Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians
1 Corinthians 6 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal teaching we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s forthright Arminian-Wesleyan exposition of First Corinthians chapter six calls the church to remember its high standing in Christ and to reject every compromise with the world’s courts or its sensualities. His words guide us to see how the saints already reign with their Lord and why every member of the body must glorify God.
Read
Let us now read First Corinthians chapter six in full, listening for the apostle’s double summons: first that believers settle disputes within the church, and second that they flee every form of uncleanness. As we hear the text, may the same Spirit who inspired Paul prepare our hearts to receive Whedon’s clear and searching comments.
Study
Whedon opens by framing Paul’s second response to the rumor of brother going to law with brother.
Verses 1-8. PAUL’S SECOND RESPONSE: TO THE RUMOUR OF BROTHER GOING TO LAW WITH BROTHER, 1 Corinthians 6:1-20 . a. The presumption of humbling Christianity before heathendom, 1 Corinthians 6:1-8 . The assertion of the last chapter is, positively, that the Church is judge within itself of its own. The assertion now is, negatively, that it is an un-warrantable thing to arraign a Christian before a pagan judge.He then turns to the cluster of vices that endanger the kingdom.
Verses 9-11. b. Sensualities and other vices exclude from the kingdom of God, 1 Corinthians 6:9-11 . St. Paul has just been holding up the highest ideal of the kingdom of God the glorious judgeship [rulership] of the saints as reason why his Corinthians should not humble each other before pagan courts. Their tendency to do so directs his thoughts to that cluster of vices, especially sensuality, by which, amid the dissoluteness of Corinth, they were in imminent danger of forfeiting their title to God’s glorious kingdom. Hence these words of earnest warning are pervaded throughout with a secret reference to their easy remissness in regard to the fornicator.Next he addresses the excuse of natural gratification under the law of the expedient.
Verses 12-20. c. Nor can sensualities be excused by the lawfulness of all natural gratification, 1 Corinthians 6:12-20 . A doctrine by which the Corinthian Antinomians, whose views of Christian ethics were yet unshaped, were deceiving themselves, ( 1 Corinthians 6:9 ,) is now stated and explained. God has given internal appetites and external objects to gratify them. This is the divine constitution. He has given, for instance, the stomach and the food, ( 1 Corinthians 6:13 ;) so he has given the sexual instincts and the sex; the desire for wealth and external property, etc. St. Paul replies, that all those external objects are truly lawful sources of gratification; yet the unrestrained gratification is limited by the law of the expedient , and that limits the right. The injurious is wrong, the truly beneficial alone is right. And so we are truly restricted not only to the right object, but also to that object in the right degree. The interpretation given by the great body of commentators ”all indifferent things are lawful” seems not only itself an empty truism, but involves perplexity in carrying a consistent meaning through the paragraph. Our interpretation perhaps justifies itself by its clear results.
Consider
Whedon concludes with the warning against self-deception in justification.
Verse 11. 11 . Washed Greek middle voice, Ye have washed yourselves; that is, by regeneration internally, symbolized by baptism, externally. Sanctified And, therefore, these sensualities are the opposite of your character. Justified And so such practices must forfeit your justification, and exclude you from the kingdom of God. This paragraph condemns, 1. All idea that the being once justified insures, in spite of relapse into vice, a secured inheritance of God’s glorified kingdom; and, 2. All Antinomianism; that is, the doctrine that a Christian’s professional holiness renders his sin and vice righteous and safe, so that he may transgress with impunity.He presses the call to flee fornication as the destroying vice.
Verse 18. 18 . The apostle now breaks out in direct address, Flee , O ye Corinthians, your destroying vice, fornication . Flee As Joseph fled from the wife of his master; for, as St. Anselm says, “other vices are best conquered by fighting, this by running away.” Without the body Extra of the body. That is, every sin is really committed by the soul, through the will, and the body is only the instrument. Against Rather, into. Fornication differs not from other sins touching its being committed by the soul; but pre-eminently of all it pours the sin into and throughout the body . And this striking of this sin through the whole body consists not merely in its withering, and wasting, and destroying power upon the body, but in something deeper, more awful, and more truly eternal. As the whole being is satanically unified with the harlot, so the whole body becomes, in its uncleanness, the perfect opposite of the pure person of Jesus the pure. How awfully incapable, then, of coming into mystic oneness with him. And from these views it would seem to follow that lawless love is really more truly opposite to Christ than even lawless hate. Our Corinthians may now infer how detestable is that religion with which their city so abounded, and of which debauchery was one of the consecrated rites.
Respond
1. Where in my present dealings am I tempted to bring the church’s witness under the judgment of the world? 2. How does the truth that I am already washed, sanctified, and justified stir me to guard the body as the temple of the Holy Ghost? 3. In what concrete choice today will I choose the expedient that glorifies God rather than the indulgence that enslaves?
Pray
Gracious Lord, we thank thee for the high calling set before us in thy word and opened to us by thy servant Whedon. Keep us from abasing thy church before any earthly bar and from every sensual snare that would forfeit our inheritance. Wash us again by thy Spirit, sanctify us wholly, and teach us to glorify thee in our bodies. May the same royal priesthood that reigns with Christ now be seen in our peaceable dealings and our pure living, until the day when we judge angels and share thy everlasting kingdom. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →