c. (Haydock)
Respond
How does Jonathan's loyalty challenge me to stand with friends in difficulty? Where do I see God's protection at work even when human plans seem to prevail? What covenant promises in my own life call for greater fidelity today?
Pray
Lord God, as you shielded David through Jonathan’s steadfast covenant of friendship, deepen in us a loyal trust in your providence and a faithful love that seeks your will above every fear. Through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints, grant us grace to keep our promises with integrity and to walk in the truth that glorifies you alone. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →