Eterniseed › Curriculum › Romans
Romans 11 — with Hodge
Opening
In the rich tradition of Reformed exegesis, we turn today to Charles Hodge's Commentary on Romans, 1 Corinthians, and Ephesians, where the Princeton theologian unfolds the apostle's argument in Romans chapter eleven with precision and pastoral care. Hodge's treatment guards the sovereignty of divine grace while tracing Paul's careful distinction between the external nation and the elect remnant. His words steady the church in the assurance that God's promises stand firm.
Read
Let us now attend to the sacred text itself. Read Romans chapter eleven slowly and prayerfully, noting the apostle's movement from the reality of a present remnant to the certainty of future restoration and the doxology that crowns the chapter.
Study
Hodge opens by confronting the apparent contradiction between the doctrine of rejection and the promises made to Israel.
Is it to be inferred from what I have said, that God hath rejected his people? When we consider how many promises are made to the Jewish nation, as God’s peculiar people; and how often it is said, as in Psalms 94:14 , “The Lord will not cast off his people,” it is not surprising that the doctrine of the rejection of the Jews, as taught in the preceding chapters, was regarded as inconsistent with the word of God. Paul removes this difficulty, first by showing that the rejection of the Jews was neither total nor final; and secondly, by proving that the promises in question had reference, not to the Jewish nation as such, but to the elect, or, the spiritual Israel. The word ̓ ́ stands at the beginning of the sentence, to show that it is emphatic. Has God utterly, (i.e., totally and finally) rejected his people? This Paul denies. He had not asserted any thing of the kind.He then weighs two possible readings of the phrase 'his people which he foreknew.'
Verse 2. Romans 11:2 God hath not cast away his people which he foreknew. This verse admits of two interpretations. The words his people may be understood, as in the preceding verse, as meaning the Jewish nation and the clause which he foreknew , as, by implication, assigning the reason for the declaration that God had not cast them off. The clause, according to this view, is little more than a repetition of the sentiment of the preceding verse. ‘It is not to be inferred from what I have said of the rejection of the Jews, that God has cast away all his chosen people. Multitudes are excepted now, as in the days of Elias.’ The second interpretation requires more stress to be laid upon the words which he foreknew , as qualifying and distinguishing the preceding phrase, his people . ‘God has indeed rejected his external people, the Jewish nation as such, but he has not cast away his people whom he foreknew.’Hodge next shows why the second reading, distinguishing the elect remnant, best fits the apostle's argument.
According to this view, his people means the elect, his spiritual people, or the true Israel. This interpretation seems decidedly preferable, 1. Because it is precisely the distinction which Paul had made, and made for the same purpose, in Romans 9:6-8 , ‘The rejection of the external Israel does not invalidate the promises of God, because those promises did not contemplate the natural seed as such, but the spiritual Israel. So, now, when I say that the external Israel is rejected, it does not imply that the true chosen Israel, to whom the promises pertained, is cast away.’ 2. Because this is apparently Paul’s own explanation in the sequel. The mass of the nation were cast away, but “a remnant, according to the election of grace,” were reserved, Romans 11:5 . Israel, as such, Paul says in Romans 11:7 , failed of admission to the Messiah’s kingdom, “but the election hath obtained it.”He proceeds to identify the present remnant as chosen according to the election of grace.
Verse 5. Romans 11:5 Even so then at this present time also there is a remnant according to the election of grace. As in the days of Elias, there was a number which, although small in comparison with the whole nation, was still much greater than appeared to human eyes, who remained faithful, so at the present time, amidst the general defection of the Jews, and their consequent rejection as a people, there is a remnant, ( ͂ , what is left , answering to ́ in Romans 11:4 ,) according to the election of grace; that is, graciously chosen. The election was gracious , not merely in the sense of kind , but gratuitous , sovereign , not founded on the merits of the persons chosen, but the good pleasure of God. This explanation of the term is given by the apostle himself in the next verse. Remnant according to the gracious election is equivalent to remnant gratuitously chosen , see Romans 9:11 , and Romans 11:21 , Romans 11:24 of this chapter. Paul, therefore, designs to teach that the rejection of the Jews was not total, because there was a number whom God had chosen, who remained faithful, and constituted the true Israel or elected people, to whom the promises were made. As in the days of Elias, the number of those who had not bowed the knee to Baal was far greater than the prophet believed it to be, so the number of those who acknowledged Christ as the Messiah, in the times of the apostle, was much larger probably than is generally supposed. The apostle James speaks of many myriads ( ́ ́ ), Acts 21:20 , of believing Jews.
Consider
Hodge presses the point that this election is altogether gratuitous and reaches the kingdom of Christ itself.
For a choice founded upon the foresight of good works, is as really made on account of works as any choice can be, and, consequently, is not of grace, in the sense asserted by the apostle. In the second place, the choice which is here declared to be so entirely gratuitous, is a choice to the kingdom of Christ. This is evident from the whole context, and especially from Romans 11:7 . It was from this kingdom and all its spiritual and eternal blessings that the Jews, as a body, were rejected, and to which “the remnant according to the election of grace” was admitted. The election, therefore, spoken of in the ninth chapter, is not to external privileges merely. The latter part of this verse is simply the converse of the former. But if of works, then it is no more grace; otherwise work is no more work. If founded on any thing in us, it is not founded on the mere good pleasure of God. If the one be affirmed, the other is denied.
Respond
1. How does the distinction between the visible nation and the elect remnant shape your view of the church today?
2. In what ways does the freeness of electing grace guard you from both presumption and despair?
3. Where do you see the same sovereign mercy at work in your own calling?
Pray
O Lord of the covenant, we thank thee that thou hast not cast away thy people whom thou foreknewest. Keep us from measuring thy faithfulness by outward numbers or by the sight of widespread apostasy. Grant that we may rest in the election of grace, neither adding to it our works nor doubting its certainty. Preserve a remnant in our day according to thy sovereign pleasure, and bring many of Abraham's natural seed to the obedience of faith. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →