Eterniseed › Curriculum › Ecclesiastes
Ecclesiastes 11-12 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary
Opening
Welcome to this daily lesson drawn from Haydock's Catholic Family Bible Commentary on Ecclesiastes chapters 11 and 12. In these final chapters the Preacher urges generous living, remembrance of the Creator, and preparation for judgment. Haydock's compilation gathers the insights of Challoner, Calmet, Worthington and others to illuminate the text for Catholic readers today. Over the next twenty minutes we will read the sacred words, study selected commentary paragraphs, consider their deeper connections, respond with reflection, and close in prayer. May the Spirit plant eternal seed in our hearts through this ancient wisdom.
Read
Take a quiet moment to read Ecclesiastes chapters 11 and 12 slowly and prayerfully. Listen for the call to sow mercy without calculation, to remember your Creator in the days of youth, and to fear God because every deed will be brought to judgment. Let the images of light, clouds, and the failing body speak to your own season of life. When you finish, return here ready to study how Haydock's commentary unfolds these verses.
Study
Haydock opens the section on chapter 11 by directing attention to the call for generous sowing.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Waters. Sow thy seed where it may produce a good crop. (Calmet) --- Be charitable to all, Luke vi. 30. Indiscrete faciendum bene. (St. Jerome) --- Assist those in distress, (Calmet) even though they may be ungrateful, or unable to make a return, Luke xiv. 12. (Tirinus) --- In this third part we are exhorted to serve God with perseverance. Of all virtues, the works of mercy avail most, Matthew xxv. (Worthington)On the image of the falling tree, the commentary next explains the unchangeable state after death.
If the tree fall, &c. The state of the soul is unchangeable, when once she comes to heaven or hell: and the soul that departs this life in the state of grace, shall never fall from grace; as on the other side, a soul that dies out of the state of grace, shall never come to it. But this does not exclude a place of temporal punishment for such souls as die in the state of grace: yet not so as to be entirely pure; and therefore they shall be saved, indeed, yet so as by fire, 1 Corinthians iii. 13, 14, 15. (Challoner) --- After death, none can merit. (Worthington) --- "He who shall not have cultivated his field, (the soul) shall after this life experience the fire of purgation, or eternal punishment." (St. Augustine, de Gen. contra Man. iii. 20.) (Haydock) --- The souls in purgatory have their names inscribed in heaven, like the ancient saints, who were detained in the bosom of Abraham. (Calmet) --- They fall, therefore, to the south. Let people dispense their alms to all, as the clouds rain upon the just and unjust, (Haydock) upon the cultivated and the barren land, and let them do it before death. They know not how soon it may lay them low. (Calmet) --- By looking at the branches of a tree, we may conclude which way it will fall; so we may form a judgment of our future state, by reflecting on our present dispositions. "Our branches are our desires, by which we stretch ourselves to the south, if they be spiritual," &c. (St. Bernard, ser. xlix.) The liberal are not concerned where they bestow charity. People will gather up the fruit both on the north and south, and they who have given alms will find them (Abenezra; Mercer.) laid up in the heavenly tabernacles. (Haydock) --- This agrees with the sequel. (Calmet)Haydock then turns to chapter 12 and stresses the need to act before old age arrives.
Haydock Catholic Bible Commentary Not. Prevent old age, to procure a stock of virtues. (Haydock) --- Solomon refutes the former sentiments of the wicked, which he had perhaps once entertained. (Calmet)
Consider
Haydock next draws out the distinction between body and soul.
It. Man is composed of two distinct parts; the destination of which we ought never to forget. Thus the objection of infidels (chap. iii. 19.) is refuted. Plato and some of the ancients had the same idea of the soul's spiritual nature; though some took it to be an aerial body. (Calmet)Finally the commentary gathers the entire book into its moral conclusion.
Ecclesiastes. "The preacher." (Worthington) --- He returns to his first proposition, and having pushed the objection of free-thinkers as far as possible, shews us what we ought to believe and practise. He establishes the distinction of soul and body, the advantage of instruction, (ver. 11.) without meddling with things too high, (ver. 12.) the obligation of fearing God, (ver. 13.) and future retribution, ver. 14. This is the sum of all sound morality. (Calmet)
Respond
How does the call to give without expecting return challenge your present habits of generosity? In what concrete way can you remember your Creator before the days grow dark? Which single verse from these chapters most moves you to live in holy fear today?
Pray
Lord of every season, teach us to sow mercy freely upon the waters and to remember our Creator while strength remains, walking always in holy fear. Draw our souls to you as the body returns to dust and the spirit to its God, that every deed may be offered for your glory and the salvation of souls. Through Christ our Lord. Amen.
Source & Verification
The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.
See the original, our full translation, and the review →