Eterniseed › Curriculum › 2 Samuel
2 Samuel 1-2 — with Whedon
Opening
Beloved, we open our hearts today to the steady guidance of Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. With reverent attention we follow his exposition of 2 Samuel chapters 1 and 2, where the transition from Saul to David unfolds under the sovereign hand of God. Whedon's careful notes invite Wesleyan pilgrims to trace loyalty, grief, and divine leading without resentment or haste. May the same Spirit who anointed David steady our steps as we listen for the Lord's direction in every season of change and sorrow.
Read
Let us now read 2 Samuel chapters 1 and 2 aloud with open Bibles and attentive spirits. Hear the report of Saul's fall, David's lament, and the first steps of kingship in Hebron. Allow the narrative to stir both sorrow and hope, remembering that every word is given for our instruction and sanctification.
Study
Whedon opens by setting the scene of the tidings reaching David.
Verses 1-16. DAVID HEARS OF THE DEATH OF SAUL AND OF JONATHAN, 2 Samuel 1:1-16 . As soon as the results of the fearful battle of Gilboa became known, great must have been the excitement through all the land of Israel. Saul’s partisans and all his loyal subjects must have felt the spell of mingled alarm and grief, and even the bitterest malcontents must have been ill at ease when they learned that the whole army of Israel was demoralized and put to flight by the Philistines. In this chapter we learn with what anguish David’s loyal heart received the bitter tidings.Whedon then unfolds the elegy itself with its tender structure.
Verse 17. DAVID’S LAMENTATION OVER SAUL AND JONATHAN, 2 Samuel 1:17-27 . 17 . This lamentation , which evidently sprang from deep and sanctified emotions, is an elegy of surpassing tenderness, and one of the most beautiful odes of the Old Testament. The fallen power and beauty of Israel, as represented by the king and his noble-hearted son, is the poet’s theme, and though that king had burned with a deadly fury towards David, chased him like a partridge in the mountains, and sought his life in many ways, not the slightest trace of resentment or cherished passion, not the most distant allusion to the persecutions which he had suffered from him, appear in all this tender song. It is the pure lamentation of a loving heart that has forgiven and forgotten the injuries of the past, and knows no other feeling than that of profoundest sympathy and sorrow for the heroic dead. “It is almost impossible,” says Dr. Clarke, “to read the noble original without feeling every word swollen with a sigh or broken with a sob. A heart pregnant with distress, and striving to utter expressions descriptive of its feelings, which are repeatedly interrupted by an excess of grief, is most sensibly painted throughout the whole.” We give, as usual in our notes on poetical passages, a new and literal version, in which the order and idiom of the Hebrew original is, as far as possible, exhibited.He proceeds to David's inquiry of the Lord before any move toward the throne.
Verse 1. DAVID KING IN HEBRON, AND ISHBOSHETH KING IN MAHANAIM, 2 Samuel 2:1-11 . 1 . After this After his lamentation over the death of Saul and Jonathan. Inquired of the Lord By the urim of the priest Abiathar. Compare 1 Samuel 23:9-12 . Shall I go up David knew that he was to be king, but how to attain the throne he knew not. He had no unholy ambition, and in matters of so great responsibility he wished Jehovah to guide him. Hebron The ancient city of the patriarchs. See on Genesis 13:18 , and Joshua 10:3 . It was inexpedient for David longer to abide in the land of the Philistines, and Hebron, because of its peculiarly sacred associations and its central position in the tribe of Judah, was a most appropriate place for David to begin his reign. But it should be observed that, though he received divine counsel to go up to Hebron, he was not divinely advised to receive the kingdom from a single tribe. See note on 2 Samuel 2:4 .
Consider
Whedon weighs the long-term consequences of receiving the kingdom from one tribe alone.
Verse 4. 4 . The men of Judah came The elders of Judah, the official representatives of that tribe. And there they anointed David king over the house of Judah By what particular ceremony and by whom the anointing was done we are not told. He had already been anointed by Samuel, ( 1 Samuel 16:13 ,) but that was done privately in his father’s house. We shall see in the sequel that when he became king of all Israel he was again anointed. 2 Samuel 5:3 . It was an ill-advised course and a dangerous policy for David to accept the kingdom of a single tribe. It was a sanction to a usurpation of power which no single tribe had a right to exercise, and it intensified that rivalry and hostility between Judah and the other tribes which at the death of Solomon resulted in the division of the kingdom. Had it not been that David had so strong a hold upon the nation’s heart, the rupture between the tribes might have occurred long before it did.He closes the section by tracing the measured timeline between the two anointed kings.
Verse 10. 10 . Ishbosheth… reigned two years The next verse informs us that David reigned in Hebron ever Judah seven years and six months, and therefore we must naturally conclude that for five years and six months the other tribes of Israel were without an acknowledged king. It is altogether gratuitous to assume, as some critics have done, that Ishbosheth reigned all the time that David reigned in Hebron. It is probable, however, that David was king in Hebron some time before Ishbosheth began to reign. David seems to have been anointed very soon after Saul’s death, but it must have taken Abner some time to gather up the scattered army and recover from the defeat and losses of Gilboa sufficiently to attend to the inauguration of Ishbosheth. So it is likely that David reigned in Hebron a year or more before the son of Saul was anointed at Mahanaim. Then followed two years of strife and bickering between the two governments, which was of sufficient length to be called “long war.” 2 Samuel 3:1 . And after both Abner and Ishbosheth had been vilely assassinated, it is but natural to suppose that the northern tribes would wait some years to observe the manner of David’s government before they all came together to acknowledge and anoint him king. See on 2 Samuel 5:1 .
Respond
1. Where in my own life am I tempted to receive advancement before the Lord has fully prepared the way? 2. How does David's refusal to rejoice over an enemy's fall challenge my heart toward genuine forgiveness? 3. In what present decision am I pausing to inquire of the Lord as David did at Hebron?
Pray
Gracious Lord of Israel and of the Church, we thank Thee for the faithful labors of Daniel D. Whedon and for the light his commentary sheds upon Thy holy Word. Grant us hearts as loyal as David's, quick to mourn what Thou dost mourn and slow to seize what Thou hast not yet given. Keep us from every rash step that would divide Thy people or grieve Thy Spirit. Anoint us afresh with the oil of Thy grace, that we may serve Thee in humility and truth until the day when Christ alone is King over all. In His name we pray. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →