Eterniseed › Curriculum › 2 Samuel
2 Samuel 19-20 — with Benson
Opening
Beloved, we gather today under the steady light of Joseph Benson’s the Commentary on the Old and New Testaments, allowing his measured Wesleyan insight to guide our reading of David’s troubled return. In these chapters the Spirit shows us both the cost of sin and the surprising breadth of mercy that still flows from the throne of grace. Benson helps us see how the king’s private grief and public duty meet at the city gate, and how the same heart that mourns must also govern. May the Lord who restored David also restore us to ordered affection and holy courage as we listen together.
Read
Let us read slowly and prayerfully the nineteenth and twentieth chapters of Second Samuel. Hear how the victory over Absalom is turned to mourning, how Joab rouses the king, how Judah and Israel contend at the Jordan, and how a new rebellion flares under Sheba. Notice the pardons granted, the estates restored, the oaths sworn, and the blood shed at the highway. Ask the Spirit to show you where grief, justice, and mercy meet in your own story.
Study
Benson opens by recounting Joab’s stern address to the sorrowing king.
Verses 5-6. 2 Samuel 19:5-6 . Joab said, Thou hast shamed this day the faces of all thy servants By disappointing their just hopes of praises and rewards, and requiting them with contempt and tacit rebukes; and thus making them hang down their heads, as if they had committed such a crime, that they were ashamed to look men in the face. Which this day have saved thy life, and the lives of thy sons, &c. Who, in all probability, would all have been slain, if Absalom had gained the victory. In that thou lovest thine enemies Thy rebellious son, and those associated with him, to effect thy destruction. And hatest thy friends Who have risked their lives in thy defence, but in whose preservation thou seemest to take no pleasure, only grieving for the death of a rebel. If Absalom had lived, and we had all died, then it would have pleased thee well Joab seems to speak this in reference to the exclamation of the king, Would God I had died for thee, O Absalom! for had this been the case, as the king wished, Joab and the rest of David’s faithful commanders would in course have perished through the power of Absalom, who would then have had none to oppose him. Joab’s words, however, are not to be understood as exactly true, but as spoken hyperbolically: but David’s carriage gave too much colour to such a suggestion; and such sharpness of speech was in a manner necessary to awaken the king out of his lethargy, and to preserve him from the impendent mischiefs.He then considers David’s surprising appointment of Amasa over the host.
Verse 13. 2 Samuel 19:13 . Say to Amasa, Art thou not of my bone, &c. That is, nearly related to me, being my sister’s son. God do so to me, and more also, &c. He solemnly promises to prefer him to the highest command in the kingdom; for he now thought it a fit time to depress Joab, who was grown insufferably insolent and imperious, and who, through his credit with the army, had protected himself in the commission of the greatest crimes. He had slain Abner most perfidiously in cold blood, and killed Absalom contrary to the king’s express command, and now lately had insulted him in his sorrow. Having, therefore, now an opportunity of transferring the command to another person, who had as great an interest in the people’s favour as Joab, he gladly embraces it, that so he might both chastise Joab for his faults, and rescue himself from the bondage in which that general had hitherto held him. Some, however, have thought that, considering Joab’s very faithful services to David in all the changes of his fortune, and that his violent measures proceeded in part from a regard to him, as judging them necessary for his safety and tranquillity, David’s conduct in this instance, in making Amasa captain of the host in Joab’s room, is not an amiable trait in his character, and was not a prudent step at this time, especially considering Joab’s violent temper: and, it must be acknowledged, it brought on the murder of Amasa.Next Benson examines the king’s oath of pardon spoken to Shimei.
Verses 21-23. 2 Samuel 19:21-23 . Abishai said, Shall not Shimei be put to death? Abishai had before highly resented Shimei’s vile treatment of David, and thought this a fit season for taking revenge. What have I to do with you, ye sons of Zeruiah? It seems Joab joined with his brother, and together they thought to govern all the king’s motions as they pleased. But he bids them, in a disdainful manner, stand aside, and not intermeddle in this matter. That ye should this day be adversaries unto me? Should hinder me from following my own inclinations, and set my people against me. For, by taking their advice, David might have alienated the hearts of all Israel from him, and made them fear the like punishment for their revolt. Shall any man be put to death this day in Israel? In a time of universal joy, shall any family have cause for lamentation?
Consider
Benson presses the reasons David chose mercy rather than severity on this day of restoration.
It was undoubtedly David’s interest, at this time, to appease the people, and reconcile them to himself, and not give them any new distaste by acts of severity; which would have made others jealous, that he would watch an opportunity to be revenged on them. Do I not know that I am this day king over Israel? And, therefore, have power to punish or to pardon as I please. Is not my kingdom, which was in a manner wholly lost, just now restored and assured to me? And when God hath been so merciful to me in forgiving my sin, shall I show myself revengeful to Shimei? Shall I sully the glory of this day with an act of such severity? Or, shall I alienate the hearts of my people from me, now they are returned to me? “He knew himself a king,” says Delaney, “not of one party, but of a whole people; and therefore wisely resolved that his fatherly affection should extend to them all.He closes by tracing how the unchecked dispute between Judah and Israel opened the door to fresh rebellion.
As David did not think fit to interpose, the Israelites judged that he was partial, and favoured Judah, and thence arose a new rebellion.
Respond
Where in your life has unchecked grief kept you from the duties love still requires? How might you extend the mercy you have received without excusing what must be named? In what present contention is the Spirit inviting you to yield the fiercer word for the sake of peace?
Pray
Gracious Lord, who restored David through the frank speech of a servant and the quiet power of mercy, grant us the same honest counsel and tender heart. Teach us when to rise, when to pardon, and when to hold our peace. Keep us from the strife that breeds new rebellion and from the grief that forgets the living. May our homes and churches reflect the reconciling love of Christ, who bore our sorrows and still bears us home. In his name we pray. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →