Eterniseed › Curriculum › John
Judgment Given to the Son
Opening
In his Commentary on the Gospel of John, St. Cyril of Alexandria reads the fifth chapter as a sustained revelation of the Only-begotten’s divine authority. The discourse on judgment, witness, and the will of the Father becomes for Cyril a doorway into the mystery of the Incarnation itself. He shows how the Son’s every action manifests the undivided Godhead while remaining faithful to the conditions of the flesh. The Alexandrian father invites the Church to hear in these verses both the eternal generation of the Word and the economy by which that Word redeems the world. Today’s lesson follows Cyril through selected passages that illumine the Son’s righteous judgment.
Read
Slowly read John chapter 5, attending especially to the themes of judgment, the will of the Father, and the testimony of Moses. Allow the words of Jesus to rest in the heart before turning to the ancient teacher who unfolds their depth.
Study
Cyril opens his treatment of the Father’s gift of judgment by noting how actions differ from essences.
Moreover, attention must be given to this also: to judge or to be a judge is rather an action or manifestation of what is conceived concerning essences than the essences themselves in their truth. We perform an action when we judge, yet we remain what we are. If we were to attribute the significance of essences to judgment or the act of judging, it would be necessary to admit that certain beings could not exist at all unless they appeared as judges, and that with the cessation of judgment their essence would likewise cease—an absurdity of the highest order. Judgment is an action and nothing else. What then has the Father given the Son? No superiority as though from His own nature by granting Him all judgment, but rather an action extending to those who are judged. How then shall the Father be greater or higher in nature, and what shall He have added to the Son that the Son did not already possess, seeing that He says, “All things that the Father has are Mine” (John 16:15)? Hear, finally, how the word “given” must be understood.He then shows how the equality of honour flows from the identity of essence already declared.
The equality of honour between the Son and the Father is the cause and foundation of the excellences already enumerated. Returning a little and recalling what was said before, you will rightly perceive the meaning of this saying. Thus, “He called God His own Father, making Himself equal with God” (v. 18); again, He showed Himself equal in power and co-creator, saying, “Whatever He does, the Son likewise does” (v. 19); that He is also life and life-giver by nature, as is He who begot Him, He indicated by adding, “For as the Father raises the dead and gives life, so the Son gives life to whom He wills” (v. 21); and He disclosed that He will also be Judge of all, with the Father’s good pleasure and co-operation in all things, in the words, “The Father judges no one, but has given all judgment to the Son” (v. 22). What then is the reason for this? What moved the Only-begotten to speak thus? “That all,” He says, “may honour the Son just as they honour the Father.” If He is all that the Father is, so far as divine dignity is concerned, is it not fitting to crown with equal honours Him in whom there is no deficiency in identity of essence?Turning to the economy of the flesh, Cyril reads the same saying according to the dispensation with the Law.
He was born for us of a woman (Gal 4:4), for, as Paul says, “He does not take hold of angels, but of the seed of Abraham; wherefore He was obliged in all things to be made like unto His brethren” (Heb 2:16–17). And having become man and appeared in the form of a servant (Phil 2:7), He was also under the Law (Gal 4:4), though as God and Lord He is the Lawgiver. Therefore He speaks at one time as one under the Law, at another as one above the Law, and possesses unquestionable authority for both. Even now He converses with the Jews as one who keeps the Law and as man, not permitting Himself to transgress the commandments ordained from above and not venturing of His own will to do anything that does not agree with the divine Law. Hence He says, “I can do nothing of Myself; as I hear, I judge.” Thus bearing witness of Himself that He cannot do anything of Himself that is obviously not permitted by the Law, and that He judges deeds as He hears—that is, according to the ordinance of the Law—He convicts the Jews of self-will and lays bare the unbridled character of their manners.
Consider
Cyril presses the unity of will that belongs to the single divine nature in Father and Son.
If the Son were powerless to perform any work by His own strength, ought He not rather to have said, “I can do nothing of Myself, but I receive power from the Father”? Yet by joining to “I can do nothing of Myself” the words “I judge as I hear,” He shows that He used “I cannot” not from any weakness of power, but because it is impossible for Him to transgress the Father’s will in anything. Where one and the same Godhead is understood in Father and Son, there is also one will; the divine nature in Father, Son, and Holy Spirit cannot be conceived as ever rising against Itself. Whatever is pleasing to the Father is the will of the whole Godhead. The Son therefore presents Himself as sharing one will and one desire with the Father in every decision that is well-pleasing to Him, declaring that He cannot do anything that does not accord with the Father’s good pleasure. The phrase “of Myself” points to this.He safeguards the distinction of hypostases against those who would confuse the Father and the Son.
31) there was contained, as it were by way of condescension, an agreement and a meaning rather hypothetical than actual; but in the words that He knows the Father’s witness to be true there is contained an indication of the trustworthiness that befits God. It must again be noted that according to His hypostasis the Father is another, distinct from the Son, and is not, as some ignorant heretics supposed, a “Son-Father” (υἱοπάτωρ).
Respond
Where in my life do I resist the righteous judgment that Christ exercises according to the Father’s will? How does the unity of divine will comfort me when I fear that obedience might diminish my freedom? In what ways am I still tempted to treat the words of Scripture as less binding than my own opinions?
Pray
O Only-begotten Son, who hast received from the Father all judgment yet judgest with the same will and power, let the light of Thy righteous judgment search our hearts and raise us from death to life. As Moses and the prophets bear witness to Thee, grant us to honor Thee even as we honor the Father who sent Thee, and keep us steadfast in the truth of Thy Godhead by the Spirit who proceedeth from the Father. Through the prayers of the Theotokos and all the saints, O Lord Jesus Christ our God, have mercy upon us and save us. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →