← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 1 Corinthians

1 Corinthians 8 — with Whedon

1 Corinthians 8Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry and Arminian confidence in grace that builds up the whole body, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon's careful exposition of First Corinthians chapter eight invites us to weigh knowledge against love and to guard the conscience of every brother for whom Christ died. May the same Spirit who guided the apostle guide our study, that we might grow not in pride but in charity that edifies the church.
Read
With hearts open to the word that both instructs and unites, let us read First Corinthians chapter eight. Listen for the apostle's pastoral care as he answers the question of idol sacrifices, and attend to the way love must govern even the liberty that knowledge appears to grant. Read slowly, asking the Spirit to search whether our own knowledge builds up or merely puffs up.
Study
Whedon opens by taking up the Corinthian claim in the first verse. Verse 1. 1 . Assuming the first verse to introduce a passage from the Corinthian letter to the apostle, we would print it somewhat thus: Now concerning idol sacrifices, “we are convinced,” [you say,] “that all have knowledge .” Knowledge , [I reply,] puffeth up ; it is love that buildeth up; and if any man imagine he KNOWS any thing, he knows nothing as he ought to know.” Were the words on both sides spoken, not written, we would suppose Paul to cut short their soft, apologetic words rather abruptly, with a firm expression of countenance, softened by a smile, showing that his was a rebuke of love. Knowledge Γνωσις . Gnosis knowledge is the word whence the Gnostics drew their title, and designates what claimed to be a deep insight into a profound subject, requiring a penetrative mind. And upon this their pet word, knowledge, the apostle plays with a covert sarcasm through the chapter. 1 Corinthians 8:2-4 ; 1Co 8:7 ; 1 Corinthians 8:10-11 . Its arrogance was a quality largely belonging to the sect which assumed it as their title. Puffeth up An unloving knowledge , even where it is real knowledge , often results in haughty assumption, and in scorn of humbler minds. Knowing perfectly the nothingness of idols, the proud believer might be reckless of the difficulties and dangers of feebler minds. Charity An unfortunate rendering of the Greek for LOVE. St. Paul affirms that it is love, mixed with knowledge , which perfects knowledge into true wisdom. Edifieth Buildeth the possessor into a true Christian edifice. If knowledge be the bricks of the edifice, love must at least be the mortar. He next sets forth the positive Christian creed in verse six. Verse 6. 6 . To us Emphatically to us Christians. St. Paul now takes occasion to lay down the positive Christian creed on the subject, cleansing our moral sky of all mythologies, and giving us alone God in heaven and our Lord Christ on earth. God, the Father Father here used not of his divine paternity of us, but in relation to the Son. Of whom As himself the unrevealed background of Deity. One Lord… Christ The divine Manifestation on earth of the hidden Infinite in heaven. Lord as being the executive of the divine power and grace immediately upon us, on earth. Idolatry was the unregenerate effort of fallen man to frame an earthly representative of God. Christ is the true living representative, humanizing the divine, and bringing the Infinite into finite sympathy with us. The idol-lord is therefore a false, fabricated, rival to the true Lord . It must be abolished in order that He may stand supreme and alone. God , therefore, is not here so styled God as to exclude Christ from the Godhead, any more than Christ is styled Lord to exclude God from the Lordship. One is distinctly God and the other Lord, yet both are both God and Lord. And St. Paul thus states the true Christian gnosis as abolishing the idol as a nothing in the world . Whedon then follows the apostle to the vow of self-denial in verse thirteen. Verse 13. 13 . Offend Note on Matthew 18:7 . I will eat no flesh Mark how delicately the apostle passes now from the second person plural, ye , to the first person singular, I . He enjoins upon them a somewhat burdensome take heed ; but when it comes to the intensity of perfect self-denial he takes it upon himself. It is a sublime, nay, a daring height of self-consecration, rising to the level of an a p ostle, and that apostle, Paul. And, as in other high things, there is some danger in it. Note Romans 14:16 ; Romans 14:21 . We may by obeying another man’s false conscience confirm his self-conceit, encourage his tyranny, or establish a false morality, and make it a part of the present Christianity. Against this last danger Paul specially here provides. While he complies with the weak brother’s error he openly proclaims that it is an error, and that he complies, not for truth, but from tenderness.
Consider
Whedon gathers the preceding argument in verses seven through thirteen. Verses 7-13. 7-13 . The two preliminaries, the knowledge and the monotheism, now being settled, St. Paul takes up the vital topic of sacrificial eating. He denies that all possess the true gnosis, affirming that there is, on the contrary, a class of tremulous Christians with whose weakness it is a bounden Christian duty to sympathize. He closes by noting how the discussion is suspended until chapter ten. He yields to the unsound conscience; but nothing would induce him to admit that the conscience was sound. While temporizing with the weakness, he takes all care for the abolishment of the error. At this point St. Paul suspends, not terminates, his discussion of the idol sacrifices, and resumes it at 1 Corinthians 10:14 to 1 Corinthians 11:1 . He suspends it in order, through an extended and interesting digression, ( 1 Corinthians 9:1 to 1 Corinthians 10:18 ,) at once to illustrate this principle of resigning one’s rights for others’ good, and to defend himself from the charge of depreciating his own apostleship in making such surrender. Though a digression, and a long one, it is so full of the noblest sentiments and loftiest piety that none should wish it shorter.
Respond
Where in my present knowledge am I tempted to overlook the conscience of a weaker brother? How does the cross of Christ reframe the rights I most readily claim? In what concrete act of love this week might I choose to build up rather than to insist upon my liberty?
Pray
Gracious Father, who art one God with the Lord Jesus Christ, grant us that knowledge which love perfects. Keep us from the arrogance that despises tender consciences and from the indifference that wounds those for whom thy Son died. Form in us the mind of Paul, who would rather surrender every lawful liberty than cause a brother to perish. May our freedom be always ruled by charity, until the whole church is built up in wisdom and holiness. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →