← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › Apology of the Augsburg Confession

Apology — Of Monastic Vows — Book of Concord

Apology of the Augsburg Confession 24The Book of Concord15 min
Opening
Today we turn to the Apology of the Augsburg Confession, specifically its article Of Monastic Vows. This section of the Lutheran Confessions addresses a central Reformation concern: the proper place of vows and religious orders in the life of faith. It confesses that justification rests solely on Christ’s merits received by faith, not on human traditions or works of supererogation. For Lutheran readers this article safeguards the Gospel promise that salvation is God’s free gift, freeing consciences from the burden of seeking righteousness through monastic rules or ceremonies. Its witness remains vital for understanding Christian vocation and the freedom of the Gospel in daily life.
Read
We invite you to read the Apology’s treatment Of Monastic Vows in its entirety. The article rests especially on passages such as Galatians 5:4, Matthew 15:9, Romans 14:23, and 1 Timothy 4:8, which the Confession cites to show that remission of sins is received freely for Christ’s sake. As you read, attend to how the text distinguishes lawful vows from those that contradict the Gospel promise.
Study
The Confession specifies the doctrinal questions under discussion concerning monastic vows. But we are now discussing the kind of doctrine which the composers of the Confutation are now defending, and not the question whether vows should be observed. For we hold that lawful vows ought to be observed; but whether these services merit the remission of sins and justification; whether they are satisfactions for sins; whether they are equal to Baptism; whether they are the observance of precepts and counsels; whether they are evangelical perfection; whether they have the merits of supererogation; whether these merits, when applied on behalf of others, save them; whether vows made with these opinions are lawful; whether vows are lawful that are undertaken under the pretext of religion, merely for the sake of the belly and idleness; whether those are truly vows that have been extorted either from the unwilling, or from those who on account of age were not able to judge concerning the kind of life, whom parents or friends thrust into the monasteries that they might be supported at the public expense, without the loss of private patrimony; whether vows are lawful that openly tend to an evil issue, either because on account of weakness they are not observed, or because those who are in these fraternities are compelled to approve and aid the abuses of the Mass, the godless worship of saints, and the counsels to rage against good men: concerning these questions we are treating. It proceeds to examine the claim that monastic works merit the remission of sins before God. First, it is very certain that a vow is not lawful by which he who vows thinks that he merits the remission of sins before God, or makes satisfaction before God for sins. For this opinion is a manifest insult to the Gospel, which teaches that the remission of sins is freely granted us for Christ’s sake, as has been said above at some length. Therefore we have correctly quoted the declaration of Paul to the Galatians, Gal. 5:4: Christ is become of no effect unto you, whosoever of you are justified by the Law; ye are fallen from grace. Those who seek the remission of sins, not by faith in Christ, but by monastic works, detract from the honor of Christ, and crucify Christ afresh. But hear, hear how the composers of the Confutation escape in this place! They explain this passage of Paul only concerning the Law of Moses, and they add that the monks observe all things for Christ’s sake, and endeavor to live the nearer the Gospel in order to merit eternal life. And they add a horrible peroration in these words: Wherefore those things are wicked that are here alleged against monasticism. The Confession next treats obedience, poverty, and celibacy as adiaphora when rightly understood. Secondly. Obedience, poverty, and celibacy, provided the latter is not impure, are, as exercises, adiaphora [in which we are not to look for either sin or righteousness]. And for this reason the saints can use these without impiety, just as Bernard, Franciscus, and other holy men used them. And they used them on account of bodily advantage, that they might have more leisure to teach and to perform other godly offices, and not that the works themselves are, by themselves, works that justify or merit eternal life. Finally, they belong to the class of which Paul says, 1 Tim. 4:8: Bodily exercise profiteth little. And it is credible that in some places there are also at present good men, engaged in the ministry of the Word, who use these observances without wicked opinions [without hypocrisy and with the understanding that they do not regard their monasticism as holiness].
Consider
Finally the Confession concludes its treatment of monastic vows by affirming their relation to the doctrine of justification. We speak the more briefly concerning these subjects, because from those things which we have said above concerning justification, concerning repentance, concerning human traditions, it is sufficiently evident that monastic vows are not a price on account of which the remission of sins and life eternal are granted. And since Christ calls traditions useless services, they are in no way evangelical perfection.
Respond
How does the article’s emphasis on free forgiveness through faith shape your view of Christian service today? In what ways might monastic traditions still tempt us to add human works to Christ’s merit? Where do you see the freedom of the Gospel most clearly at work in your own vocation?
Pray
Gracious Father, we thank You for the clear confession of Your Gospel preserved in the Apology of the Augsburg Confession. Keep us steadfast in the truth that remission of sins is received freely for Christ’s sake through faith alone. Guard our hearts from every human invention that would obscure this promise or burden consciences with unnecessary vows. Grant that in every calling we may grow in the fear of God and confidence in Your mercy. Strengthen Your Church to proclaim this freedom boldly, that many may rest in Christ alone. Through the same Jesus Christ our Lord. Amen.

The Book of Concord · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →