← Curriculum

Eterniseed › Curriculum › 2 Samuel

2 Samuel 13-14 — with Haydock's Catholic Commentary

2 Samuel 13-14Haydock Bible Commentary20 min
Opening
Today we enter the turbulent family drama of King David through the lens of Haydock's Catholic Commentary, a treasured compilation of patristic and medieval insight. These chapters reveal how unchecked passion fractures a royal household and ripples through the kingdom. Haydock gathers the wisdom of earlier Catholic exegetes to illuminate both the human tragedy and the enduring call to justice and mercy. As we listen, may the commentary help us read Scripture with the Church's heart, recognizing God's word as living and active even in stories of sin and sorrow.
Read
Take up 2 Samuel chapters 13 and 14 and read them slowly, perhaps aloud. Notice the cascade of events that begins with private desire and ends in public grief. Allow the narrative to unfold without rushing; let the silences between verses speak as well. When you finish, return to consider how Haydock's Catholic Commentary guides our understanding of these difficult pages.
Study
Haydock opens by describing the circumstances surrounding Amnon's growing obsession. Her. He had seen her on some solemn occasions, when virgins were allowed to go out, well attended. At other times they were so strictly guarded, that Amnon thought it almost impossible to gratify his passion, (Calmet) which made him grow pale. He afterwards feigned himself to be more sickly than he really was, ver. 6. (Haydock) The commentary next identifies the character of Jonadab and the nature of his counsel. A very wise man. That is, a crafty and subtle man: for the counsel he gave on this occasion shews that his wisdom was but carnal and worldly. (Challoner) --- Jonadab seems to be styled Jonathan, chap. xxi. 21. (Calmet) On the aftermath of the crime, Haydock addresses David's response and its limitations. And he, &c. This is not in Hebrew, &c., nor in St. Jerome's version. Josephus and some copies of the Septuagint read it. But the reason here alleged would not suffice to excuse David. (Calmet) --- He might think that, as he had shewn such a bad example himself, he could not with a good grace punish others. (Sanctius) --- This however was requisite, as long as he was king. Whatever faults he might have fallen into, he was not on that account to suffer crimes to remain unpunished; (Haydock) and it is supposed that he testified his resentment to Amnon; (Salien, &c.) though the Scripture be silent thereon. (Haydock) --- Abulensis condemns him for too great remissness. (Menochius) Haydock then turns to Absalom's patient planning and the feast at Baal-hazor. Two. Hebrew, "full years." He waited so long, that he might put his murderous designs in execution with less suspicion. (Haydock) --- Sheep. It was esteemed the best husbandry, "to have fine flocks;" bene pascere: (Cato) even for the nobility. --- Ephraim, or Ephrem; (John xi. 54.) probably near Bethel. (Josephus, Jewish Wars v. 33.) (Calmet) --- Nabal had made a feast on a similar occasion, 1 Kings xxv. Absalom invites his father to avoid suspicion; (Menochius) though he would be glad at his refusing to come, unless perhaps he would not have hesitated to order his brother to be murdered in his very presence, in order to punish both. (Haydock)
Consider
Haydock draws out the wider implications for justice and mercy in the kingdom. Earth; so great was the distress of the people at the absence of their darling prince. (Haydock) --- His death would not bring Amnon to life again. We must not cherish sentiments of eternal enmity. --- Perish. Chaldean, "a just judge cannot take the money of iniquity." Le Clerc, "And cannot the prince (or judge) pardon a man, and devise means to leave his son no longer in exile?" (Calmet) --- Protestants, "neither doth God respect any person; yet doth he devise means, that his banished son be not expelled from him." Let the king imitate this example. (Haydock) The commentary closes by reflecting on the final reconciliation between father and son. Kissed Absalom, and thus was reconciled to his prodigal son, Luke xv. 20. The ungrateful wretch only took occasion, from his father's goodness, to alienate the minds of the people from him, by insinuating that he neglected the welfare of the people. (Haydock)
Respond
Where in my own life have I allowed small compromises to grow into larger disorders? How does the commentary's emphasis on accountability challenge my tendency to excuse those in authority? In what concrete way can I imitate David's eventual longing for reconciliation without neglecting justice?
Pray
O God of mercy and justice, who beholds the hidden sorrows of households torn by sin as in the house of David, heal the wounds we have inflicted on one another and turn our hearts back to you in true repentance. Grant us the grace to seek both righteousness and reconciliation, never one without the other, through the intercession of the Blessed Virgin Mary and all the saints. We ask this through Christ our Lord. Amen.

Haydock Bible Commentary · Public domain

Source & Verification

The quotations here are drawn from a public-domain edition, and each is mechanically verified to be an exact substring of the source text.

See the original, our full translation, and the review →