← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Deuteronomy

Deuteronomy 21-22 — with Whedon

Deuteronomy 21-22Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments20 min
Opening
In the spirit of Methodist Episcopal inquiry and Arminian confidence in the plain reading of Scripture, we turn today to Daniel D. Whedon’s Commentary on the Old and New Testaments. Whedon’s careful exposition of Deuteronomy 21–22 opens the ancient statutes to the light of gospel grace, showing how Israel’s civil and moral laws guarded life, protected the vulnerable, and upheld the sanctity of the covenant community. His measured, reverent notes invite us to receive these chapters not as relics but as living witnesses to God’s righteous order.
Read
Let us now read Deuteronomy chapters 21 and 22, listening for the voice that calls a people to justice, mercy, and purity. As the words are read aloud, may the Holy Spirit quicken our hearts to receive both the warning and the promise contained in these statutes of the covenant.
Study
Whedon opens by describing the prescribed ritual for an unsolved slaying. Verse 4. 4 . A rough valley The Hebrew term which is here rendered valley also means a stream, and many critics have rendered the expression a perennial stream. Neither eared nor sown Eared is the old term for ploughed. The heifer was to be brought to a valley through which flowed a perennial stream, a valley that had never been cultivated, and here be slain. This putting to death of the heifer was not, properly speaking, expiatory. It was symbolical, and calculated to impress upon the people the sacredness of human life. He then turns to the protective statutes given for female captives taken in lawful war. Verses 10-14. DIRECTIONS RESPECTING FEMALE WAR-CAPTIVES, Deuteronomy 21:10-14 . The directions that follow must refer to captives that might be taken in war with the neighbouring nations after the Canaanites have been extirpated. The law was designed for the protection of the female captive, and was far in advance of the usages of the other nations of antiquity. Whedon next sets forth the law’s provision for the incorrigible son and the communal safeguard surrounding it. Verse 18. THE PUNISHMENT OF AN INCORRIGIBLE SON, Deuteronomy 21:18-21 . 18 . A stubborn and rebellious son The directions given are intended to assert and also limit the authority of the parents. If the son was refractory no longer obedient provision was made for his punishment. From our point of view the law seems severe. But it must be borne in mind that in some ancient nations the power over the life of the child was absolutely in the father’s hand. Moses provides that both parents should consent to the infliction of the penalty, the matter having first been brought before the whole community. In the Gemara, Rabbi Simon is represented as saving that the law concerning a stubborn and rebellious son has never been, and never can be, practically applied.
Consider
On the curse attached to the hanged malefactor, Whedon presses the apostolic application. Verse 23. 23 . His body shall not remain all night upon the tree The exposed dead body defiled the land. Comp. Joshua 8:29 ; Joshua 10:26 . For he that is hanged is accursed of God The translation given in the version is the one most generally accepted. The Jewish commentators have rendered it: “He that is hanged is a curse to God that is, an insult or mockery.” We prefer the former. The whole passage would be equivalent to this: “Let not the body hang on the tree after sunset, for the hanging body of a malefactor defiles the land, since the curse of God rests upon it.” For the application of the passage, “He that is hanged is accursed of God,” to Jesus Christ, see Galatians 3:13 . Finally he weighs the stringent safeguards placed around the marriage bond. Verses 13-29. 13-29 . If any man take a wife , etc. This section relates to purity in reference to marriage. The wellbeing of the family and of the state depends upon strict observance of the laws of purity in the relation of husband and wife. If a husband unjustly accused his newly married wife of unchastity before marriage he was punished with stripes by the elders of the city, and further punished by a fine, to be paid to the father of the traduced wife. And as it was possible the charge might have arisen from the desire of the husband to contract another marriage, he was not allowed to put away his wife. But if the charge against the chastity of the wife was proved she was to be put to death. Adultery was to be punished with death, the death of both guilty parties. The sanctity of the marriage relation was most strictly protected. The woman betrothed was regarded in the same light as the married woman. The violation of the law required the death penalty. Both the man and the woman were to be put to death. In Deuteronomy 22:25-27 violence is supposed on the part of the man. In this case the man suffers the penalty of death. The case supposed in Deuteronomy 22:28-29 , is similar to that mentioned in Exodus 22:16 .
Respond
1. How does the communal responsibility shown in these laws stir us to guard one another’s lives today? 2. In what ways might the protections extended to the vulnerable challenge our own practices of mercy? 3. Where is the Spirit inviting us to renewed reverence for the marriage covenant and the sanctity of the home?
Pray
Gracious God, who gave Israel statutes both just and merciful, we thank Thee for the light shed by Thy servant Whedon upon these chapters. Grant us grace to prize the sacredness of human life, to shelter the stranger and the captive, and to uphold the honor of marriage with holy fidelity. May the curse borne by our Lord Jesus Christ move us to walk in newness of life, and may the Spirit of holiness so dwell in our households that they become schools of Thy kingdom. Through Christ our Redeemer, Amen.

Whedon's Commentary on the Old and New Testaments · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →