Eterniseed › Curriculum › Acts
Acts 15 — with Coke
Opening
In the quiet discipline of daily Scripture, we turn again to Thomas Coke's Commentary on the Holy Bible. As Wesley's trusted associate and the first Methodist bishop, Coke writes with apostolic reverence and pastoral warmth, guiding readers through the living Word. His treatment of Acts chapter 15 invites us to watch the early church wrestle, discern, and obey under the Spirit's leading. We listen not merely for history but for the same Spirit who still orders the life of Christ's people today.
Read
Let us now read Acts chapter 15 in a spirit of humble attention. Hear how the church at Antioch faces sudden division, how the apostles and elders gather in Jerusalem, and how the Holy Spirit leads them to a gracious decision that safeguards both truth and liberty. Read slowly, asking the same Lord who guided the first believers to open his word afresh to your heart.
Study
Coke opens by setting the scene of the controversy.
Verse 1. Acts 15:1 . And certain men, &c.— A circumstance now occurred, which was the occasion of very considerable consequences in the Christian church: for some persons who came from Antioch to Judea, full of Jewish prejudices,—among whom it was a common maxim, that all uncircumcised personsgo to hell; taught the Christians in their public and private discourses, that, except they were circumcised, according to the manner prescribed in the law of Moses, and became obedient to all the whole system of his precepts, they could not possibly be saved by the gospel; which, they urged, was intended to make all that were converted to it Jews, and that they could not otherwise be true and genuine Christians;—objections, which it was of the greatest consequence entirely to remove.He then records the measured debate within the assembly.
Verse 7. Acts 15:7 . And when there had been much disputing, — The debate which arose in this assembly, may indeed prove that there were some in thechurch at Jerusalem who had not a due regard to the authority of the apostles; but it cannot afford any just argument against their inspiration; for this dispute does not appear to have been among the apostles themselves; and if they really had debated the case a while, their decision at last might have been under an unerring direction. There seems no reason to conclude, that their inspiration was always so instantaneous and express, as to supersede any deliberation in their own minds, or any consultation with each oCoke next shows how Peter's words prepare the way for the whole company to listen.
Verse 12. Acts 15:12 . Then all the multitude kept silence, — St. Peter's speech silenced all the multitude, and the zealots had nothing to reply to such clear and convincing arguments. The whole body of the assembly, therefore, were then disposed patiently to attend to what Paul and Barnabas thoughtfit to communicate to them, concerning the wonders and miracles which God had enabled them to do among the Gentiles; which was a plain confirmation that God had sent them, and approved of their attempt to convert such persons, though they were not circumcised, nor subject to the burden of the Mosaic law.He continues by noting James's summing up of the matter.
Verse 13. Acts 15:13 . And after they had held their peace, — The silence being renewed, the apostle James made a speech, in which he summed up the debate, and formed the question, to which they all unanimously agreed. Hence it is plain, that the matter was not determined by virtue of any superior authority in St. Peter; and it seems very providential that St. James should have made sucha speech on this occasion; and that he should have used the expression κρινω, I determine, Act 15:19 which, had it been found in St. Peter's speech, would have been a much more plausible argument in favor of his weakly boasted supremacy, than the whole scripture now affords.
Consider
Coke draws the weightiest conclusion concerning the Spirit's guidance of the church.
Verse 28. Acts 15:28 . It seemed good to the Holy Ghost, and to us, — Though this may include the decision which the Spirit had givenby his descent upon Cornelius and his friends, yet it seems more directly to express the consciousness which this assembly had, of beingguidedbyhisinfluencesontheir minds in their present determination. When the apostles call these things necessary, they mean, by a common mode of speaking, necessary for those times and circumstances. They were undoubtedly necessary, in order to promote a free converse between the Jewish and Gentile Christians, and especially to secure communion at the table of the Lord; where we cannot imagine that Jews would have eaten and drunk with persons whom they thought in so polluted a state as those who indulged themselves in the things here prohibited. On the other hand, it seems that the Jews on these conditions gave up any further debate about other forbidden meats, as well as circumcision, &c.He closes the section with a final pastoral warning against imposing uncommanded yokes.
Verse 41. Acts 15:41 . Confirming the churches. — Mr. Cradock and many others think, that St. Paul sailed from Cilicia to Crete at this time, and, returning to the Asiatic continent quickly after, left Titus to perfect the settlement of the church there, Titus 1:5 . Inferences.— How early did the spirit of bigotry and imposition begin to work in the Christian church!—that fatal humour of imposing a yoke on the neck of Christ's disciples, by making indifferent things necessary!—that unmanly and antichristian disposition, which has almost ever since been rending the church to pieces, and clamorously throwing the blame on those, who have been desirous, on principles truly evangelical, to stand fast in the liberty with which Christ, their divine Master, hath made them free! How foolish and how mischievous the error, of making terms of communion which Christ never made!
Respond
1. Where in my own life or congregation am I tempted to add requirements that Christ has not laid upon his people?
2. How ready am I to seek the mind of the whole church, and especially the counsel of wiser brethren, when disputes arise?
3. In what ways can I more gladly trust that the same Spirit who led the Jerusalem council still leads the church today?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank thee for the faithful witness of thy servant Thomas Coke, who traced thy Spirit's work among the first believers. Grant us the same humility that sent the church at Antioch to Jerusalem for counsel. Keep us from binding heavy burdens on one another, and teach us to prize the liberty wherewith Christ has made us free. May the same Spirit who said, "It seemed good to the Holy Ghost, and to us," bear witness in our hearts, purify our motives, and knit us together in love. Through Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →