Eterniseed › Curriculum › Deuteronomy
The Place He Shall Choose: One Altar Against the Falsely-Named Gods
Opening
As Israel nears the land, Moses gives a law that will shape all their worship: when they have crossed over, they are not to sacrifice wherever they please, but only in the place the Lord their God shall choose, to set His name there. Blessed Theodoret of Cyrus reads this law with his characteristic care for the divine purpose behind the command. In the wilderness, he explains, they had offered sacrifice at every halting-station, for they were continually on the move; but in the settled land such freedom would become a snare. God therefore confines the sacrifices to one chosen place, lest the people seize the pretext of scattered altars and slip into sacrificing to the falsely-named gods. Theodoret sees this as the wisdom of the all-wise Lawgiver, who knew that the teacher of impiety enslaves men through gluttony and the love of pleasure, mixing many amusements into the feasts of the demons. So the resourceful Lord, delivering Israel from that error, did not simply forbid joy — He legislated holy feasts, permitted sacrifices, allowed even musical instruments, and commanded the people to feast beside His temple. Theodoret carefully distinguishes the two tithes — one for the Levites, one for the feasting of the offerers with the widow, the orphan, and the proselyte — and explains why blood may not be eaten: because the law is healing their murderous disposition. The one chosen place, where God sets His name, the Church reads as the figure of the one altar, the one Church, where alone the true Sacrifice is offered.
Read
Read Deuteronomy 11–12 — Moses sets before them blessing and curse, and charges them to keep the commandments when they enter the land: "ye shall utterly destroy all the places, wherein the nations which ye shall possess served their gods… And ye shall overthrow their altars… and destroy the names of them out of that place." Then the great law of the one sanctuary: "But unto the place which the Lord your God shall choose out of all your tribes to put his name there, even unto his habitation shall ye seek, and thither thou shalt come: and thither ye shall bring your burnt offerings, and your sacrifices, and your tithes… And there ye shall eat before the Lord your God, and ye shall rejoice in all that ye put your hand unto, ye and your households." He permits them to slaughter and eat meat within their gates, "the unclean and the clean," as of the gazelle and the hart, only forbidding the blood: "Only ye shall not eat the blood; ye shall pour it upon the earth as water." And he warns them, when the nations are cut off before them, not to be ensnared into asking, "How did these nations serve their gods? even so will I do likewise."
Study
Why does the law confine sacrifice to one chosen place? Theodoret answers from the danger of scattered altars in a settled land — the pretext they would give for idolatry:
he therefore forbids them to do anything of the kind in the land of promise, lest they seize the pretext for sacrificing to the falsely-named gods. He sees in this the deep pedagogy of the Lawgiver, who does not abolish festal joy but redeems it from the demons' feasts:
the resourceful Lord, delivering Israel from that error, both legislated concerning the feasts, and permitted sacrifices, and allowed for musical instruments, and commanded them to feast, cutting off the impiety of idols by such means of spiritual recreation. He distinguishes the two tithes, one for the Levites and one for the sacred feasting of the offerers:
He ordered two tithes to be consecrated from one's possessions: one to be brought to the Levites, the other to be sold and its price expended on the feasting of the offerers themselves, together with the widows, the orphans and the proselytes.
Consider
The law of the one chosen place — "the place which the Lord your God shall choose, to put his name there" — is, in Theodoret's sober reading, a guard against idolatry: scatter the altars, and you scatter the worship, and soon the falsely-named gods creep in. But the Church has always heard in this one chosen place a deeper figure. Israel's worship was gathered into a single sanctuary so that God's name might be one and His altar one; and this points forward to the one true place where God has set His name forever — His Son, and the Church which is His Body. There is one Lord, one faith, one baptism (Eph 4:5); there is one altar on which the one Sacrifice is offered. The scattered altars of the nations, where men sacrificed to demons, are the very thing the Lawgiver labored to abolish; and the Church, like Moses, calls her children away from every counterfeit worship to the one place where the true God is rightly adored. Notice, too, the tenderness Theodoret finds in the law: God does not crush human joy but sanctifies it. He gives feasts, sacrifices, even music, and commands the people to rejoice before Him — and to rejoice with the widow, the orphan, and the stranger, that no one be left out of the holy gladness. This is the Church's own festal life: joy gathered into one place, around one altar, shared with the poor, cut free from the impiety of idols. And even the forbidding of blood, Theodoret teaches, is mercy, a deeper remedy than diet —
For it is healing their murderous disposition— God training a violent people toward reverence for life, until the day when the true Blood, the Blood of Christ, would be given not to be poured upon the earth but to be drunk for the life of the world.
Respond
Learn from this law where true worship is found. God gathered Israel's sacrifices into one chosen place so that their worship would not be scattered and corrupted; and He has gathered yours into the one Church, around the one altar, where His Son, the true Sacrifice, is offered. Do not scatter your devotion among the counterfeit altars of the age — the idols of pleasure, possession, and self that the world sets up on every high hill. Seek the place where God has put His name; come to His habitation; bring your offerings there. And learn, too, that God means for you to rejoice. Theodoret shows you a Lawgiver who does not abolish festal gladness but redeems it: He gives feasts, He permits music, He commands His people to eat and rejoice before Him. So let your faith be joyful, not grim; let the worship of God be your true festival, the holy recreation that cuts the love of idols out of your heart. But keep the pattern God set: rejoice with the widow, the orphan, and the stranger. The tithe was not only for the Levite but for the feasting of the poor; the holy gladness was to be shared. So let no one be left outside your joy. Gather your worship into the one place where God's name dwells, make it joyful, and make it generous — and the falsely-named gods will find no foothold in your heart.
Pray
O all-wise Lord, who didst gather the worship of Thy people into the one place where Thou wouldst set Thy name, that they might not scatter their sacrifices and slip into the service of the falsely-named gods: gather my worship, too, into the one Church, around the one altar where Thy Son, the true Sacrifice, is offered for the life of the world. Keep me from every counterfeit altar that the world sets up, and let me seek Thee in Thy habitation and bring my offerings there. Thou art the God who redeems even our gladness; Thou didst not abolish the feast but didst hallow it, giving Thy people sacrifices and music and holy joy, and commanding them to rejoice before Thee together with the widow, the orphan, and the stranger. Make my faith joyful and generous after this pattern: let the worship of Thee be my true festival, and let none be left outside my gladness. Heal the hardness and the cruelty of my heart, as Thou didst train Thy people by the law of the blood, until I reverence all that lives; and feed me at Thy Table with the precious Blood of Thy Son, given for my life. To Thee, O Christ our God, the one Sacrifice on the one altar, with the Father and the all-holy Spirit, be glory now and ever, and unto ages of ages. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →