← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › John

John 21 — with Whedon

John 21Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In this daily lesson we turn to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments for its treatment of John chapter 21. Whedon writes with the clarity and warmth characteristic of nineteenth-century Methodist Episcopal exegesis, holding fast to the apostolic authorship of the closing chapter while unfolding its rich symbolism for the Church's ongoing life and ministry. His notes guide us through the final resurrection appearance at the Sea of Tiberias, the restoration of Peter, and the attestation that seals the Gospel. We listen reverently, ready to receive both instruction and encouragement for faithful following of the risen Lord.
Read
Let us now read John chapter 21 in its entirety, attending to the risen Christ's provision for his disciples, the symbolic draught of fishes, the quiet meal on the shore, and the searching yet restoring conversation with Peter. Read slowly, allowing the narrative to place you among the seven disciples who once more hear the Master's voice across the water and receive his commission anew.
Study
Whedon opens by addressing the question of the chapter's authorship and its place after the clear close of chapter twenty. Introduction. It has been doubted (against the judgment of all antiquity and the clearest evidences of style, both in thought and language) whether the present chapter was written by John. Grotius first started the hypothesis that it was supplied by “the elders of the Church of Ephesus,” after the death of John. The reasons are, that there is a clear closing of the book at the close of the twentieth chapter; that the narrative in the present chapter has a romantic air; that the plural we know, in John 21:24 , indicates the plurality of authors, and that the hyperbole in the closing verse is inconsistent with the idea of the author’s inspiration. We may admit without question that the book is closed with the twentieth chapter, and that this chapter is a later addition; but then beyond all doubt it was added by the hand of John himself. The “romantic air” is imaginary with the critic, while the depth of the thoughts and events, as well as the tone of composition, is unlike those of any author that ever held a pen save John. The other objections will be met in our notes. § 153. JESUS’S APPEARANCE AT THE SEA OF TIBERIAS, John 21:1-24 . He then examines the disciples' return to their boats and the reenactment of their original call. Verse 3. 3 . I go a fishing Literally, I am going to fish. The symbolical fishers of men are going to their literal and original work. The transaction that now ensues is a re-enactment and enlargement of their first call to follow Jesus, after a similar miracle. See notes on Matthew 4:18-20 ; Luke 5:4-11 . That miracle presaged their future office under Christ’s living guardianship; this miracle prophetically promises a guardianship of the ascended Christ over his faithful ministry, and their final attainment to the everlasting shores. Caught nothing Their catching nothing, the presence of Jesus, and their rare success at his command, are clear repetitions of the former transaction. Whedon next traces the threefold exchange in which Jesus restores Peter to pastoral oversight. Verse 15. 15 . Had dined But still sat at the meal. Peter was likely to be upon one side and John upon the other of Jesus, at the head. Jesus, in allusion (though the allusion is disclosed gradually) to Peter’s thrice denying him, proceeds to ask him thrice, Lovest thou me? At each profession Jesus bids him, in increasing kindness, to return to his pastoral office. Simon, son of Jonas Jesus calls him not by his name of honour, Peter. He recurs rather to his origin as a natural man, son of Jonah. Lovest There are two Greek words alike rendered love in our translation, but which have a different force. The love of this question, αγαπας signifies the love of will, of judgment or of moral feeling, nearly our English word to prize. The other is φιλεις , which is simply affectional love, springing from the natural sensibility. In his question Jesus uses the former word; in his answer Peter uses the latter. Simon, son of Jonas, prizest thou me ? More than these More than the rest of the disciples at the meal love me. Peter had proudly boasted over them, “Though all should be offended in thee, yet will not I .” Our Lord tests him to see whether he still professes over the others. Thou knowest He makes no vehement protestations, but appeals to the Lord’s own knowledge of his heart. I love thee Peter uses the affectional term for love: I love thee tenderly from the heart. Feed my lambs It is as if Peter’s first denial is now wiped out. Jesus bids him to return to the pastoral office in its humblest form. He distinguishes the two Greek verbs for love employed in that exchange. Verse 17. 17 . Lovest thou Jesus now, at last, uses the affectional term for love. This affectional term is lower than the moral term, but yet tenderer. But the cherishing of the moral tends to produce the affectional; and it is when both are united that the love is perfected. This blending in spiritual perfection is impossible without the aid of the blessed and Divine Spirit of love. Peter was grieved Peter now sees that it is his threefold denial that demands this threefold confession. He is grieved, not because the demand is made, but for the sad cause that renders it necessary. He had thrice said, I know not the man; he may now thrice declare how he loves the man. But the recollection of the sad scene of apostacy melts him to sorrow in this his hour of restoration. Knowest all things The man whom he denies is divine. The man whom, in the hour of the denial, he knew not, knows all things. I love thee The full profession is uttered, and the full absolution will now be made. Feed my sheep Shepherd my full-grown sheep. Peter passes by humble degrees to his full pastoral office. But he receives no popedom, no triple crown over the universal Church. Nothing indicates that he is restored more than to the level of his fellow-disciples.
Consider
Whedon then sets forth the symbolic prophecy of Peter's future martyrdom. Verses 18-19. 18, 19 . Jesus has restored him to his office and now he symbolizes his future destiny. He who shrank from an imaginary danger will not shrink from the cross and the crown of martyrdom. Peter is said to have been crucified at Rome more than thirty years after this memorable conversation. Finally he affirms the apostolic authenticity of the chapter's closing attestation. Verses 24-25. The attestation and conclusion, John 21:24-25 . Against the arrogant pretensions of modern factitious criticism, “criticism run mad,” we repudiate the notion that these verses are added by a later hand It is a modern invention, that about the Ephesian Church giving us this testimony to John! His own spirit and style breathe in every clause. This, is certain, that if it were by any other hand, the spurious writer does his best, with great success, to counterfeit the authorship he professes to authenticate. The additional verses are composed either by the apostle or by an impostor. But we believe that the Church of that day could not have been imposed upon, and would not impose upon us a counterfeiter’s endorsement of this memorable Gospel.
Respond
1. Where in your present service do you sense the Lord calling you back to simple obedience before any new commission is given? 2. How does the distinction between prizing Christ and loving him tenderly shape your daily response to his questions? 3. In what ways does the assurance of Christ's watchful presence on the farther shore strengthen you to follow him without turning aside?
Pray
Gracious and risen Savior, we thank thee for the faithful witness preserved in John chapter 21 and for the careful exposition given by thy servant Daniel D. Whedon. Grant us grace to hear thy voice across the waters of this present life, to cast our nets at thy word, and to receive both the provision and the commission thou dost offer. Restore us where we have denied thee, and bind us again to the work of feeding thy lambs and shepherding thy sheep. Keep us steadfast in following thee through every trial until we reach the eternal shore where thou hast prepared a place. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →