Eterniseed › Curriculum › John
John 9 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Wesleyan inquiry and Arminian confidence in prevenient grace, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. This revered Methodist Episcopal work opens the ninth chapter of John with careful attention to historical setting, miracle attestation, and the soul's movement toward Christ. Whedon's exposition invites us to behold both the Lord's sovereign work and the human response of faith amid opposition. As we study, may the same Spirit who opened the eyes of the blind-born quicken our understanding and strengthen our witness.
Read
Let us now read the entire ninth chapter of the Gospel according to John. Attend to the progression from physical blindness to spiritual sight, from hostile examination to faithful confession, and from rejection to reception by the Son of Man. Read slowly, allowing the narrative to disclose both the miracle and the judgment that follows willful unbelief.
Study
Whedon opens by situating the narrative within the Feast of Tabernacles.
Verses 1-41. § 84. RESTORATION OF THE BLIND-BORN AND FOURTH DISCOURSE AT THE FEAST OF TABERNACLES, John 9:1 John 10:21 . The event here narrated, with its appended discourse, must, in order to be understood in its completeness, be taken into one reading from John 9:1 to John 10:39 . It takes place at the Feast of Tabernacles. Through chapter ix the spiritual lords of Jerusalem show themselves false shepherds, as the blind-born is a true representative sheep; and through John 10:1-21 Jesus contrasts the true shepherd with the false. Three months after, at the Feast of Dedication, ( John 9:22-39 ,) Jesus takes occasion to resume the same thread of discourse, and the angry Jews, in resentment for his rebukes, drive him from their capital. The immediate narrative exhibits a thorough hostile sifting of one of our Lord’s miracles by the exciting authorities.Whedon then details the thorough examination of the miracle's reality.
First, it was the case of one born blind; a kind of case never curable ( John 9:32 ) by natural means. Second, the reality of the blindness was notorious, and yet was thoroughly examined by the authorities. Third, there was no escape from the conclusion of the reality of the miracle. It was attested by the man himself, by his parents, by his neighbours, by Jesus and his disciples. It was finally undenied by the Lord’s enemies. It was moreover attested and recorded by John, our Evangelist, himself an eye and ear witness of the whole transaction. After the performance of the miracle, John 9:1-7 , the case is examined by the neighbours, John 9:8-12 ; the man is brought before the authorities and examined a first time, John 9:13-17 ; the parents are brought before them and examined, John 9:18-23 ; the man is recalled and re-examined and cast out, John 9:24-34 .Whedon next highlights the man's bold confession before the authorities.
Verse 17. 17 . What sayest thou of him, [in view of the matter,] that he hath opened This shows that there is but one question. And the crooked question brings a straight answer. A prophet The man had heard from the readings of the Old Testament (though his own eyes had never seen a letter) that there were prophets of old, who did works by the power of God, and whose words, as from God, were thus divinely authenticated. Nothing less than such a one, even before this spiritual court, he avers, could this restorer of his sight have been. And this firm confessor shows himself prepared for that humble reception of Jesus’s words which he exhibited in John 9:36-38 . He is a predestined sheep of Christ; predestined, that is, by predisposition and free volitional purpose before he is by full regeneration. And this confession disconcerts these lords spiritual for the moment. But they fall back upon a pretext; perhaps his parents will admit that he was not born blind.
Consider
Whedon presses the consistency of miracles with human experience.
Verse 32. 32 . Since the world began Philosophers at the present day, like Hume and his followers, maintain that as miracles are contrary to experience, they can never take place. But, 1. A thing is not contrary to experience because it is unexperienced. To be contrary to experience, somebody must have a positive experience that a miracle cannot take place. But no one ever had or can have such an experience. 2. Miracles are not contrary but according to experience. This man could hold that giving sight to the blind-born was hitherto unexperienced; but he positively knew that it was not contrary to experience, for he knew that he himself had just experienced it. 3. Human experience is, that the so-called laws of nature are in themselves permanent, and yet that their operations are sometimes interrupted or varied by divine interpositions. And these two experiences are perfectly consistent with each other. Hence our man here correctly argues, human experience is, that ordinarily the born-blind is never restored; but a human experience also is, that in the present case the operation of that law has received a divine exception. 4. To say that a miracle never happened, because it is contrary to experience, is reasoning in a circle. For to say “it is contrary to experience” is but to say, in other words, that “it never happened.” So that the reasoning then is: A miracle “never happened” because it “never happened.”Whedon concludes by unfolding the Lord's judgment upon willful blindness.
Verse 41. 41 . If ye were blind If, like this man, you were utterly and innocently without the power to see. Ye should have no sin Ye would be perfectly blameless for not seeing. Just as blameless as this man for not seeing the sun without the power. No man is required to use a power he never could possess. If a man never could possess the power for right, he could never be condemned for wrong. If, indeed, he brings his powerlessness upon himself, he cannot plead it in excuse. But now ye say, We see By your own confession, which is true, you are able to see the truth; and yet, wilfully, ye see falsely; your judgment shall be that ye shall lose the opportunity to see truth, and ye shall be abandoned to that false seeing which is a real blindness. As both their not seeing truth and their untruthful seeing were willful, there was no excuse; their sin stood permanent, recorded, unpardoned, eternal.
Respond
1. Where in your own life has the Lord used an apparent defect or limitation to manifest the works of God? 2. How does the blind-born man's steadfast confession challenge any tendency to compromise truth for acceptance? 3. In what ways might we guard against the willful blindness that refuses the light Christ offers?
Pray
Gracious Father, who sent the Son as the true Light of the world, we thank Thee for the faithful labors of Daniel D. Whedon in expounding Thy Word. Grant us, like the man born blind, ears to hear Thy voice and courage to confess Thy Son before all examiners. Deliver us from every prejudice that would reject Thy miracle-working grace. May Thy prevenient Spirit continue to draw us, and may we walk as true sheep of the Good Shepherd until faith gives way to sight. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →