Eterniseed › Curriculum › Judges
Judges 19-20 — with Barnes
Opening
In the clear exegetical tradition of American Presbyterian scholarship, we turn today to Albert Barnes's Notes on the Bible. His verse-by-verse commentary on Judges 19–20 guides us through one of Scripture’s most sobering accounts, illuminating the historical setting, tribal customs, and moral consequences that unfold when God’s people depart from covenant faithfulness. Barnes’s careful attention to chronology, geography, and the precise wording of the Hebrew text helps modern readers grasp both the gravity of the events and the enduring principles they display.
Read
With reverence and attention, read Judges chapters 19 and 20 in full. Note the rapid descent from private hospitality into public outrage, the gathering of the tribes, and the costly battle that follows. Allow the text’s unsparing detail to impress upon the heart both the horror of sin and the necessity of righteous judgment.
Study
Barnes opens by situating the narrative chronologically.
Introduction. This history has no connection whatever with the preceding. The note of time Judges 20:28 shows that the date of it is in the lifetime of the first generation of settlers in Canaan.He then details the national assembly at Mizpeh.
Verse 1. The “congregation” is the technical term for the whole community of the Israelite people. Its occurrence here is an indication of the early date of these transactions. From Dan to Beer-sheba - We cannot safely infer from this expression that the settlement of Dan, recorded in Judges 18:0 had taken place at this time. It only proves that in the writer’s time, from Dan to Beer-sheba was a proverbial expression for all Israel (compare the marginal reference). With the land of Gilead - Meaning all the trans-Jordanic tribes; mentioned particularly, both to show that the whole congregation of the children of Israel, in its widest meaning, took part in the council, and also because of Jabesh-Gilead Judges 21:8 , Judges 21:10 . Unto the Lord in Mizpeh - The phrase “unto the Lord”, implies the presence of the tabernacle ( Judges 11:11 note). Mizpeh in Benjamin Joshua 18:26 , from its connection with Bethel and Ramah, is probably meant here. It is the same as that which appears as a place of national assembly in 1 Samuel 7:5 ; 1 Samuel 10:17 ; 2 Kings 25:23-25 . It must have been near Shiloh and Gibeah, and in the north of Benjamin. The Benjamites were duly summoned with the other tribes; so that their absence was contumacious Judges 20:3 .Barnes next underscores the decisive chronological marker involving Phinehas.
Verse 28. Phinehas, the son of Eleazar ... - A most important chronological statement, which makes it probable that these events occurred within twenty years of the death of Joshua. To-morrow - The two former answers only bade them go up against Benjamin; now, for the first time, the promise is added, “Tomorrow,” etc. (compare Joshua 8:1 ).
Consider
Finally, Barnes weighs the thoroughness of the judgment carried out against Benjamin.
Verse 48. They treated Benjamin as devoted to utter destruction, as Jericho had been Joshua 6:17 , Joshua 6:21 , and the whole tribe was all but actually extirpated. We see in the punishment inflicted the same ferocity which marked both the crime and the Levite’s mode of requiring vengeance.
Respond
1. How does the early date of these events shape our understanding of Israel’s spiritual condition shortly after entering Canaan?
2. In what ways does the Levite’s appeal to hospitality expose both the strengths and failures of covenant community life?
3. What warnings does the near-extirpation of Benjamin hold for churches that tolerate grave sin in their midst?
Pray
Gracious Father, as we behold in Thy Word the depths of depravity that overtook Benjamin, open our eyes to the exceeding sinfulness of sin and the ruin that follows every departure from Thy covenant. Grant us repentant hearts that flee to the cleansing blood of Christ and depend wholly on Thy Spirit to preserve Thy church from moral confusion. Raise up in us a holy resolve to walk uprightly before Thee until Thy kingdom comes in fullness. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →