← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Tobit

Tobit 3-4 — drawing on Aquinas (Summa II-II q.101 pietas + q.83 prayer)

Tobit 3-4Saint Thomas Aquinas — Summa Theologiae + Catena Aurea + Commentary on Sentences22 min
Opening
The third and fourth chapters of Tobit set forth the two great prayers of the narrative — Tobit's lament in his blindness and Sarah's lament under the Asmodean trial — followed by Tobit's catechetical instruction of his son Tobiah in the order of filial piety and the duties of a faithful Israelite. Drawing on Aquinas's treatment of pietas in Summa Theologiae II-II q.101 and his sustained treatise on prayer in II-II q.83, we may approach these chapters not as two unrelated devotional episodes but as the structural articulation of the virtue Aquinas calls pietas, by which the soul renders due reverence to those to whom it is bound by the deepest natural and covenantal ties — to God most of all, then to parents, then to country, then to the wider family of those who share in our covenant. Tobit's instruction to Tobiah is one of the great catechetical discourses of the Old Testament; Aquinas's scholastic articulation of the virtue it embodies provides the categorical clarity by which the contemporary reader may receive it.
Read
Read Tobit chapters 3 and 4 with attention to the prayers of Tobit and Sarah and to the catechetical discourse of Tobit to Tobiah. In chapter three, mark Tobit's prayer of distress in his blindness — his recital of God's righteous judgments, his confession of his own and his ancestors' sins, his plea that the Lord take his life rather than allow him to bear continued reproach; the simultaneous prayer of Sarah in distant Ecbatana in her chamber after she has been reproached by her maid for the death of seven husbands at the hands of the demon Asmodeus; her plea also for death rather than continued reproach; the angelic determination in heaven that Raphael is to be sent to heal both. In chapter four, attend to Tobit's belief that his prayer for death will be answered and his consequent summoning of Tobiah to receive his final instructions — the recital of the deposit at Rages with Gabael, then the long catechetical discourse: bury me with proper respect, honor your mother all her days and remember her, give alms from your substance, do not store up evil for the day of necessity, avoid all uncleanness, do to no one what you yourself hate, drink your wine in measure, give your bread to the hungry, take a wife of your own kindred, do not turn your face from any poor man.
Study
Aquinas's treatise on pietas in Summa II-II q.101 articulates the virtue precisely. In q.101 a.1 he asks whether pietas (familial and filial piety) is a virtue distinct from religion (which is the virtue rendering due worship to God). His answer is yes: pietas is a special virtue, distinct from religion though analogous to it, by which the soul renders due reverence and service to those to whom it owes itself by natural origin — primarily to parents and to country (patria). In q.101 a.2 he treats the act of pietas: it consists in worship (cultus) of parents, by which is meant honor, reverence, support in their need, obedience in matters proper to their authority, and the carrying forward of the family memory. In q.101 a.4 he raises the difficult case of whether the pietas-precept binds even when parents are unworthy or dishonorable. His response, following Aristotle and the patristic tradition, is that the duty of pietas in its substance (honor, support in need, the preservation of life) continues even when parents have failed in their corresponding duties, though it may be modulated in its mode (a son need not obey a parent's command to sin, but he must continue to honor the parent's life and to provide for the parent's necessities). Tobit's instruction to Tobiah is the practical embodiment of this scholastic articulation. The first command, "bury me with proper respect," is the paradigmatic act of pietas pertaining to the moment of death: q.101 a.2 explicitly mentions the proper burial of parents as the conclusive act of filial piety. The second command, "honor your mother all her days and remember her," extends pietas to the surviving parent in a manner Aquinas treats in q.101 a.3 as a particular obligation when the children's labor is the principal support of an elderly parent's life. The middle commands — give alms, avoid uncleanness, do unto no man what you yourself hate, drink in measure, give bread to the hungry — extend beyond pietas into the wider field of charity (II-II q.32 already considered in the preceding lesson) and the cardinal virtues. The closing command, "take a wife of your own kindred," falls under the question of consanguinity in marriage that Aquinas treats in the Supplement q.54-55, where he distinguishes between the natural prohibitions of incest (which forbid marriage within certain degrees of consanguinity by divine and natural law) and the ecclesiastical prohibitions (which extend the prohibitions further as a matter of canonical discipline). The pre-Mosaic patriarchal custom of marrying within one's tribe but outside one's immediate household — the principle Tobit follows when he directs Tobiah to take a wife from the seed of his fathers — is the substrate from which the Mosaic and later canonical prohibitions developed, and Aquinas's treatment in Supplement q.54 takes the Old Testament patriarchal pattern as one historical phase of the working out of the natural and divine prohibitions. The prayers of Tobit and Sarah deserve special attention in light of Aquinas's treatise on prayer in II-II q.83. In q.83 a.1 he distinguishes prayer from the wider category of devotion: prayer is the elevation of the mind to God to ask of him fitting things. In q.83 a.15-16 he asks whether prayer must be confident and whether prayer should be vocal or merely interior. The prayers of Tobit and Sarah are both confidently addressed to the God of their fathers, both invoke the divine attributes of justice and mercy, both confess sin and request relief. They differ in their petition: Tobit asks for death, and Sarah asks for death. Aquinas would recognize in this petition a difficulty: q.83 a.6 asks whether one should ask for temporal things in prayer, and his response is that temporal goods may be asked but only insofar as they conduce to the soul's good or are willed by God. Asking for death as relief from reproach is a particular and grave species of petition that Aquinas treats in I-II q.5 (on the soul's natural ordination toward beatitude) and in II-II q.18 a.3 (on whether hope may be lost): the petition for death must be ordered to the deeper hope for resurrection and for participation in the beatific vision, not to the despair that would simply prefer non-being to reproach. The inspired narrative of Tobit answers this difficulty implicitly: God does not grant either Tobit's or Sarah's request for death; instead he sends Raphael to bring about the healing and the marriage that will restore both households. The Church reads this divine response as a school of the principle Aquinas articulates in q.83 a.15: prayer is heard according to the good of the petitioner, which the petitioner himself may not yet perceive. Augustine in De Sermone Domini in Monte 2.10 (which Aquinas cites in q.83 a.15) had taught the same principle in commenting on the Lord's Prayer: we ask of God what he has taught us to ask, and what he himself has provided we may rightly ask for, and even when we ask amiss the Father gives us what we would have asked had we understood our need. The Catena Aurea on Matthew 6:9-13 (the Lord's Prayer) preserves this Augustinian formula at length, and Aquinas uses it as one of the foundational principles of his treatise on prayer.
Consider
Drawing on Aquinas's distinction between pietas and religio in II-II q.101 a.1, consider whether the structure of your own life acknowledges the distinct virtue of pietas as a real virtue in its own right. The contemporary culture has tended to collapse pietas into a generic warmth toward parents or into a sentimental affection that does not bear the actual obligations Aquinas enumerates. The substantive duties of pietas — honor, reverence, support in need, the preservation of the family memory, the eventual proper burial — are not optional acts of affection but binding obligations of a special virtue ordered to the natural and covenantal bonds within which the soul comes into being. Have you grown intentional about the discharge of these obligations toward your own parents, living or deceased, or have you allowed the surrounding culture's loss of pietas to dim your own? Consider too Tobit's catechetical discourse in chapter four. The form is striking — a dying father gathering his son to recite the practical commandments by which the son's life should be ordered. Aquinas would recognize in this scene a particular instance of the act of pietas extended to one's posterity (q.101 a.3 mentions the duty to provide for one's offspring). Have you yourself composed or considered composing the equivalent of Tobit's instruction for your own children? The Catholic tradition has cultivated this form across centuries — the spiritual testaments of saints and lay faithful, the deathbed instructions, the written letters of fathers to sons (Saint Louis IX to his son Philip is the most famous medieval example). Consider finally the petition of Tobit and Sarah for death. Aquinas's teaching in II-II q.83 a.6 and a.15 is delicate but firm: temporal goods may be asked in prayer but only insofar as they conduce to the soul's good, and the petition for death must be ordered to the deeper hope for resurrection. Where in your own prayer have you petitioned amiss — asking for relief that would not in fact serve your soul, or asking for ends that would not be ordered to the beatific vision? The inspired narrative of Tobit demonstrates the divine mercy of answering the deeper need rather than the surface petition.
Respond
Compose this week a brief spiritual testament for your children or godchildren or those younger persons whose formation falls under your care. Follow the structure of Tobit's discourse in chapter four: name what you ask for the disposition of your remains, what you ask for the care of those who will outlive you, what virtues you commend to those you address, and what concrete practices you exhort them to. The discipline of writing in this register clarifies the actual order of one's own pietas as Aquinas articulates it in II-II q.101.
Pray
Heavenly Father, source of every grace and end of all virtue, hear the prayers we lift to you in affliction as Tobit and Sarah did, and conform our hearts to the piety by which we honor you above all and render due reverence to those bound to us by blood and covenant. By the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and the communion of saints, strengthen us to pray with persevering trust and to live in filial devotion to your holy will. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen.

Saint Thomas Aquinas — Summa Theologiae + Catena Aurea + Commentary on Sentences · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →