Eterniseed › Curriculum › Luke
Luke 20 — with Whedon
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry and Arminian confidence in the full counsel of God, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon's careful exposition of Luke chapter 20 invites us to trace the Lord's defense of the resurrection against the Sadducees and his clear warning against the scribes. With reverent attention we prepare to receive the Word through this trusted Wesleyan voice, asking the Spirit to quicken our understanding for holy living.
Read
Let us now read Luke chapter 20 in full, listening for the questions posed to Jesus and the authority with which he answers. Attend especially to the exchange concerning the resurrection and the final admonition regarding those who seek honor for themselves. May the Lord grant us ears to hear his living word.
Study
Whedon opens by examining inferences drawn from the phrase accounted worthy.
Verse 35. 35 . They which shall be accounted worthy From the words accounted worthy, some draw the inference that the resurrection is conditional and partial; that it is limited to the worthy, while the wicked are left in perpetual extinction. It is an unwarranted conclusion. For, 1. The Greek word here rendered accounted worthy is often elegantly put for equum censetur, it is thought proper, or it seems good; good, that is, in the present case, to the Divine Mind. The meaning then would be: Those who by the Divine will shall attain the resurrection. Their resurrection would be not dependent upon personal worthiness, but upon God’s plan; whether of a part or the whole. 2.He proceeds to clarify the limited scope of the Sadducees' question.
As the question of the Sadducees, (briefly feigning to be orthodox,) which Christ here answers, regarded solely the children of Abraham, who were assumed to be of course heirs of the blessed resurrection, it is of the blessed resurrection, or the blessed side of the resurrection, only, that Jesus now speaks, to which the worthy alone do in fact attain. In the same manner Paul in 1 Corinthians 15:0 , as writing for the Christian alone, describes only the glorious resurrection. In neither case is it implied that there is not also, and at the same time, a resurrection of the unjust, ( Acts 24:15 ,) or resurrection of damnation, John 5:29 . Resurrection from the dead Literally, resurrection from dead. There is apparently a difference in meaning between the three phrases, resurrection of the dead, resurrection from the dead, and resurrection from dead, without the article. Says Winer, (Gram. of N.T., vol. ii, p.Whedon then unfolds the meaning of being equal unto the angels.
Verse 36. 36 . Neither can they die Soul and body are made incapable of separation, and both incapable of disintegration or extinction. Death from violence, either from others or their own efforts, is impossible, and out of their natures. Equal unto the angels In Mark, are as the angels which are in heaven. Luke’s words might be translated are angel-like . To them, as to angels, is attributed neither death, birth, nor marriage. It is not to be inferred that the angels are, like men even in their glorified state, of a compound nature, body and soul. Angels we understand to be pure spirits, who in becoming visible to bodily eyes invest themselves with a visible vehicle; unless, indeed, we suppose with some that matter is but a denser and solidified sort of spirit. And are the children of God… children of the resurrection Literally , sons of the resurrection. The opposite of this would be son of gehenna, or child of hell, in Matthew 23:15 . This is in accordance with that Hebrew figure of speech by which a being is said to be a son or child of that to whose nature he is conformed, or to whom he somehow belongs. So son of Belial, son of perdition, son of death. They who attain the resurrection in its glorious side cannot die, because they are now angel-like, and so god-like, resurrection-like.
Consider
Finally Whedon shows how the argument affirms both resurrection and immortality together.
Verse 37. 37 . Now that the dead are raisen Our Lord, in the argument of this verse, does not prove the resurrection of the body distinctively from the immortality of the soul. This is because he is arguing with those who hold the former to be included in and inseparably identified with the latter. To prove one, therefore, is to prove both. See notes on Matthew 22:32 .
Respond
1. How does the assurance that the resurrection belongs to God's own plan strengthen your hope today? 2. In what ways might you guard against the self-exalting spirit Jesus condemns in the scribes? 3. Where is the Spirit prompting you to live even now as a child of the resurrection?
Pray
Gracious God, Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, we thank thee for the faithful labors of Daniel D. Whedon and for the light his commentary sheds upon thy holy word. Grant us, we beseech thee, the same Spirit that raised Jesus from the dead, that we may walk as children of the resurrection, angel-like in purity and undying in hope. Keep us from every proud and self-seeking way, and make us worthy, not by our merit but by thy electing grace, to attain that blessed resurrection. Through Christ our risen Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →