Eterniseed › Curriculum › Esther
Esther 9-10 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Welcome to this daily lesson drawn from Haydock's Catholic Family Bible Commentary on Esther chapters 9 and 10. Haydock's compilation gathers the insights of Challoner, Calmet, Worthington and others to illuminate the providential reversal that saves God's people. As we trace the establishment of Purim and the lasting memory of deliverance, the commentary invites us to see divine justice at work in history. Let Haydock's Catholic Commentary guide our reading today, helping us ponder how God turns threats into triumph for those who trust him.
Read
Open your Bible to Esther chapters 9 and 10. Read slowly the account of the Jews' victory, the hanging of Haman's sons, the institution of Purim, and the final tribute to Mordecai. Notice the careful balance between justice and restraint, and the lasting decree that keeps the memory of deliverance alive. Allow the narrative to settle in your heart before turning to Haydock's Catholic Commentary for deeper insight.
Study
Haydock opens the commentary on chapter 9 by setting the scene of the edict's execution.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary As. Hebrew, "(which is the month of Adar) when the king's command and edict drew near to be executed, in that day when the enemies of the Jews hoped to have power over them, (though it turned out that the Jews had dominion over those who hated them)" (Haydock) --- To revenge, &c. The Jews, on this occasion, by authority from the king, were made executioners of the public justice, for punishing by death a crime worthy of death, viz., a malicious conspiracy for extripating their whole nation; (Challoner) so inscrutable are the judgments of God, who never wholly abandoned his people! The old Vulgate passes over the first 19 verses, with the 24th, 25th, and 28th. (Calmet) --- In this whole history we cannot but admire the Providence of God. (Worthington)The commentary next examines the restraint shown regarding the goods of the slain.
Goods, in any place, (Tirinus) that they might not appear to be actuated by the desire of riches, (Calmet) to fall upon the innocent. How often does this fatal cause blind Christian conquerors! The sons of Aman were married, and had separate establishments, chap. viii. 1.Haydock then explains how the feast of Purim was established and observed.
Receive. Protestants, "establish this among them, that they should keep the 14th....yearly," 2 Machabees xv. 37. (Haydock) --- None were obliged to keep more than one of these days, according to their respective dwellings. The 14th was for the provinces, the 15th for the Jews of Susan, ver. 18. (Tirinus) (Calmet) (Worthington) --- Yet it would seem that both days were enjoined, ver. 27, 28. (Haydock) --- The Jews still observe, them, as they gratify their vanity and vindictive spirit. The 13th is kept a rigid fast, for all above sixteen, for twenty-four hours, during which they eat nothing. (Calmet) --- If that day should be a sabbath, or its eve, they fast on the 11th or 12th. (Drusius) --- The day before the festival they give alms to their poor brethren, enjoining them to consume the whole in making good cheer. Each person must then contribute the half sicle, (Exodus xxx. 13.) which is bestowed on those who undertake a pilgrimage to the land of promise. At night, when the feast commences, they light the lamps, and begin to read the Book of Esther, as soon as the stars appear. They use an old parchment manuscript roll, and, in the five places, the reader shouts with all his might, running over the names of the ten sons of Aman with all haste, to shew that they all died in a moment. Whenever Aman is mentioned, the children beat the benches with mallets; and formerly they used to strike at a stone, on which his name was cut, till it broke, ver. 31. After the lecture, they take a repast at home. Early the next morning they return to the synagogue, and read the account of Amalec from the Pentateuch, and repeat the Book of Esther, with the aforesaid ceremonies. The rest of the day they spend in merriment. Their teachers allow them to drink till they are unable to distinguish the name of Aman from that of Mardochai. (Basnage, vi. 15.) --- They also change clothes, in contradiction to the law; (Deuteronomy xxii. 5.) and were formerly accustomed to crucify a man of straw, which they burnt with the cross, till Christian emperors put a stop to them; as it was concluded, from their curses, &c., that they had an eye to our Saviour. (Calmet) See chap. v. 14. (Haydock)
Consider
Haydock reflects on the extent of the king's dominion and God's providence in chapter 10.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Land. He conquered many countries on the continent, and several to which he could not come but by water, which the Jews call islands, whether they were surrounded on all sides by the sea or not. Hebrew has not the word all: but as the expressions are indefinite, they are usually taken in this sense. Yet we must not suppose, that the dominion of Assuerus extended over the whole world, no more than that of the Romans, who were styled masters of it. Before this king, the provinces had not paid tribute, but gave what they judged proper. But Darius laid a heavy tribute upon all, that, when half was afterwards remitted, they might esteem it a favour. The Persians hence looked upon him as a trafficker: Greek: kapelos. (Herodotus iii. 89., and iv. 44., and vi. 7., &c.) (Calmet) --- Providence punished them for thirsting after the possessions and blood of the Jews. (Tirinus)
Respond
Where in my own life have I seen threats turned into unexpected deliverance? How does the restraint shown by the Jews challenge my approach to justice or victory? What feast or memorial in my spiritual life helps me remember God's faithfulness?
Pray
O Lord of hosts, you turned the counsel of the wicked into deliverance for your chosen people and established an enduring memorial of your mercy. Grant us grace to act with justice tempered by mercy, keeping ever alive the memory of your saving deeds and trusting in your providence over the Church. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →