← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Tobit

Tobit 1-2 — drawing on Aquinas (Summa II-II q.32 almsgiving + q.101 pietas)

Tobit 1-2Saint Thomas Aquinas — Summa Theologiae + Catena Aurea + Commentary on Sentences22 min
Opening
The opening chapters of the book of Tobit place before the Church a figure whose entire religion is structured around the corporal works of mercy and especially around the dangerous duty of burying the unjustly slain. Drawing on Aquinas's treatment of almsgiving in Summa Theologiae II-II q.32 and his treatment of pietas (filial and familial piety) in II-II q.101, we may approach Tobit not merely as a moral exemplar but as a particular instance of the theological logic by which the works of mercy constitute the body's participation in the soul's love of God. Aquinas treats almsgiving (eleemosyna) under the genus of charity, holding in II-II q.32 a.1 that almsgiving is an act of charity through the medium of mercy, by which the giver relieves the misery of another for the love of God. The Catena Aurea, Aquinas's compilation of patristic commentary on the four Gospels, draws sustained attention to Christ's teaching on almsgiving in Matthew 6, and threads through it the voices of Augustine and Chrysostom that this lesson will follow. The Church receives Tobit's hidden charity in the captivity of Nineveh as the Old Testament substrate of the ordered love that Aquinas's treatise on almsgiving articulates with scholastic precision.
Read
Read Tobit chapters 1 and 2 with attention to the precise enumeration of Tobit's almsgiving and his attention to the burial of the unjustly slain. Notice his autobiographical account of his early observance of the three tithes — the Levitical tithe, the Jerusalem tithe, and the tithe distributed to orphans, widows, and converts; his continued observance after the deportation; his refusal to eat the food of the Gentiles though most of his kindred ate; the favor he found at the court of Shalmaneser; and his courageous burial of the slain Israelites under the succeeding king's death decree. Mark the closing scene of chapter two where Tobit, ritually defiled from his most recent burial and sleeping beneath a wall, is blinded by the warm droppings of sparrows; the physicians' failed attempts at treatment; his wife Anna's labor at weaving; the quarrel between them when she returns with a kid given as a gift. Hold in mind the contrast between Tobit's external trial and his interior religious order.
Study
Drawing on Aquinas's treatment of almsgiving in Summa II-II q.32, we may articulate the structure of Tobit's charity with scholastic precision. Aquinas holds in q.32 a.1 that almsgiving (eleemosyna) is an act of charity exercised through the medium of mercy: misericordia is the affective passion by which the soul is moved by the misery of another, and almsgiving is the external act by which that misericordia is brought to effective relief. Tobit's three-tithe pattern in chapter one corresponds to what Aquinas in q.87 (on the precept of tithes) and in q.32 a.5-6 distinguishes between the obligation of justice (the tithe owed in justice to the priesthood and the support of the cult) and the obligation of charity (the further alms given to the poor beyond what justice requires). Tobit's third tithe distributed to orphans, widows, and converts is the paradigmatic instance of the latter category, and Aquinas would recognize in Tobit's continued observance after the deportation a witness to the principle articulated in q.32 a.5 that the obligation of almsgiving extends beyond ordinary circumstances into circumstances of exile and pressure, because charity is a virtue infused in the soul rather than a habit conditioned by external circumstance. The corporal work of mercy that constitutes the spine of Tobit's narrative is the burial of the unjustly slain. Aquinas treats the dignity of the human body and the corresponding duty of burial in several places: in II-II q.32 a.2 he enumerates the seven corporal works of mercy and lists the burial of the dead seventh, citing as his sed contra authority Tobit himself; in q.59 (on respect for the dead) he extends the treatment; in the Catena Aurea on Matthew 8:21-22 (where the disciple asks leave to bury his father before following Christ) he threads the patristic discussion of how the corporal work of mercy of burying the dead nevertheless yields, in particular cases, to the higher claim of evangelical discipleship. Aquinas's treatment of this question follows Augustine closely. In his work De cura pro mortuis gerenda (On the Care to Be Taken for the Dead), Augustine had argued that the body of the deceased is to be treated with reverence not because its condition affects the soul's situation but because of the dignity owed to that which was once and will be again the temple of the Holy Spirit. Aquinas in II-II q.32 a.2 follows Augustine in this judgment, and would recognize in Tobit's burial of the slain Israelites cast into the marketplace of Nineveh the particular instance of mercy that Augustine had argued for in his treatise. The further question Aquinas raises in II-II q.32 a.6 is whether almsgiving should be given indiscriminately or by ordered preference. His response distinguishes between the strict order of charity (in which one is bound to give first to those most closely connected by familial bond or covenant relationship) and the prudential extension of almsgiving to strangers and even enemies (which is praiseworthy beyond the obligation but is permitted when basic obligations are met). Tobit's giving to the slain Israelites is the giving to those most closely connected by covenant bond — they are his kinsmen, his fellow exiles, men of his people. Aquinas would recognize in this priority the structure of well-ordered charity that q.32 a.6 articulates. The household conflict between Tobit and Anna at the close of chapter two is a particular case worth Aquinas's attention. He treats marital conflict in the Supplement q.65 and in I-II q.46-48 on the passion of anger; his judgment would be that Tobit's initial suspicion of Anna (the assumption that the gift kid had been stolen) was a failure of just charity within the household, and that Anna's stinging reply (recalling Tobit's failed charity to his wife in their trial) was a failure of the patience that pietas (II-II q.101 a.3) requires within the family. The conflict is restored by Tobit's prayer in chapter three. Drawing the patristic anchor that Aquinas uses, Saint John Chrysostom in his homily 21 on Matthew (which the Catena Aurea preserves at length) had taught that the household is the school of charity in which the works of mercy are first learned and from which they extend to the wider community; the discord between Tobit and Anna is precisely the disorder Chrysostom warns against. Aquinas's scholastic apparatus enables the reader of Tobit to see in the narrative not merely a sequence of virtuous acts but the inner structure of a religious life ordered by charity, exercised through mercy, manifested in almsgiving, refined by patience, and corrected when necessary by the prayer that q.83 (on prayer) treats as the soul's continuing conversation with God.
Consider
Drawing on Aquinas's articulation in II-II q.32 a.6 of the order of charity, consider the structure of your own almsgiving. Aquinas distinguishes between the strict obligation of charity (which is first to those most closely connected by familial bond and covenant) and the prudential extension to strangers and enemies. Have you ordered your almsgiving according to this scholastic principle, or has your charity drifted toward either the anonymous abstraction (giving only to organizations that handle the relationships on your behalf) or the favored circle (giving only to those whose company you enjoy)? Consider too Tobit's continued observance under exile. Aquinas's principle in q.32 a.5 that charity is an infused virtue rather than a habit conditioned by external circumstance has the practical implication that the loss of comfortable circumstance is not an excuse for the loss of the works of mercy. The Catholic moral tradition has been steady about this. Where in your own life have you used a change of circumstance as a reason to scale back the works of mercy that your previous condition supported? Consider finally the household conflict at the close of chapter two. Drawing on Aquinas's treatment of pietas in II-II q.101, consider whether the works of mercy you perform outside the home have a corresponding structure of pietas inside the home. The patristic principle Chrysostom articulates and Aquinas cites is that the household is the school of charity. Has your household become such a school, or has the charity you exercise outside the home gradually replaced rather than enriched the pietas required within it?
Respond
This week, take one specific act from the seven corporal works of mercy that Aquinas enumerates in Summa II-II q.32 a.2 (feed the hungry, give drink to the thirsty, clothe the naked, shelter the homeless, visit the sick, visit the imprisoned, bury the dead) and perform it deliberately for a person inside the order of charity that q.32 a.6 articulates as primary — a family member, a parishioner, a neighbor, a member of the household of faith — before extending the same action to those further from your immediate covenant bonds. Let the act be small enough that you complete it and concrete enough that it costs you something.
Pray
O God our Father, who hast revealed in thy servant Tobit the ordering of almsgiving and pietas as living participation in thy charity, conform our hearts and households to this same love so that every work of mercy may become an act of worship pleasing to thee. Through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints, grant that we may faithfully extend thy mercy to the living and the dead. Amen.

Saint Thomas Aquinas — Summa Theologiae + Catena Aurea + Commentary on Sentences · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are rendered into English by Eterniseed from the public-domain original by multi-model convergence, independently checked for fidelity to the source, and reviewed by a four-model cross-provider panel. Every quotation is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of that published rendering.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →