Eterniseed › Curriculum › 2 Samuel
Clean of Innocent Blood: The King Who Will Not Reign by Murder
Opening
As the house of Saul wanes and the house of David waxes, Abner — Saul's great captain — defects to David and undertakes to bring all Israel under his rule. But before the kingdom can be made whole, two murders stain the road to the throne, and the chapters turn on a single question: will David seize the crown by blood, or keep his hands clean? Joab, who had every motive of envy, draws Abner aside and kills him under the pretext of avenging his brother Asahel. Blessed Theodoret of Cyrus sees through the pretext to the true cause: not justice but envy, not vengeance but love of power, for Joab feared that Abner would be honored with the generalship he coveted. And David's response is the heart of the matter. The king who was excellent in all things mourned the one unjustly slain and loaded the one who slew him with solemn curses, declaring himself and his kingdom innocent before the Lord of the blood of Abner. When the murderers of Ish-bosheth come bearing the head of Saul's son, thinking to hand David a whole kingdom, he has them put to death and gives the head of his rival an honorable burial. Theodoret's portrait is of a righteous king who will not be made king by murder — and so a true type of the Lord Christ, who founded His Kingdom not by shedding the blood of His enemies but by the shedding of His own, and whose throne, being clean of all injustice, stands forever.
Read
Read 2 Samuel 3–4. "There was long war between the house of Saul and the house of David: but David waxed stronger and stronger, and the house of Saul waxed weaker and weaker." Abner falls out with Ish-bosheth and comes to David at Hebron, promising "to bring about all Israel unto thee." David receives him in peace and sends him away. But Joab returns, takes Abner aside "to speak with him quietly, and smote him there… for the blood of Asahel his brother." David, hearing of it, cries out: "I and my kingdom are guiltless before the Lord for ever from the blood of Abner the son of Ner: let it rest on the head of Joab, and on all his father's house." He commands mourning, follows the bier weeping, and laments: "Died Abner as a fool dieth? Thy hands were not bound, nor thy feet put into fetters: as a man falleth before wicked men, so fellest thou." And "all the people took notice of it, and it pleased them." Then two men murder Ish-bosheth in his bed and bring his head to Hebron, expecting reward; but David answers, "When one told me, saying, Behold, Saul is dead… I took hold of him, and slew him… How much more, when wicked men have slain a righteous person in his own house upon his bed?" — and he has them executed, and buries the head of Ish-bosheth honorably.
Study
Theodoret asks the plain question — why did Joab kill Abner? — and refuses the easy answer Joab himself gave. The avenging of Asahel was only a pretext; the real spring of the murder was envy and the lust for power, for Joab knew Abner would be rewarded with the command he wanted for himself:
His pretext was the slaughter of Asahel, but the true cause was envy.And so, says Theodoret, the murder was armed by ambition:
Love of power, therefore, armed him for the murder.Against this Theodoret sets the conduct of the king, in whom he finds an entire integrity: David neither shared in the crime nor profited by it, but mourned its victim and cursed its author:
But the king, who was most excellent in all things, both mourned the one unjustly slain and subjected the one who unjustly slew him to many and various curses.In his lament Theodoret hears David weighing his words justly, mourning Abner not as a Nabal justly struck down by God, but as one valiant and innocent — not bound or fettered like a captive of war, but felled by a feigned friendship.
Consider
The whole movement of these chapters is the making of a king who refuses to be made by murder. Twice the throne is offered to David through blood — Abner's death would clear his rivals, Ish-bosheth's death would hand him the kingdom whole — and twice David turns from the blood and toward justice, mourning the slain, cursing or executing the slayers, declaring himself "guiltless before the Lord for ever." Theodoret notes that the king's very grief drew the nation to him, for honest sorrow over an unjust death is a kind of testimony:
The king, grieving, mourned; and the mourning increased the people's goodwill.And when the murderers of Ish-bosheth came expecting reward, David executed them, yet would not let his hatred follow his rival past death, but buried him with honor:
But while he slew them in this way, he gave the head of his enemy to an honourable burial.Theodoret's careful reading of motive — envy beneath the pretext, love of power arming the hand — only sharpens the contrast: where Joab's heart was bent on advantage, David's was bent on innocence. And here the history opens, as it always does for the Antiochene fathers, toward the Son of David. For the Lord Christ too came to a throne, and to Him too a kingdom could have been seized by force: He could have called legions of angels, His followers were ready to take up the sword. But He rebuked the sword in Gethsemane, healed the ear that Peter cut, and went to His Kingdom not by shedding His enemies' blood but by pouring out His own. The throne David would not stain is the figure of the throne Christ founded in perfect righteousness — a Kingdom "not of this world," that did not fight (John 18:36), and that therefore endures forever. Pilate could find no fault in Him; David could declare himself guiltless of Abner's blood; and the King of kings reigns clean of all injustice, having conquered not by killing but by being killed, and rising.
Respond
Examine the pretexts your own heart manufactures. Joab told himself, and told the world, that he was avenging a brother; Theodoret names the truth — it was envy, and the love of power armed his hand. How often do we cloak ambition, resentment, or self-advancement in the language of justice and duty, and so commit in good conscience what God will not bless? Learn from David to want clean hands more than you want the prize. There were crowns within his reach that he would not touch because blood lay on them; there are advancements within your reach that you must not take because they would cost another's good, or your own integrity. Do not be made great by anyone's ruin. And when you cannot punish the wrong done by those "too hard" for you, do as David did: hand the matter over to God — "the Lord shall reward the doer of evil according to his wickedness" — and refuse to let bitterness turn you into the very thing you hate. Mourn what should be mourned, honor even a fallen rival, keep your conscience guiltless before the Lord. So shall you walk toward whatever throne God has appointed you — in your home, your work, your calling — by the road the Son of David walked: not by seizing, not by murder of body or of name, but by righteousness, which alone makes a kingdom that lasts.
Pray
O Lord, righteous Judge, who didst keep Thy servant David guiltless of innocent blood and wouldst not let him be made king by murder, and who in Thy Son didst found a Kingdom not by the sword but by the pouring out of Thine own most precious Blood: cleanse my heart of every pretext by which I dress up envy as justice and ambition as duty. Give me clean hands, that I may never be made great by another's ruin, nor seize by wrong what only Thou shouldst give. When I cannot right the wrongs done by those too strong for me, teach me to commit all vengeance into Thy hands and to keep my soul free of bitterness. Let me mourn what is to be mourned and honor even a fallen adversary, walking toward every appointed throne by the road of righteousness alone. For Thy Kingdom, O Christ, is established for ever because it is clean of all injustice; reign Thou so within me. To Thee, O Christ our God, with the Father and the all-holy Spirit, be glory now and ever, and unto ages of ages. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →