← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › John

John 5 — with Whedon

John 5Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of the Methodist Episcopal tradition we open this day’s lesson with Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s clear Arminian-Wesleyan exposition of John chapter five invites us to behold both the merciful power and the divine Sonship of our Lord. His careful notes on the Bethesda healing and the ensuing discourse guide the heart toward saving faith and holy obedience. As we listen, may the same Spirit who moved the evangelist quicken our souls to receive the word with meekness and love.
Read
Let us now give reverent attention to the fifth chapter of John’s Gospel. Hear how Jesus meets the impotent man at Bethesda, commands him to rise, and then unfolds before the hostile Jews the mystery of his eternal Sonship. Read slowly, allowing each verse to speak to conscience and heart, that the living Word may work in us both the will and the deed of faith.
Study
Whedon opens by examining our Lord’s searching question to the infirm man. Verse 6. 6 . Wilt thou Our Lord puts the question as part of the manifestation that the healing is produced by his own divine will. But it is in truth the same great question which Jesus is putting to a world of sinners lying in disease and death. It is his will to save them, but not without their wilt thou concurring. Whole The word whole is cognate with the words heal and hale, health. In the old English a man is called whole as free from any wound or disease. He then unfolds the eternal Sonship of Christ in his defense before the Jews. Verse 17. I. The eternal Sonship of Christ. 17 . Worketh hitherto By virtue of his oneness with God, Jesus is truly Lord of the Sabbath; and he no more violates the Sabbath by sending the current of vitality through the limbs of this paralytic, than the Father violates the Sabbath by keeping the stars in their courses, or sustaining the generations of men in the flow of life. God, having indeed closed the work of original creation with the creation of man, rested therefrom through a long Sabbath of time, even until now. God’s creative days were each perhaps an age; and this world’s long age may be his Sabbath. But he breaks neither that Sabbath, nor the Sabbath-day that commemorates that repose, by carrying on the ordinary train of nature or redemption. And as he has hitherto worked even through these Sabbaths, so do I work. I create nothing absolutely; but I control, hasten, or even vary, the processes of ordinary nature. Hitherto From the close of his creative work until now. I work My secret power in healing this man worked, just as God’s secret power worked in his generation and birth. Whedon next expounds the present conditional spiritual resurrection of the believing soul. Verse 24. The present conditional, spiritual resurrection of the soul, John 5:24-25 . 24 . Heareth my word and believeth This is a conditional quickening or resurrection to the life of the soul. The conditions are hearing, that is listening, voluntarily attending; and believing, that is, accepting the word into our heads, hearts, and lives. Hath everlasting life Everlasting life is already in him. That life is a present possession which heaven will perpetuate. Shall not While that life is thus within him. So, on the other hand, John 3:36 , he that believeth not shall not see life; that is, unless his unbelief be removed; for the wrath of God abideth on him. So that as eternal death is upon the unbeliever until he is converted, so eternal life is in the believer so long as he is a believer and does not apostatize. When a man is converted his death is removed; when a believer loses his faith, his eternal life is removed from within him. Is passed Has passed from death unto life. To him this resurrection is already past. The seed or principle of life is within his soul. It is in him a well of water springing up to everlasting life. The life cannot expire, but the well may be removed. See notes on John 4:14 .
Consider
Whedon concludes by sketching the twofold structure of Christ’s great discourse. Verses 17-47. First great discourse, furnished by John, of Jesus to the hostile Jews, John 5:17-47 . The best biblical scholars consider this defence, or self-explanation, to have been delivered by Jesus before the Sanhedrim. It bears, hence, some slight resemblance to the Apologia, or defence of Socrates before the Helioea, or popular court, of Athens. The two discourses resemble at least in this, that both refuse to extenuate, but boldly magnify and glory in the matter charged. Hence Luther calls this “a sublime apology, which makes the matter worse.” We have here, doubtless, rather an outline than full report of the discourse. It consists of two parts: The first, 17-30, bases his defence for an apparent act of Sabbath-breaking upon his eternal Sonship of God. The second, 31-47, adduces the threefold witness to his Sonship.
Respond
1. In what area of my life is Jesus asking, “Wilt thou be made whole?” 2. How does the truth of Christ’s eternal Sonship strengthen my trust in his present lordship over the Sabbath and over my circumstances? 3. Am I living daily in the spiritual resurrection that Christ offers, or have I allowed unbelief to keep me among the impotent folk?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the faithful labors of Daniel D. Whedon, whose commentary opens to us the riches of thy Son. Grant that the same divine will which healed the paralytic may quicken our souls today. May we hear thy word, believe on thy Son, and pass from death unto life. Keep us from seeking the honor that comes from men, and teach us to rest in the honor that cometh from thee alone. Through Jesus Christ our Lord, who with thee and the Holy Spirit liveth and reigneth, one God, world without end. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →